Trades 2024 Round 16 Trades

[WaynesWorld19]

At this stage ....these are my trades

I gave up the idea of the M9 Premo in Rozee ....maybe an opportunity to bring back McKercher as that M9 / D7 , if he can stay out of the side another 2 weeks

 

[Lord De Goey]

Do you agree with these classifications ...?

View attachment 2029461
https://x.com/Third_ManUp
Third Man Up
@Third_ManUp
Let's get a bit of #SuperCoach discussion going! RANKING THE 57 PLAYERS AVERAGING 100+!!!

Seems a tad harsh on Day

 

[Lord De Goey]

I’m surprised I only managed a finished team with 4 trades left. I haven’t had as many injuries or suspensions as past years but I still barely got it done. I guess the damage was done sideways trading premiums for no reason

Young -> Ryan
Grundy -> Xerri (it was fine for the 100k)
Xerri -> English
Whitfield -> Serong why did I pay 660k the week before his bye???
Wines -> Steele
Steele -> Ridley
Oliver -> Day (should have been Gulden)

My issue all year has been trying to chase the best players available regardless of price. Traded in English before Serong when Serong was by far the number 1 mid, top price for Zorko, Merrett etc.

The only time I went value was Oliver and that blew up in my face

 

[JuddgementDay]

I’m surprised I only managed a finished team with 4 trades left. I haven’t had as many injuries or suspensions as past years but I still barely got it done. I guess the damage was done sideways trading premiums for no reason

Young -> Ryan
Grundy -> Xerri (it was fine for the 100k)
Xerri -> English
Whitfield -> Serong why did I pay 660k the week before his bye???
Wines -> Steele
Steele -> Ridley
Oliver -> Day (should have been Gulden)

My issue all year has been trying to chase the best players available regardless of price. Traded in English before Serong when Serong was by far the number 1 mid, top price for Zorko, Merrett etc.

The only time I went value was Oliver and that blew up in my face

Given your overall ranking, you had to keep trading aggressively - these trades are just an unfortunate by product of that push for better scores

 

[Lord De Goey]

Given your overall ranking, you had to keep trading aggressively - these trades are just an unfortunate by product of that push for better scores

Definitely, but too often I go back to old mistakes. I’ve always loved Noah Anderson, so last year after he went something like 150,190 I had to get him, I didn’t care that I was paying 600k. He didn’t score above 131 for the rest of the season.

This year it was Will Day. I still think he will be a fine pick but I know better than to trade for a player the week before his bye. Even though I preferred Day to Gulden and preferred the pod aspect to him, it made no sense doing it. Gulden scored 120 points more than Clark who was my 18th scorer this week. Need to think with my brain more instead of ignoring logic to have my favourite players in my team

 

[ArdentEagle]

Anyone used all their trades yet???

 

[Falchoon]

Definitely, but too often I go back to old mistakes. I’ve always loved Noah Anderson, so last year after he went something like 150,190 I had to get him, I didn’t care that I was paying 600k. He didn’t score above 131 for the rest of the season.

This year it was Will Day. I still think he will be a fine pick but I know better than to trade for a player the week before his bye. Even though I preferred Day to Gulden and preferred the pod aspect to him, it made no sense doing it. Gulden scored 120 points more than Clark who was my 18th scorer this week. Need to think with my brain more instead of ignoring logic to have my favourite players in my team

Day's run home is favourable, it won't be the worst pick ever.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Anyone used all their trades yet???

You can't at this point.

Anyone trading at the max will have 1 trade left after this week.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Day's run home is favourable, it won't be the worst pick ever.

I don’t think so either but being at the Richmond game I didn’t realise how strange his role is. He would often sit as the last player behind play, basically full back. But he never really got involved in the chip play back there either. Hopefully he sticks to being a midfielder from now on

 

[No eye deer]

I can go Piggy to Rozee and Green to Curnow as a straight swap.
Then a def/fwd up/down next week to finish my side.
Will only leave four trades for the run home though.
Is the Green/Curnow trade too sideways?

 

[Scythe94]

I can go Piggy to Rozee and Green to Curnow as a straight swap.
Then a def/fwd up/down next week to finish my side.
Will only leave four trades for the run home though.
Is the Green/Curnow trade too sideways?

I'm doing the exact same two trades. Not sideways - Greene looks like a 75-80 average, Curnow should go 95+ with his draw. Not to mention Punchy will almost certainly miss a game at some point.

 

[Pocket Aces]

Anyone have the courage to trade Luke Ryan out. Could be the POD move that lift you up the rankings if he regresses a lot. 15 and 18 touches the last 2 weeks.

Does have tigers in Rd 17 though, that will tell the story if he has regressed.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Anyone used all their trades yet???

I think you are the leader here with 1 trade left - I haven’t seen anyone else mentioned they were down to 1 trade

 

[ArdentEagle]

You can't at this point.

Anyone trading at the max will have 1 trade left after this week.

I'm down to 1 but I could of sworn I held back one week.

Obviously not. Had COVID too many times, brain doesn't work now. Thanks mate

WaynesWorld19 Doe this mean I get a trade maniac badge now??

 

[Judd_Magic]

I'm down to 1 but I could of sworn I held back one week.

Obviously not. Had COVID too many times, brain doesn't work now. Thanks mate

WaynesWorld19 Doe this mean I get a trade maniac badge now??

I feel like a billionaire with my 3 trades now.

 

[Veer Right]

I think you are the leader here with 1 trade left - I haven’t seen anyone else mentioned they were down to 1 trade

 

[Judd_Magic]

Question.

Do I trade Oliver > Dunkley this week kenties or do I not trade and get 1 of Schoemaker or Evans in next week for Hore as D7 cover?

 

[Dangerwooodlett]

Question.

Do I trade Oliver > Dunkley this week kenties or do I not trade and get 1 of Schomaker or Evans in next week for Hore as D7 cover?

View attachment 2029789

Go Dunkley. Fisher via dpp can cover your Def. Go hard at this time of year as all teams will be at full premo and every point on field counts.

Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk

 

[Judd_Magic]

Go Dunkley. Fisher via dpp can cover your Def. Go hard at this time of year as all teams will be at full premo and every point on field counts.

Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk

Yrah I think I'm leaning that way mate.

Humphries should play soon too which can give me some defensive cover.

 

[toxic]

Sam Draper

As a solo ruck (with fwd dpp) he has some appeal
Less than 400k

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I'm down to 1 but I could of sworn I held back one week.

Obviously not. Had COVID too many times, brain doesn't work now. Thanks mate

WaynesWorld19 Doe this mean I get a trade maniac badge now??

You’re certainly in the running for the Tradeaholic Badge, in honour of the great inventor an serial tradeaholic Judd_Magic

Sadly though that last trade is an impediment

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Sam Draper

As a solo ruck (with fwd dpp) he has some appeal
Less than 400k

 

[54Dogs]

What are peoples thoughts on 40 trades at this point?

 

[toxic]

View attachment 2029827

As f7 I'm interested

He goes on little runs of okay sc scoring

For 350k I can find far worse options

Obviously assuming no Goldstein

2023 run below as an example

 

[Saints4ever]

What are peoples thoughts on 40 trades at this point?

Not enough should be 2 every week and 3 on bye weeks
Nah in all seriousness it’s way too many and now everybody has the same team.