List Mgmt. 2024 Draft - Post Trade Period Edition

[KrispyKreme]

You are speaking theoretically, when these decisions are to be made by people with an intimate knowledge of the players available this year and next year

Pick 10 this year is a better player than Pick 5 most years, this is the consensus

You don't have to agree with it, but it is what it is

Nah, so from what I’ve heard the draft is deep it just means pick from 1-30 are good. But most drafts are just very top heavy. Ie top 1-5/8 are extremely/very good

 

[THE_GUN]

So many clubs have improved this off season. You're not going to find many that have gone backwards. North has natural improvement in them, but I don't see them climbing out of the bottom 4 when they almost finished last again this season.

I think they will improve and have them at 7-9 wins

Now where that puts them on the ladder is anybody's guess

 

[prodigy]

Pick 10 this year is a better player than Pick 5 most years, this is the consensus

You're also theoretically speaking here aren't you?
We don't know what kind of player pick 10 will be this year in an AFL system.

You're just trying to manipulate the discussion in a certain way but I'm familiar with these parlour tricks.

 

[KrispyKreme]

You're also theoretically speaking here aren't you?
We don't know what kind of player pick 10 will be this year in an AFL system.

You're just trying to manipulate the discussion in a certain way but I'm familiar with these parlour tricks.

This.

I think people are to lost in the whole deep draft they are forgetting most years are very top heavy.. ie 2021 and 2022 drafts

 

[THE_GUN]

You are speaking theoretically, when these decisions are to be made by people with an intimate knowledge of the players available this year and next year

Pick 10 this year is a better player than Pick 5 most years, this is the consensus

You don't have to agree with it, but it is what it is

But how do we know this ?
The top Tier is effectively 6-7 players in this years draft maybe 8 at the best depending on which players get taken due to need like Tauru/Armstrong then you get into the next tier of players like Allan , Travaglia , Shannahan

Also what if the NorF F1 actually ends up being a pick #3-#5 and some of the non academy kids develop like Lalor , Jagga and even Tauru ? Maybe a KPF bolts up the charts from obscurity to become a Roughead/Franklin type

Its 100% worth the trade to get #2 this year

 

[Spanish_Fly]

Nah I'd rather just pick the players we have at 1 and 2 in the order as they're likely the best ones for us.

But hey, that's just me.

You keep posting as if there’s no opportunity cost to trading up to 2. What if we have Smillie at 3 on our board and think it’s almost certain we get him at 6? Would we trade 3 and 18 for 2? Technically we are trading pick 6 but if the player we would get at 6 is rated higher by us then we are trading that better pick.

You also need to allow for the fact that recruiting is an imperfect science, even more so in this draft where some have Draper at 2 and some at 7. Odds are our rankings won’t be correct and the best option may be to stack the odds in our favor by weight of numbers.

Pick 11 could easily turn out the best player in this draft, it’s not highly unlikely that 6, 10 & 11 all are better players than pick 1 in this draft. It’s not a draft with 2-3 obvious standouts hence the apprehension giving up valuable draft capital.

 

[UpTheGutz]

FOS could play the Jaidyn Stephenson

2

Jaidyn Stephenson

Age

25

Ht

189cm

Wt

79kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.2

3star

K

8.8

3star

HB

4.4

3star

M

4.7

4star

T

2.6

4star

G

1.5

5star

D

11.0

3star

K

6.7

3star

HB

4.3

3star

M

3.5

3star

T

2.7

4star

G

1.2

5star

D

12.6

4star

K

8.0

3star

HB

4.6

4star

M

3.4

4star

T

3.4

5star

G

1.4

5star

role at North. Probably straight away

 

[KrispyKreme]

FOS could play the Jaidyn Stephenson role at North. Probably straight away

What about Jagga

 

[Mr Magic]

I have a question

at the moment we have 8 picks


I think someone said we have 8 spots on our list available, senior spots?


So if had 9 picks at some point, via a trade, do we lose the last pick?? unless we trade out another pick for a future as part of the trade???

is this the correct interpretation of current situation.

I think trading for picks stops in early november before draft day/night?

 

[Oldmanuncle]

Then watch him more and understand

Xavier,Chargers,VicC or Academy?
Name the game he's been dominant from the centre bounce.

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

 

[Al Heimer]

Richmond trades for Norfs F1 and next year the AFL and umpires suck them off big enough to finish mid table.

Any other club trades for Norfs F1 and they will finish bottom 3.

On SM-A426B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[KrispyKreme]

Xavier,Chargers,VicC or Academy?
Name the game he's been dominant from the centre bounce.

Chargers, vic country and academy and futures. Not sure about Xavier. But there is footage of him online buddy. I’m not concerned on 18 touches this year especially injury riddled. He’s a gun, he’s a hard worker can play outside/inside, major threat inside 50. Creates score involvements. Will take 1-2 years to get going but will be an extremely damaging midfielder. Think Isaac Heeney where every possession is crucial.

 

[Mr Magic]

i am still leaning at the moment to keeping pick 1 and pick 6

pick 1 probably Sam Lalor, pick 6, whoever slips.

picks 10 and 11, depends on who is there and bids with other clubs wanting to come up will be thick and fast

 

[Wacky Tiger]

FOS could play the Jaidyn Stephenson role at North. Probably straight away

Whats that? VFL?

 

[LOZWILDA]

- No F/S or academy picks
1-Richmond -Lalor
2-NTH- Tauru
3-Carlton- FOS
4-Adelaide- Draper
5-Melbourne- Langford
6- Richmond- Smith
7- Stkilda- Smillie
8- Stkilda- Reid
9- Melbourne- Lindsey
10- Richmond- Armstrong
11- Richmond- Travaglia
12- WC- Allan
13- Port- Gerryn
14- Freo- Hotton
15- GWS- Berry
16- GWS- Shanahan
17- Bulldogs- Trainor
18- Richmond- JWhitlock
19- Sydney- Davis
20- NTH- MWhitlock -traded from Richmond for future First
21- GWS- Haynes
22- Sydney- Dodson
23- Richmond-Hanniford
24- Richmond- future first
Can not see too many or any team trading out of this years draft.
Next years draft heavily compromised by academy picks.
North will be desperate to get back in this draft more so now that Stevenson has retired.





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[UpTheGutz]

What about Jagga

Jagga more a CB/ clearance king guy (vs fwd/mid), though I suppose he’d likely also do some time outside to start. Our CB clearances were absolutely dreadful this year, so there’re positions vacant.

North do have a few of those, especially if Daniel lets McKercher graduate up the ground, Sheezel gets set in the middle & presuming Parker spends proper minutes in the guts.

 

[KrispyKreme]

Jagga more a CB/ clearance king guy (vs fwd/mid), though I suppose he’d likely also do some time outside to start. Our CB clearances were absolutely dreadful this year, so there’re positions vacant.

North do have a few of those, especially if Daniel lets McKercher graduate up the ground, Sheezel gets set in the middle & presuming Parker spends proper minutes in the guts.

North want Jagga. They scream about using pick 2 on him ion there draft board

 

[Mr Magic]

- No F/S or academy picks
1-Richmond -Lalor
2-NTH- Tauru
3-Carlton- FOS
4-Adelaide- Draper
5-Melbourne- Langford
6- Richmond- Smith
7- Stkilda- Smillie
8- Stkilda- Reid
9- Melbourne- Lindsey
10- Richmond- Armstrong
11- Richmond- Travaglia
12- WC- Allan
13- Port- Gerryn
14- Freo- Hotton
15- GWS- Berry
16- GWS- Shanahan
17- Bulldogs- Trainor
18- Richmond- JWhitlock
19- Sydney- Davis
20- NTH- MWhitlock -traded from Richmond for future First
21- GWS- Haynes
22- Sydney- Dodson
23- Richmond-Hanniford
24- Richmond- future first
Can not see too many or any team trading out of this years draft.
Next years draft heavily compromised by academy picks.
North will be desperate to get back in this draft more so now that Stevenson has retired.





Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

in this sceanrio, RFC is crazy trading up with pick 6 for 2 because we get one of Smith or Smillie or another if we keep 6.

If I am RFC I am thinking with our later picks can we get pick 12/13 and 14 depending on who is still there and is it worth it?

Freo, West Coast and Port will have there own ideas who they would like. Being interstate, more open to trading as targeting specific players or even going into futures or trading back I think

 

[UpTheGutz]

Whats that? VFL?

Nah, initially at least, more the opportunistic, low possession but sprightly flanker who can link up, jump & even score.

Those guys are pretty important

 

[Coach_Required]

FOS could play the Jaidyn Stephenson role at North. Probably straight away

Think it means that trade for picks might be actually happening or more chance of happening.

Pick 2 & F1 for picks 6 & 11.

 

[UpTheGutz]

North want Jagga. They scream about using pick 2 on him ion there draft board

the next time I go to their board will be the first, and I can see why he’d appeal, but if they’re after more size & that’s on the first line of their wants, well he isn’t Smillie/ Langford

 

[Coach_Required]

North want Jagga. They scream about using pick 2 on him ion there draft board

Their board might think so but their club doesnt. LOL

 

[KrispyKreme]

the next time I go to their board will be the first, and I can see why he’d appeal, but if they’re after more size & that’s on the first line of their wants, well he isn’t Smillie

I don’t know I like Jagga he fits a purpose. But he is one dimensional. Probably can change though. But why north fans thought this was a great pick up is beyond me. Jagga is better suited for us. Obviously Lalor and FOS are better suited to us as well.

 

[tigersnag]

They know their stuff. Nothing they said was unreasonable. Good stuff.

They know more than 3/4 of the AFL media