Mercurial89
Brownlow Medallist
You don't throw away players with Massimo's skillset. He was never just a loose checking half back. Half the players in the competition are playing different roles week to week but we couldn't use a little foresight with one of the best kicks in the competition. Absolute inditement on everyone involved in this decision.
I think it's also the type of thing you throw away too that adds to the frustration,
I value actual football skills incredibly highly (hence my horror at watching Tsatas play, and other AFL level players being unable to handball). That we would dispose of someone with that skillset makes it worse (imo).
We have done similar to this scenario before, recruiting big bodies and playing them on a damn wing and putting players from other areas into the middle.
Hell, do we remember what we did to Hep when he played as a crash and bash midfielder for a bit?
As we are gathering, football skills, being able to handball, kick accurately are becoming increasingly not valued by clubs. Whether it's how they weight strengths and weaknesses or they simply believe you can train it, I'm not sure but it's not sought after above all else.
If a player has gone through the entire youth development system and not learnt to kick well, then that isn't going to magically improve once the enter the AFL system which limits contact hours with clubs.
In my opinion for where this is all going,
As the competition becomes stronger and stronger at defensive zones there needs to be a tipping point where ball use and offensively talented footballers are the difference. It won't be just "run harder", you will need to be able to break through defences with kicking talent, and having 2 players that can kick in charge of your ball movement is not feasible.
The entire comp is built off turnover scores and how you defend them.
One great way to limit scores from turnover is to be clean with the ball.
Even if the comp doesn't get better defensively, if their is a market inefficiency in that the league does not value football skills, there will become a point that if you have enough of them, you have an edge on the comp.
It's how you build yourself into a powerhouse instead of trying to reinvent the team each year to mimic and copy the premier of the time.
Now just to reiterate, this isn't all just about this one player. It's the process and decision making behind the whole situation that's frustrating.