List Mgmt. 2024 Draft - Post Trade Period Edition

[prodigy]

Nankervis
Lynch
Lefau
Young
Miller
Balta
Hayes-Brown
Colina
Gibcus
Blight
Gray
Fawcett

Take a good hard look at that list and name the KPP & Rucks you're confident will be around in 3 years time, then ask yourself again why phantom drafts have us targeting talls in the later part of the first round and as early as 10.

By my count there are 2 and they are Balta and Gibcus. The rest could be gone by then.

2? I swear your brain deflates during the off season.
You left a couple off the list as well, one who recently signed for 3 years.
You also can't leave Bauer off the list if you have Lefau on the list.
The way you have shaped your argument isn't really fair because a lot of that list is straight up too early to call.
Definitely: Balta, Gibcus, Fawcett, Ryan
Probably: Miller, Young, Lefau, Bauer
Too early to say: Blight, Gray, Hayes-Brown

The rest, I'd say won't be sticking around.
So, maybe, you should be the one taking the good hard look at our KPP stocks considering you couldn't even name all of them.

 

[docko911]

i like reid a lot, would be very happy if he slid to picks 10/11 and we select him

I’d prefer Lindsay

 

[guruisatiger]

Not the first person to say that to me today, the other one is a complete moron, but you are alright.

I wont say who it was but it rhymes with Pigsbentyben

Lol love this

 

[guruisatiger]

You'd have to be a complete dumb campaigner to be a mod let's be honest.

Post of the century

 

[guruisatiger]

I projectile vomitted enough yesterday when this was posted

I couldn't get out of the toilet

 

[docko911]

Nankervis
Lynch
Lefau
Young
Miller
Balta
Hayes-Brown
Colina
Gibcus
Blight
Gray
Fawcett

Take a good hard look at that list and name the KPP & Rucks you're confident will be around in 3 years time, then ask yourself again why phantom drafts have us targeting talls in the later part of the first round and as early as 10.

By my count there are 2 and they are Balta and Gibcus. The rest could be gone by then.

If that’s true it’s bad luck but we have re-signed Gray, Blight, Lefau, Miller and it looks like Colina is joining our senior/rookie A list. We must think these players have a chance of making it or we wouldn’t waste list spaces on them knowing we expected a strong draft hand. Our list will be far too top heavy if we draft 3 or more KPP/rucks.

Assuming Colina does count as a list spot that would mean we would only have 7 picks in the draft and would leave us only taking 4 smaller types, if we take 3 KPPs/rucks. If you look at our depth chart that would be absurd. We have lost 8 smaller types from the team we entered the season with. In fact we’ve actually gained a KPP already if you count Blight, Gray and Colina, having only lost Grimes and Naismith.

 

[Wrenny]

You'd have to be a complete dumb campaigner to be a mod let's be honest.

 

[tigs2010]

 

[Wrenny]

 

[the underdog]

Port Adelaide zeroing in on either Shanahan or J Whitlock with their first pick.

If we want Shanahan, we will need to use 10 or 11.

 

[tunksy]

Port Adelaide zeroing in on either Shanahan or J Whitlock with their first pick.

If we want Shanahan, we will need to use 10 or 11.

thought they were very keen on berry.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Port Adelaide zeroing in on either Shanahan or J Whitlock with their first pick.

If we want Shanahan, we will need to use 10 or 11.

Why would we want Shanahan?

 

[Rich01]

Port Adelaide zeroing in on either Shanahan or J Whitlock with their first pick.

If we want Shanahan, we will need to use 10 or 11.

PA are keen on Allan and Travaglia.
West Coast Allan, Travaglia and Lindsay.
Freo are keen on Shanahan, Berry and Allan.
GWS like Shanahan, Hotton and Lindsay.

Port jump to 10 to get their pick ahead of West Coast. West Coast take their second option at 12 (if we don’t at 11).
GWS jump to 13 to jump ahead of Freo to get Shanahan.

 

[tunksy]

PA are keen on Allan and Travaglia.
West Coast Allan, Travaglia and Lindsay.
Freo are keen on Shanahan, Berry and Allan.
GWS like Shanahan, Hotton and Lindsay.

Port jump to 10 to get their pick ahead of West Coast. West Coast take their second option at 12 (if we don’t at 11).
GWS jump to 13 to jump ahead of Freo to get Shanahan.

and we miss out on drafting KPF we badly need.

 

[tiger_tough]

and we miss out on drafting KPF we badly need.

Armstrong? Faull? Whitlock?

 

[Tigers Time]

View attachment 2160312

The above chart is based on the Top 30 Players on Rookie Me Central Draft Guide

I thought it would be helpful for people to have a quick access to how these players are rated across 9 different categories. Some interesting rankings when compared to the opinions we have had on players across the board. FWIW this is done using a combination of 7 people rather than just the one person and has been fairly accurate across the last few years that they have produced this content.

To rank Lombard as above average in both Agility and Speed when he finished 1st (6th of all time) in the agility test and 2nd in the 20m sprint while they rank Allen as elite in both when he finished way after Lombard is laughable.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Wrenny]

thought they were very keen on berry.

Where’d you hear that they were berry keen?

 

[Coach_Required]

So glad I'll be on holidays when the draft is on because if we get FOS with pick 1 I'll ****ing melt.

 

[tiger_tough]

Heard Jagga is willing to let us select him with pick 1.

 

[tigerdan]

He won't.

In that scenario someone has to slide and if it's not Langford then it's presumably Smith. I would not be unhappy if that happens.

 

[tunksy]

Where’d you hear that they were berry keen?

Article last week about Robbie gray interviewing him. Robbie now works in recruiting for them.

The kpf are also pretty set

 

[wormy]

That YouTube bro knows his stuff, but yet again we are taking too many talls and a bloody tall defender as well (which we absolutely do not need).

We should take 6 picks:

3 mids (he says Lalor, FOS, Reid) ️️️

2 tall forwards: Faull ️, defender Whitlock ️ and Dodson ️). Replace that with one of either Shanahan, Armstrong, Gerreyn.

1 small forward: Hannaford, Alger or Berry

On SM-A528B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[prodigy]

So glad I'll be on holidays when the draft is on because if we don't get FOS with pick 1 I'll ****ing melt.

Fixed

 

[Tiger1974]

Calling it a weak draft a year out is just not right.

Look at this year, apparently no key position talent a year ago now there is about 6-8 that will go in the top 25.

They saying it's a weak draft compared to this year. They study/watch teens years ahead. They know.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

That YouTube bro knows his stuff, but yet again we are taking too many talls and a bloody tall defender as well (which we absolutely do not need).

We should take 6 picks:

3 mids (he says Lalor, FOS, Reid) ️️️

2 tall forwards: Faull ️, defender Whitlock ️ and Dodson ️). Replace that with one of either Shanahan, Armstrong, Gerreyn.

1 small forward: Hannaford, Alger or Berry

On SM-A528B using BigFooty.com mobile app

When you have Miller and Young as your key defenders you need some new ones badly. The worst key defender group in the league