2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Collingwood	Tim Membrey
2	Carlton	Ethan Phillips	Soapy V
3	Greater Western Sydney	Ben Paton	bradfisher14
4	Geelong	Jack Martin	Coona Blues
5	Brisbane	Sam Day	Sheephead
6	Collingwood	Adam Tomlinson	Bamboo Harvester
7	Carlton	Coby Burgiel	Soapy V

Rookie Draft

Pick	Club	Player	Poster
1	Richmond	Josh Dolan	Bletch
2	North Melbourne	Nash King	Blue and Silver
3	West Coast	Pass	TerryWallet
4	Adelaide	Lucas Impey	GoBlues!
5	Melbourne	Rhys Unwin	Blugazi
6	Gold Coast	Sam Durdin
7	St Kilda	Brad Crouch	Ninja Worrier
8	Essendon	Gabriel Stumpf	TENACIOUS
9	Fremantle	Noah Cumberland	WalshistheGOAT
10	Collingwood	Will Hayes	Bamboo Harvester
11	Carlton	Liam McMahon	soapy
12	Western Bulldogs	Jacob Newton	Coona Blues
13	Hawthorn	Jack Gunston
14	Greater Western Sydney	Josh Fahey	bradfisher14
15	Geelong	Lachlan Blackiston	Coona Blues
16	Port Adelaide	Charlie West	Pablito
17	Sydney	Ollie Warburton	Wickzki
18	Brisbane	Darragh Joyce	Sheephead
19	Richmond	Pass	Bletch
20	North Melbourne	Riley Bice	Blue and Silver
21	Adelaide	Pass	GoBlues!
22	Melbourne	Sam Toner	Blugazi
23	Gold Coast	Pass
24	St Kilda *	Lennox Hoffman	Ninja Worrier
25	Essendon	Waylon Davies-Motlop	TENACIOUS
26	Fremantle	Pass	WalshistheGOAT
27	Collingwood	Oleg Markov	Bamboo Harvester
28	Carlton	Asher Eastham	Soapy V
29	Western Bulldogs	Max Knobel	Coona Blues
30	Hawthorn	Pass
31	Greater Western Sydney	Lachie Keeffe	bradfisher14
32	Geelong	Marcus Herbert	Coona Blues
33	Port Adelaide		Pablito
34	Sydney	Joel Hammling	Wickzki
35	Brisbane	Darcy Craven	Sheephead
36	North Melbourne	Toby Pink	Blue and Silver
37	Essendon		TENACIOUS
38	Collingwood	Ash Johnson	Bamboo Harvester
39	Carlton *	Lucas Camporeale	Soapy V
40	Greater Western Sydney	Jacob Wehr	bradfisher14
41	North Melbourne *	River Stevens	Blue and Silver
42	Greater Western Sydney *	Logan Smith	bradfisher14
43	Essendon		TENACIOUS
44	Sydney	Aaron Francis	Wickzki

Soapy V · Oct 30, 2024

Stamos said:
That's only 34 on the Senior List, you have to have 36 as a minimum.

I know. There will be 2 x Rookies and we will be trialing people over pre season

Stamos · Oct 30, 2024

Soapy V said:
I know. There will be 2 x Rookies and we will be trialing people over pre season

That's still too few, and any SSP players will go to the Rookie List, not the Senior List.

Soapy V · Oct 30, 2024

Stamos said:
That's still too few, and any SSP players will go to the Rookie List, not the Senior List.

DFA's we sign up

By my numbers we have 34 players plus Monahan and Duffy

We will pick 2-3 players during Draft. That is 36-37. Two rookies is 38-39 then we can sign DFA's (which we will) or SSPs

Is that right?

Stamos · Oct 30, 2024

Soapy V said:
DFA's we sign up

For the purpose of this Phantom Draft, which doesn't have a DFA period, why don't you take the 2 DFAs you want in the PSD?

TENACIOUS · Oct 30, 2024

Soapy V said:
Pass PSD

Will add a rookie or two

Hi Soapy you’ll need to pick 2.

Minimum senior list number is 36 and Carlton has 34, you can choose from undrafted players or DFA.

And Carlton has 3 picks in the rookie draft. As there is no SSP period in the phantom.

You can pick anyone if you don’t want to use those that you’d know we’re going to take.

Soapy V · Oct 30, 2024

TENACIOUS said:
Hi Soapy you’ll need to pick 2.

Minimum senior list number is 36 and Carlton has 34, you can choose from undrafted players or DFA.

And Carlton has 3 picks in the rookie draft. As there is no SSP period in the phantom.

You can pick anyone if you don’t want to use those that you’d know we’re going to take.

I think we will add three players in draft. Pick 3, Ben Campo and another player

I expect at least one tall added as a DFA and maybe another player

That's 38 or 39

One rookie spot will be Lucas Camporeale (40)

Sam Durdin & Matt Carroll will be given pre season to try and prove fitness for a rookie spot

Sheephead · Oct 30, 2024

Aren’t we talking about this Mock draft. Mock as in, this is what I would do? So we just pick players so this thing can be completed???

Stamos · Oct 30, 2024

Soapy V said:
I think we will add three players in draft. Pick 3, Ben Campo and another player

I expect at least one tall added as a DFA and maybe another player

That's 38 or 39

One rookie spot will be Lucas Camporeale (40)

Sam Durdin & Matt Carroll will be given pre season to try and prove fitness for a rookie spot

Your numbers are wrong.
If we pick 3 in the ND, AND a DFA (/PSD) AND another player (PSD) to make 37, that would be taking 5.
But you only took 2?

TENACIOUS · Oct 30, 2024

With the recent batch of delistings.

Please let me know if you intend on using the PSD and how many picks you have.

Adelaide: GoBlues!
Brisbane: Sheephead
Carlton: Soapy V
Collingwood: Bamboo Harvester
Essendon: TENACIOUS
Fremantle: WalshistheGOAT
Geelong: Coona Blues
Gold Coast: Auto Match
GWS: bradfisher14
Hawthorn: TerryWallet
Melbourne: Blugazi
North Melbourne: Blue and Silver
Port Adelaide: Pablito
Richmond: Bletch
St Kilda: Ninja Worrier
Sydney: Wickzki
West Coast: TerryWallet
Western Bulldogs: Coona Blues

TENACIOUS · Oct 30, 2024

Soapy V said:
I think we will add three players in draft. Pick 3, Ben Campo and another player

I expect at least one tall added as a DFA and maybe another player

That's 38 or 39

One rookie spot will be Lucas Camporeale (40)

Sam Durdin & Matt Carroll will be given pre season to try and prove fitness for a rookie spot

AFL rules state that each club has 42 players on their list, consisting of Senior Players and Rookies.

Plus the additional option of 2x additional Cat B rookies. Making the lid 44 players.

Senior List.
Must be between 36 and 38 players.

Carlton currently have 34 players, (including Hayes, Boyd & your drafted players)
As this is a phantom draft and we don’t have the luxury of train on players, we are filling all the lists now.
You passed in the draft and will need to fill the remaining 2 senior spots in the PSD.

Rookie List
Must be between 4-6 players

Carlton currently have 3 players, (including Lord) You’ll need to pick 3 players here.
As this is a phantom draft and we don’t have the luxury of train on players, we are filling all the lists now.

For the PSD and Rookie draft you can pick from the undrafted players or DFAs. Doesn’t need to have anything to do with who Carlton are looking at. Only who you think is best.

Hold off on your picks until we finalise the PSD order with all the additional delistings.

Sheephead · Oct 30, 2024

Hey T. I’ll be taking Sam Day in the PSD. Not sure how many list spots that leaves Brisbane with. Can you or one of the crew help a brother out?

bradfisher14 · Oct 31, 2024

GWS will take Ben Paton in PSD if available.

Jimmae · Oct 31, 2024

bradfisher14 said:
GWS will take Ben Paton in PSD if available.

Let's cross live now to Ben's reaction:

TENACIOUS · Oct 31, 2024

That’s enough time to check list numbers Soapy V Carlton are up.

Also does anyone want to put up their hand for Hawthorn and Gold Coast in the rookie draft

Coona Blues · Oct 31, 2024

TENACIOUS said:
That’s enough time to check list numbers Soapy V Carlton are up.

Also does anyone want to put up their hand for Hawthorn and Gold Coast in the rookie draft

Most of the rookie draft will be clubs re-rookieing “delisted” players in reality. Nit sure it has much relevance TBH

Soapy V · Nov 1, 2024

Carlton will go with Ethan Phillips for first pick in PSD

Coona Blues · Nov 1, 2024

TENACIOUS said:
Understand you can too. Your up

Well we had better add Jack Martin then.

Sheephead

Sheephead · Nov 1, 2024

It’s a beautiful day, Sam Day in fact. Lock him in T.

Back to Soapy I think.

Soapy V · Nov 1, 2024

Bit left field but I’m going

Coby Burgiel

Mid/fwd that has some leg speed. Victorian and young who may mature after a couple of tough years at West Coast in a bad side

Time for Rookie Draft. Carlton will take Lucas Camporeale with our pick nominated as a F/S

TENACIOUS · Nov 1, 2024

That’s the MSD run and done.

Bletch Richmond are up with the first pick in the rookie Draft.

When everyone’s rookie lists are full let me know.

Ninja Worrier · Nov 1, 2024

Saints will prelist NGA player Lennox Hoffman with their last rookie pick and have committed to rookie Brad Crouch

Blue and Silver · Nov 1, 2024

If I have my count correct for North:

Out 11 players, 1 committed to re-rookie (Pink)

In 4 trade (Daniel, Parker, Konstanty, Darling) 3 ND ( Tauru, Shanahan, Sulzberger)

4 spots remaining.

River Stevens F/S nominated will be added as a rookie pre Rookie Draft

2 spots for rookies with the last to be used on Pink, unless someone takes him

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

GoBlues! · Nov 2, 2024

Adelaide has:

6 players out - Lachlan Gollant (delisted), Will Hamill (delisted), Elliott Himmelberg (free agent, Gold Coast), Ned McHenry (delisted), Patrick Parnell (delisted), Rory Sloane (retired).

3 players traded in - Isaac Cumming, Alex Neal-Bullen, James Peatling.

2 selected in ND - Draper, Welsh.

Leaves 1 spot open for Rookie selection.

Wickzki · Nov 2, 2024

Sydney has:

9 players out

Delisted: Harry Arnold, Aaron Francis, Joel Hamling, Jaiden Magor, Lachlan McAndrew, Cooper Vickery

Traded: Jacob Konstanty, Luke Parker

Retired: Sam Reid

4 players in

Draft: Harry Armstrong, Jesse Dattoli, Matt Whitlock, Luke Urquhart

Reported to be interested in rookie-ing Francis and/or Hamling.

3 to 5 list combined list places seems excessive. Am I missing something?

Bletch · Nov 2, 2024

Richmond Rookie Draft pick 1: Josh Dolan

Richmond done.

Fantasy Footy leagues open! Sign up now for 2025.

2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Club Legend

Not actually Brad Fisher

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Director of Coaching

Brownlow Medallist

Director of Coaching

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Definitely Sam MacLure.

Premium Platinum

2024 (Tenacious) Annual Carlton Board Phantom Draft

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account