Wasn't he Trapper John on M*A*S*H?
2023 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft
- Thread starter TENACIOUS
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Pick 16 - St Kilda - Ollie Murphy
Sorry for the delay I honestly was very torn on this pick. I've re-written my post 3 times as I went back and forth between the two local Sandy boys here Ollie Murphy and Charlie Edwards. I've ultimately gone for the rarer commodity KPD.
Wilkie, Cordy and Howard will all be in front of Ollie to start with however the Saints just delisted Tom Highmore and Oscar Adams who were their KPD depth so it does fit a need also. He'll fit in nicely in their VFL setup while he gets his body ready for the rigours of AFL.
Elite runner for his size, did the 2km time trial in sub 6:30 from what I believe.
Won the Vic Metro MVP, shutting down the best KPF (and best player imo) in the draft Jed Walters at one stage.
No go home factor and a lifelong saints fan so you'll know you get every bit out of him also.
Ninja Worrier with Adelaide's first pick up next.
Sorry for the delay I honestly was very torn on this pick. I've re-written my post 3 times as I went back and forth between the two local Sandy boys here Ollie Murphy and Charlie Edwards. I've ultimately gone for the rarer commodity KPD.
Wilkie, Cordy and Howard will all be in front of Ollie to start with however the Saints just delisted Tom Highmore and Oscar Adams who were their KPD depth so it does fit a need also. He'll fit in nicely in their VFL setup while he gets his body ready for the rigours of AFL.
Elite runner for his size, did the 2km time trial in sub 6:30 from what I believe.
Won the Vic Metro MVP, shutting down the best KPF (and best player imo) in the draft Jed Walters at one stage.
No go home factor and a lifelong saints fan so you'll know you get every bit out of him also.
Ninja Worrier with Adelaide's first pick up next.
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,948
- 14,898
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #79
Hawks Match
Pick 17 - Hawthorn - Will McCabe - Height: 197cm - Weight: 86kg - D.O.B: 29-09-2005
McCabe's aerial ability is arguably his most eye-catching trait, and one which strongly demonstrates his athleticism. At 197cm, he has good range and reach, but also leaps at the ball stylishly and isn't afraid to attack the contest. While applicable at either end of the field, it's an attribute he uses most prominently when intercepting down back. McCabe reads the play well and has good toe off the mark to get to the ball first, or close in on other contests as the third man up. He averaged 5.9 marks and 6.1 intercepts per his nine SANFL Under 18 games this season, highlighting his ability to cut off opposition attacks via the aerial route.
Another aspect of McCabe's strong athletic profile is his pace - with the ball. He can run-and-carry like few players his size, taking off on the rebound and often showing opponents a clean set of cleats. He also has a good enough tank to make such plays repeatable and seems to enjoy taking the game on. In those instances, he puts speed on the ball and acts as a dual-threat with his ability to turn defence (intercepting) into attack (rebounding). Compounding his hurt factor, McCabe is also a handy field kick and ran at 81 per cent efficiency at Under 18s level, opting to kick 67 per cent of the time from his average 21.8 disposals.
STRENGTHS:
- Aerial ability
- Intercept marking
- Speed
- Upside
- Versatility
- Vertical leap
IMPROVEMENTS:
- One-on-one defending
- Strength
Credit
Will McCabe Draft Profile
Hawthorn father-son prospect Will McCabe is a versatile tall with terrific speed and aerial ability, projecting as a first round talent.
central.rookieme.com
Ninja Worrier
Last edited:
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Crows bid on Jordan Croft Coona Blues
Absolutely matched.
Pick 18 - Western Bulldogs - Jordan Croft - VIC Metro/Calder Canons - 200cm - 81kg
Outside of Walter, he is the best genuine key forward in the draft. With his slight frame has a number of years development before becoming an AFL key forward, but has all of the pre requisites.
The ridiculous amount of young, ultra tall talent the Bulldogs have acquired through father/son rules is “criminal”. Added to NGA young gun Jamarra Ugle-Hagan and mercurial Aaron Naughton it will be intriguing how the are all jammed in to the side.
On under age showings CROFT shapes as a genuine forward first option. (For the record, I believe Naughton has to go BACK in a couple of years. Ugle-Hagan the focal point, Darcy forward/ruck and Croft developing while an aging Bont spends significant time in the front half. If the keep English through the free agency threat, it will be scary)
Well done on the bid Ninja, think it may be a few too late
Ninja Worrier back to you.
Last edited:
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Hmm, have to do some thorough assessment for the Blues’ pick now. So many options, some speculative, some “vanilla”. Some needs and some will be best available. It really is a conundrum which way to go.
Can somebody do the mathematics regarding the draft pick cost of the various bid matches thus far? We need to recalibrate very soon to confirm pick order. TENACIOUS apologies, you are calculating points. Just need confirmation of revised order.
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Sorry Coona Blues was trying to get the crows a tall for balance but when the bids failed I just went to my best available
As you should. No apologies necessary. Tholstrup was just the “easy” pick if he lasted. The way this has transpired, I have a left field option lined up.
Pick 19 - North Melbourne
Archer Reid Key Forward
North now have a glut of mid/runners. Need to add some size. Ollie Murphy would be the target but he is gone
This is more about needs than best player available.
Archer is the best KPP left in the draft. At 203cm has the size just now to develop. For mine he is still very raw and has things to work on. Marking is good and agility good for his size. Reads the ball well in the air so the basics are there to be a very good player. Kicking needs work
Has potential to develop into a Fwd/2nd Ruck type
Will need time but with Larkey CCJ Comben Edwards Zurharr on Norths list he has time to develop
JuddgementDay you're up!
Archer Reid Key Forward
North now have a glut of mid/runners. Need to add some size. Ollie Murphy would be the target but he is gone
This is more about needs than best player available.
Archer is the best KPP left in the draft. At 203cm has the size just now to develop. For mine he is still very raw and has things to work on. Marking is good and agility good for his size. Reads the ball well in the air so the basics are there to be a very good player. Kicking needs work
Has potential to develop into a Fwd/2nd Ruck type
Will need time but with Larkey CCJ Comben Edwards Zurharr on Norths list he has time to develop
JuddgementDay you're up!
JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
Pick 20 GWS - Mitch Edwards
Ruck 206cm/88kg
With GWS' balanced list, they've got time to invest into the future.
After securing a KPD, they can now lock in a future ruckman.
Mitch Edwards is tall and mobile, has excellent ruck craft and is quite skilful.
He's a modern day ruckman, taking good contested marks around the ground, and can fill in at both ends of the ground.
Ninja Worrier got the player I wanted.
Over to you Soapy V
Ruck 206cm/88kg
With GWS' balanced list, they've got time to invest into the future.
After securing a KPD, they can now lock in a future ruckman.
Mitch Edwards is tall and mobile, has excellent ruck craft and is quite skilful.
He's a modern day ruckman, taking good contested marks around the ground, and can fill in at both ends of the ground.
Ninja Worrier got the player I wanted.
Over to you Soapy V
Last edited:
Pick 21 - North Melbourne
Harry DeMattia Mid/Fwd
Would have liked another KPP but nothing stood out and this kid was too good to pass up
He has what Clarko loves. Running left footer with leg speed who can play Mid/Fwd or off HB.
Can win his own ball and hit targets. Could become a bit of a cult figure and North need these types
Harry DeMattia Mid/Fwd
Would have liked another KPP but nothing stood out and this kid was too good to pass up
He has what Clarko loves. Running left footer with leg speed who can play Mid/Fwd or off HB.
Can win his own ball and hit targets. Could become a bit of a cult figure and North need these types
Pick 22 - North Melbourne
Tew Jiath - Defender
Another player with run and dash. Will add to North's defence. Brother of CJ who Clarko coached and he knows the family.
Lot's of upside and improvement to come. I like that he hits targets and is a one grab mark
North have now covered so much. Their list looks awesome for 2028
Blugazi You're up
Tew Jiath - Defender
Another player with run and dash. Will add to North's defence. Brother of CJ who Clarko coached and he knows the family.
Lot's of upside and improvement to come. I like that he hits targets and is a one grab mark
North have now covered so much. Their list looks awesome for 2028
Blugazi You're up
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,948
- 14,898
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #90
order is in the first post.
2023 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft
Hi Everybody, With the draft just a few weeks away, it's time to get Tenacious's Annual Carlton Board 2023 Phantom Draft going again... Usual phantom draft rules applies: 1) Everyone is welcome to put their hand up to participate, but this is a commitment. If you can't commit to seeing this...
www.bigfooty.com
Yeah, be nice if a mod could sticky the rolling order to each page so we have a quick reference.order is in the first post.
2023 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft
Hi Everybody, With the draft just a few weeks away, it's time to get Tenacious's Annual Carlton Board 2023 Phantom Draft going again... Usual phantom draft rules applies: 1) Everyone is welcome to put their hand up to participate, but this is a commitment. If you can't commit to seeing this...
The evenness of this draft is “epic”.
One mooted first rounder by Draft Central left in rebounding half back Roberts, although sneaky ranges added to
Collard, Edwards, Stevens and Green.
Logjam of 25-40 rated Simpson, Schoenmaker, Sanchez, Graham, Delean, Goad, Gothard, Hastie, Lual, and Moir.
I don’t necessarily agree with all of their ratings from 30 suggesting Zakostelsky, Morris, Cleary, Freijah, Lloyd. For mine they have SA captain Patton, O’Driscoll, McAuliffe and Dawson too low, but it is very even and very subjective.
The glaring absence is “silk”. The only top notch distributors from that list are Moir, Schoenmaker and maybe Patton and Simpson. A handful are adequate to good. The point of difference players pretty much all have some queries attached.
One mooted first rounder by Draft Central left in rebounding half back Roberts, although sneaky ranges added to
Collard, Edwards, Stevens and Green.
Logjam of 25-40 rated Simpson, Schoenmaker, Sanchez, Graham, Delean, Goad, Gothard, Hastie, Lual, and Moir.
I don’t necessarily agree with all of their ratings from 30 suggesting Zakostelsky, Morris, Cleary, Freijah, Lloyd. For mine they have SA captain Patton, O’Driscoll, McAuliffe and Dawson too low, but it is very even and very subjective.
The glaring absence is “silk”. The only top notch distributors from that list are Moir, Schoenmaker and maybe Patton and Simpson. A handful are adequate to good. The point of difference players pretty much all have some queries attached.
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Torrent has a great left peg
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
You eedjit
- Jul 13, 2018
- 1,158
- 2,653
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 26,470
- 63,600
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Hope you didn't get goaded into that pick.
No pressure CB…but if Charlie Edwards is on the table you will have Arrow on tenterhooks.
Pick 26 - St Kilda - Charlie Edwards
Bendigo boy who has shot up the ranking in the past few months. Extremely high ceiling, think potentially Bontempelli.
Eyed him off at my previous pick also so extremely happy he's still available here. Saints just need game breakers and Charlie is that.
Great runner also for his size. 2km in sub 6.30.
central.rookieme.com
Next pick Blooz Coona Blues
(sorry)
Bendigo boy who has shot up the ranking in the past few months. Extremely high ceiling, think potentially Bontempelli.
Eyed him off at my previous pick also so extremely happy he's still available here. Saints just need game breakers and Charlie is that.
Great runner also for his size. 2km in sub 6.30.
Charlie Edwards Draft Profile
Sandringham Dragons midfielder Charlie Edwards is one of this year's great draft bolters, having produced a sparkling end to the season.
central.rookieme.com
Next pick Blooz Coona Blues
(sorry)
