List Mgmt. 2024 Draft - Post Trade Period Edition

[tigerfan1961]

It’s likely top 5 and definitely top 10. Gives us plenty of flexibility if a certain eagle bails a year early to play with his vic country mates

In Blair I fully trust

 

[THE_GUN]

Nah, 6 & 24 should be the deal for 2, means we're giving 11 for F1, not worth it

#6 & #24 is way unders for #2
I see Norths F1 as a pick between #5-#7 next year

 

[Danog]

I am starting to think this way also.
Nth desperate for another first round pick.
Richmond are not desperate for pick 2.
Tauru should be there at pick 10.
So Richmond should have a take it or leave approach and offer 10 & 18 for pick 2.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Feel like Saints would take Tauru

 

[4tune8]

1 Lalor
7 Jagga
12 Travaglia
14 Armstrong
22 Trainor
24 Dodson
28 Dattoli

Would settle for that

Reckon it'll be a fair bit different to that, I really don't like Travaglia, Armstrong, Trainor and Dodson at those picks, there'll be a better mix come draft night. Saints could take Travaglia & Armstrong, leaving Lindsay, Allan, Hotton, Berry for us.

 

[prodigy]

If I'm going to plant my flag to any phantom draft/form guide it's always going to be Cal Twomey's.
It's been a rare occasion where he misses a top 10 selection.

#itsFOSoclock

 

[THE_GUN]

Reckon it'll be a fair bit different to that, I really don't like Travaglia, Armstrong, Trainor and Dodson at those picks, there'll be a better mix come draft night. Saints could take Travaglia & Armstrong, leaving Lindsay, Allan, Hotton, Berry for us.

Saints will be dreaming of Smillie & Armstrong double ( 7 & 8 )
Melbourne will be looking at Langford & Reid ( 5 & 9 )
Carlton & Adelaide Jagga & Draper if we dont take Jagga
Norf will be FOS / Tauru

 

[THE_GUN]

If I'm going to plant my flag to any phantom draft/form guide it's always going to be Cal Twomey's.
It's been a rare occasion where he misses a top 10 selection.

#itsFOSoclock

True and i agree
But his Phantom will depend on where the picks sit as his info comes from managers and Clubs
His Ranking will change


He usually drops the phantom the day before and updates the morning of the draft

 

[4tune8]

#6 & #24 is way unders for #2
I see Norths F1 as a pick between #5-#7 next year

IMO we hold the whip hand here, 6 & 23 should be our one and only offer.

I certainly wouldn't give up 11 this year, North shopped F1 & F2 for 13.

 

[Coach_Required]

1 Lalor
7 Jagga
12 Travaglia
14 Armstrong
22 Trainor
24 Dodson
28 Dattoli

Would settle for that

I'd take FOS at 1, but the rest would be great if true.

 

[archer the tiger]

Why would they trade all their members? The club would fold

They’re gunna get em back when they’re in their window!

 

[richoatthedisco]

Yep, didn’t think of it that way but even now, 18 for their F1 in a weaker draft. Would need to really think about it as we could still get a very very good player at 18

We're trading Norf's F1 for Cadman.

 

[Smoocher]

Its such a risky play.

I wouldnt offer any more than 6,18,24, even then, I dont like it for us

So you'd knock back pick 2 this year and a top 4 pick next year. Even if North win 6 or 7 games it leaves them in bottom 4 territory.

I'd say the deal for those picks would be for nothing less than 6,11 18/23.

North's future first is more valuable than any other teams other than maybe west coast but they will be using there 1st for Warner.

The other bottom teams from this year have the potential to make the 8.



Sent from my SM-A156E using Tapatalk

 

[tiger_tough]

Its such a risky play.

I wouldnt offer any more than 6,18,24, even then, I dont like it for us

I'd do that deal every day of the week. 6 and 18 for 2 is fine. 24 for an all but guaranteed top 6 pick? no dramas.

 

[THE_GUN]

IMO we hold the whip hand here, 6 & 23 should be our one and only offer.

I certainly wouldn't give up 11 this year, North shopped F1 & F2 for 13.

I think it was F1 for #13 plus they wanted a late pick as well but GC were not interested in that
#6 + #18 is fair value for pick #2 imo but hey if its 6 +23 im not complaining but doubt that happens if we are serious about getting #2

 

[blaisee]

Cal said he would not trade 6 and 18 for 2

 

[richoatthedisco]

So you'd knock back pick 2 this year and a top 4 pick next year. Even if North win 6 or 7 games it leaves them in bottom 4 territory.

I'd say the deal for those picks would be for nothing less than 6,11 18/23.

North's future first is more valuable than any other teams other than maybe west coast but they will be using there 1st for Warner.

The other bottom teams from this year have the potential to make the 8.



Sent from my SM-A156E using Tapatalk

10 & 11 back to back are too valuable to us, especially being at the back end of the second tier of players in this draft.

If Norf are talking to us about trading their F1 it's because they can't get a pick better than 18 for it.

 

[THE_GUN]

So you'd knock back pick 2 this year and a top 4 pick next year. Even if North win 6 or 7 games it leaves them in bottom 4 territory.

I'd say the deal for those picks would be for nothing less than 6,11 18/23.

North's future first is more valuable than any other teams other than maybe west coast but they will be using there 1st for Warner.

The other bottom teams from this year have the potential to make the 8.



Sent from my SM-A156E using Tapatalk

6 , 11 , 23 would be the max i would pay

have to look at it this way , There are no teams that have the picks that want to trade out of this years draft into next year and certainly no team that has a pick before GWS picks 15,16,21 and they want to trade up into this draft not trade out into this year so the there are not many takers.
If Richmond give up #11 for your F1 then they will pay less for your #2 this year so #6 , #11 , #23 would be best from Richmond imo.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Cal said he would not trade 6 and 18 for 2

No he didn't. He said that's the most he would give, and that there's no need for us to give more.

6 & 23 it is.

 

[richoatthedisco]

6 , 11 , 23 would be the max i would pay

have to look at it this way , There are no teams that have the picks that want to trade out of this years draft into next year and certainly no team that has a pick before GWS picks 15,16,21 and they want to trade up into this draft not trade out into this year so the there are not many takers.
If Richmond give up #11 for your F1 then they will pay less for your #2 this year so #6 , #11 , #23 would be best from Richmond imo.

Bring cash. No IOUs.

 

[THE_GUN]

Bring cash

Nah i'll transfer into account

I dont trust facebook market place

 

[noobermensch]

Lots of requests recently for more vision of Sam Lalor. Given his injury restricted 2024 season we have to go back to 2023 when he was a bottom ager. Here we see him putting in a remarkably powerful game as an inside midfielder given he's a year younger than most of his opponents, bulldozing through stoppage or crunching in with tackling pressure. He found plenty of the footy, but was uncharacteristically a bit variable with his disposal.

 

[THE_GUN]

Lots of requests recently for more vision of Sam Lalor. Given his injury restricted 2024 season we have to go back to 2023 when he was a bottom ager. Here we see him putting in a remarkably powerful game as an inside midfielder given he's a year younger than most of his opponents, bulldozing through stoppage or crunching in with tackling pressure. He found plenty of the footy, but was uncharacteristically a bit variable with his disposal.

@BlairHartley

 

[prodigy]

Cal said he would not trade 6 and 18 for 2

That's a bald face lie as I just watched Gettable and he said he wouldn't do any more than 6 and 18 for 2. Which means he would do 6 and 18 for 2.

 

[THE_GUN]

That's a bald face lie as I just watched Gettable and he said he wouldn't do any more than 6 and 18 for 2. Which means he would do 6 and 18 for 2.

And really thats exactly what the value is

I mentioned thses 2 picks when we got the bolton trade done as the trade as it just felt right

 

[4tune8]

I think it was F1 for #13 plus they wanted a late pick as well but GC were not interested in that
#6 + #18 is fair value for pick #2 imo but hey if its 6 +23 im not complaining but doubt that happens if we are serious about getting #2

This was what was being offered for 13....


EVERY CLUB’S OFFER FOR PICK 13:

COLLINGWOOD - John Noble + Future 1st

HAWTHORN - Future 1st + Future 2nd
NORTH MELBOURNE - Future 1st + ?

ST KILDA - Future 1st + Future 2nd

SYDNEY - Pick 19 + 22