Autopsy 2nd Elimination Final, 2020: St.Kilda v Western Bulldogs

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Instead of enjoying the win the campaigners been digging up old posts

y03EPyrq9Sd63lSX7b0L828b8lrNloHaGeANg84VV-4GymLcKC-wPZEZ8sBGCIvMNp0pErigJrL0V6exOiH7do-AKDBpPRpjVrP7REFhIgKBG6B3FrncJjqaJQzQ-zNHOtiV=w220-h165
 
Kent kicked two out on the full, but I feel like he doesn't deserve to be dropped. I'd like to watch the game again to be sure, but I feel like despite his major errors, he was in and around the ball enough to help influence the times we won the ball.

0 tackles, another low possession game , no goals .. sorry but if being in and around the ball enough was deserving of a game robert eddy could have played 200.

He’s had his chances it’s time to go .
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

So Friday night will come quickly.

Out
Ryder
Kent

In
Battle
Parker/Hind

Battle for Ryder an easy swap. Marshall into the ruck full time. Battle (forward) and Snake (defence) to pinch hit around the ground.

Kent was a non factor tonight. No tackles, no marks, no goals. That doesn't cut it & we can't carry him next week. I would bring in Parker for that X Factor but Hind seems the next in line.

If Carlisle isn't available then Battle plays CHB & Jon Marsh comes in to play a role on Vlastuin.

Geary to tag Houli.

Here we ****ing go!!!
 
Best performance from our backline that I’ve seen in years . Coffield played one of the great last quarters for a defender . He will be all Australian within 2 years. I was a bit worried at stages our defenders were panicking with the ball , Over hand balling to someone under pressure but they stood tall in the last .

Max kings first half was crucial! Kept us in it in the first quarter

So glad we got hanners back in . He lifted early and was as if he was saying come with me boys this is what finals is

Paddy was enormous really feel for him and it is a big loss for us.

I’ve been a geary critic over the journey but his role tonight went a long way to us winning . Really happy for him .

Bit worried that a few things have been creeping into wilkies game like those little dinky diagonal kicks. Hopefully someone has a chat to him during the week to just take more care .

Umpires did their best . I haven’t an angle yet that suggests that Daniel tackle was even high at all let alone the fact he ducked abd it’s the dying stages of a final !!!!!

Bruce was dead to me after the jumper grab . High level of disrespect

Kent needs to go hasn’t deserved his spot any more

Love my club !!!!
 
So Friday night will come quickly.

Out
Ryder
Kent

In
Battle
Parker/Hind

Battle for Ryder an easy swap. Marshall into the ruck full time. Battle (forward) and Snake (defence) to pinch hit around the ground.

Kent was a non factor tonight. No tackles, no marks, no goals. That doesn't cut it & we can't carry him next week. I would bring in Parker for that X Factor but Hind seems the next in line.

If Carlisle isn't available then Battle plays CHB & Jon Marsh comes in to play a role on Vlastuin.

Geary to tag Houli.

Here we ******* go!!!
Surely you jest with Parker??
 
0 tackles, another low possession game , no goals .. sorry but if being in and around the ball enough was deserving of a game robert eddy could have played 200.

He’s had his chances it’s time to go .
I disagree, I've said plenty of times on here I reckon his footy IQ is incredibly high. When he doesn't have the ball he gets to the right spots, he pushes the ball towards our guys, he blocks the opposition.

I can't speak for his game tonight, all I remember is his two out on the fulls, but I think he is underrated in our team.
 
What's with all the Bruce hate? Who cares if he grabbed the jumper, he's been there for a year now and through a lot as has every player at every other club. As if he's not going to carry on kicking the first goal in a final for his side in his first finals appearance - we're better off with the team we have now and if he's happy at WB then good on him
 
Surely you jest with Parker??

There's just always been something about him where, like Long, his physicality makes up for a lack of stats.

Bringing him in to smash into guys like Balta & Baker could be a huge move.

I'm totally fine with Hind playing though. He's a proven player.
 
It was some game to watch, great for the neutral, terrible on the nerves supporters of both clubs. Credit to Bulldogs also, as it takes two sides to make a nail-biting finish. I thought Bulldogs were going to nick it at the death and I've never been so relieved to hear the siren. Phew.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy 2nd Elimination Final, 2020: St.Kilda v Western Bulldogs

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top