5 way Deal Reported on SEN re Ottens

[Pedro]

Ottens to Geelong
Zantuck to Kangaroos
Maloney to Melbourne
Harding and Pick 12 to Carlton
Pick 9 and 16 to Richmond

Apparently agreed to in priciple at 8.30p.m tonight

 

[FreoDocker]

Ottens to Geelong
Zantuck to Kangaroos
Maloney to Melbourne
Harding and Pick 12 to Carlton
Pick 9 and 16 to Carlton

Apparently agreed to in priciple at 8.30p.m tonight

Carlton would be stoked with that!!!

 

[Port01]

Ottens to Geelong
Zantuck to Kangaroos
Maloney to Melbourne
Harding and Pick 12 to Carlton
Pick 9 and 16 to Carlton

Apparently agreed to in priciple at 8.30p.m tonight

Carlton did well. 3 first rounders and Harding for nothing!

Even if you meant Richmond, 3 first rounders and Harding is rape for Ottens and Zantuck.

 

[mickrocks1]

so does Richmond give Ottens away for free?

 

[DBAH0]

Ottens to Geelong
Zantuck to Kangaroos
Maloney to Melbourne
Harding and Pick 12 to Carlton
Pick 9 and 16 to Carlton

Apparently agreed to in priciple at 8.30p.m tonight

How can Carlton get trade their own pick to themselves.

 

[Pedro]

Woops. Call it a typo. 9 and 16 to Richmond. I'm sure you knew what I meant

 

[Karbassiyoon]

if i were carlton i'd take that deal!

can somebody please tell us what was actually reported? because 5 club deals are just too radical for my liking.

 

[rUsTy_mAgPiE]

ffs use ya noggin

quite clearly the 2nd carlton one (pick 9 and 16) is what richmond gets he just made a stuff up


and yes that is what was reported

 

[Sambar]

Just heard the same report on SEN

 

[Karbassiyoon]

errors galore

 

[Shwab]

It actually works like this -

Melbourne
Lose - Pick 12
Gain - Moloney (from Geelong)

Richmond
Lose - Ottens and Zantuck
Gain - Pick 9 (From Carlton) Pick 16 (from Geelong)

Geelong
Lose - Moloney and Pick 16
Gain - Ottens

Kangaroos
Lose - Harding
Gain - Zantuck

Carlton
Lose - Pick 9
Gain - Harding and Pick 12 (From Melbourne)

 

[Ricketts]

Carlton: Pick 9 for Harding (no deal!)

wouldnt that be pick 9 for harding and pick 12??

 

[evo]

so richmond give zantuck away to upgrade pick 12 to pick 9?

surely not

 

[LongBomb]

If this is the way it happens, I'm happy with the deal.

 

[Karbassiyoon]

yeah i got it totally wrong look at shwabs post

 

[jezza]

Interesting, probably a fair to good deal for Richmond, two players for two picks, I would have liked more but this will do, especially if the pick 20 for Simmonds deal goes through.

 

[Ricketts]

yeah i got it totally wrong look at shwabs post

serves you right for rushing in and trying to be the hero by posting first.

 

[Pedro]

yeah i got it totally wrong look at shwabs post

Nobody's perfect Ted. Happens to the best of us

 

[understudy]

Ottens to Geelong
Zantuck to Kangaroos
Maloney to Melbourne
Harding and Pick 12 to Carlton
Pick 9 and 16 to Richmond

Apparently agreed to in priciple at 8.30p.m tonight

Sounds feasible, geelong would be doing pretty well out of that.

Carlton fair rather bad though lol

 

[Pedro]

I would have thought Carlton do alright. Lose pick 9, gain Harding and pick 12. Certainly not big losers.

 

[Karbassiyoon]

Melbourne
Lose - Pick 12
Gain - Moloney (from Geelong)

a fair deal given the lottery of the draft, an established young player who can make up for losing scott thompson

Richmond
Lose - Ottens and Zantuck
Gain - Pick 9 (From Carlton) Pick 16 (from Geelong)
pretty much what they wanted - they offload a player who wanted to go (as opposed to losing him for ransom because he wanted to go)

Geelong
Lose - Moloney and Pick 16
Gain - Ottens
gettings ottens is a massive coup for the cats and moloney and pick 16 is very adequate payment, they would be delighted with this deal given what ottens could do for thier side

Kangaroos
Lose - Harding
Gain - Zantuck
bit of a ho-hum deal, and probably thier second risky move of the trade period

Carlton
Lose - Pick 9
Gain - Harding and Pick 12 (From Melbourne)
harding could be good foil for fevola, and pick 12 practically means they gave nothinig up at all - big winners from this deal

 

[Karbassiyoon]

serves you right for rushing in and trying to be the hero by posting first.

well ricketts bartel to you

 

[evo]

guys are you sure richmond dont get carltons 2nd round as well--this trade doesnt make sense for us

we were better off leaving zantuck out and just taking 12 and 16

 

[banzai]

so richmond give zantuck away to upgrade pick 12 to pick 9?

surely not

I think richmond really have their eye on someone with their third selection and this is why they are so desperate to get another top 10 pick.

 

[Ricketts]

well ricketts bartel to you

ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts! ricketts!bartel!ricketts!