Player Watch #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - Extends to End of 2025

[Junk yard]

Elite for medium forward rankings, not midfield. He and his bro tested as good endurance runners.
He still has puppy fat on him, whether it was no preseason or late start, that might be the case, but he still needs to work on his conditioning and muscle tone. Looked overweight. Surprised Cornes didn't go him.

I'd take a fatty that can run one from one end of the oval to the other and get a kick, over a good kid that's no good.

 

[swaeney]

Tagging brilliance... Just missed the part where you're meant to nullify the bloke for the whole game. Subbed himself off because he couldn't keep up. Other than that he's a gun, let's not discount that this time last year he earned a brownlow vote.

It doesn’t surprise me that you’re awake at 2:34 am posting about WP. If a 22 year old player for your favoured sports team is keeping you up at night I seriously suggest you seek help bud.

 

[DuckYeah]

It doesn’t surprise me that you’re awake at 2:34 am posting about WP. If a 22 year old player for your favoured sports team is keeping you up at night I seriously suggest you seek help bud.

 

[Devil Fish]

No Brownlow vote for Will Phill this year certainly raised a few eyebrows in my household.
That one he got last year was a ripper.

 

[shinboner magic]

Tagging brilliance... Just missed the part where you're meant to nullify the bloke for the whole game. Subbed himself off because he couldn't keep up. Other than that he's a gun, let's not discount that this time last year he earned a brownlow vote.

Was taken off to sign his new contract

 

[Orange Peanut]

It doesn’t surprise me that you’re awake at 2:34 am posting about WP. If a 22 year old player for your favoured sports team is keeping you up at night I seriously suggest you seek help bud.

In fairness I think JY is a WA kid so it's not that late.

 

[Chip Scab1]

In fairness I think JY is a WA kid so it's not that late.

We take them all!

If he's U25, from WA, we salute you, even. Poor kid, just imagine the shit he would've copped. From WCE fans, fair enough they won in 2018, but the shit copped from Freo fans would be tough to stomach.

 

[Devil Fish]

So we are showing interest in C Daniel?

Why did we extend Will Phil if that’s the case?

Jy, Wardlaw, Powell, Will Phil, Daniel…..we represent the Lollipop kids…..

 

[chubbspeterson]

I'd take a fatty that can run one from one end of the oval to the other and get a kick, over a good kid that's no good.

Elijah Hollands lol

 

[Duck the GOAT]

L. McDonald fanboys, where are you?

 

[Roosurgence]

Who is Logan McDonald? LOL

Not sure he will be able to look his Captain in the face who was ruled fit to play.

 

[DocSholl]

Who is Logan McDonald? LOL

Not sure he will be able to look his Captain in the face who was ruled fit to play.

Is this a coping mechanism? You're onto your 20th post about his performance

 

[Sillygit]

Is this a coping mechanism? You're onto your 20th post about his performance

20 is bush league in this thread

 

[Roosurgence]

Is this a coping mechanism? You're onto your 20th post about his performance

Not coping. He’s shit.

I think we should have taken him over Phillips given our need for a forward, but also laugh at the sky’s falling mentality when comparing him to Phillips.

Both have been extremely underwhelming.

Are you a closet Logan McDonald fan? Must be if you are biting at these posts.

If so you are the fanboy of a shittruck.

 

[Marstermind]

At least Will Phillips can say he's had a much influence over a Grand Final as Logan McDonald...

 

[DocSholl]

Not coping. He’s shit.

I think we should have taken him over Phillips given our need for a forward, but also laugh at the sky’s falling mentality when comparing him to Phillips.

Both have been extremely underwhelming.

Are you a closer Logan McDonald fan? Must be if you are biting at these posts.

If so you are the fanboy of a shittruck.

Lol k

 

[RossHenshaw]

At least Will Phillips can say he's had a much influence over a Grand Final as Logan McDonald...

Will be a premiership captan

 

[Junk yard]

L. McDonald fanboys, where are you?

Sydney are an 80 point better team than us and they jabbed him and played him underdone. Your boy Will got dropped four five times this year alone, let that sink in you fool. Did you happen to watch the preliminary? Logan took two more marks than Will averages kicks and 2 goals all from 70 odd minutes.

 

[Junk yard]

Not coping. He’s shit.

I think we should have taken him over Phillips given our need for a forward, but also laugh at the sky’s falling mentality when comparing him to Phillips.

Both have been extremely underwhelming.

Are you a closet Logan McDonald fan? Must be if you are biting at these posts.

If so you are the fanboy of a shittruck.

Missed the prelim champ?

 

[Lomas]

Missed the prelim champ?

The champ is here, the champ is here.

 

[Roosurgence]

Missed the prelim champ?

You must have missed it chump?

If thats the bar it’s a low as shark shit.

Pink could have done as much against a cooked Port Adelaide.

Your’e like a rabbit with Myxo.

 

[Marstermind]

The answer is that both Will Phillips and Logan McDonald are underwhelming picks from an understandably underwhelming draft. Yes, 4 years on McDonald seems the better pick. But only in that a shit sandwich with sprinkles on is better than a plain shit sandwich.

 

[Blightys Barrel]

At least out club showed some common sense with just a one year extension for Will Phil. Swans loaded up for 4 more years with Logan, and that decision will be placed under the microscope further next year. This year alone he could have won 2 games of his boot, and the pressure was too much. I agree with all others it was a shite draft. Lucky we didn’t pick DGB (Hawks) who was just after these 2.

 

[Junk yard]

You must have missed it chump?

If thats the bar it’s a low as shark shit.

Pink could have done as much against a cooked Port Adelaide.

Your’e like a rabbit with Myxo.

You must know more than longmire, what a legend. Apologies.

 

[Junk yard]

At least out club showed some common sense with just a one year extension for Will Phil. Swans loaded up for 4 more years with Logan, and that decision will be placed under the microscope further next year. This year alone he could have won 2 games of his boot, and the pressure was too much. I agree with all others it was a shite draft. Lucky we didn’t pick DGB (Hawks) who was just after these 2.

22yr old key forward with 37 goals and was sought after by several teams. Not really a comparison to a slow mid with no tank.