AFL Player # 9: Dylan Shiel - Sticking around for 2025 18/10

Remove this Banner Ad

No coincidence that Shiel names Stringer first as the player he is looking forward to playing with. He knows that Merrett, Heppell, Daniher, Hurley, Hooker, Zaka etc will all prepare immaculately for the season but getting and keeping Stringer on board is absolutely key to our success. Shiel is A grade professional.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Barrett keeps raving on about how Carlton nearly snared Shiel, yet even SOS denies he was close.

Let it go Barrett you Geeky looking flog, he's a Bomber - as he intended to be from the beginning of the trade period when he nominated Essendon!

FMD

Much of the media report that carlton were so close they had already said that they would give their future first.

Which is all well and good but if they are turning down 2 first rounders they arent turning around speaking to the club that Dylan hadnt agreed to go to and accepting 1 future first.

But of course the history has been written and we were 3rd in line to get him mid way through negotiations

I have no doubt Carlton were close in that they were probably his second choice but if the deal falls down he goes back to the Giants. Either that or Blues give up pick 1 this year as part of it and I question whether the Blues do that tbh.
 
I have no doubt Carlton were close in that they were probably his second choice but if the deal falls down he goes back to the Giants. Either that or Blues give up pick 1 this year as part of it and I question whether the Blues do that tbh.
Agree with this. The whole Carlton piece to me personally, I find irrelevant; precisely because he didn't nominate them.

Interestingly, the article on the HUN talks about how McCartney tried to convince Dylan to stay with the Giants as they had freed up their cap space. Man, that guy really must hate Dodo after getting fisted in the Stringer deal.
 
But of course the history has been written and we were 3rd in line to get him mid way through negotiations.

Mid way? We were 3rd in line up til an hour before the deadline, where we buckled like a cheap suit and took the deal that we were reported here to have taken 2 days earlier.

Nothing contrived at all about the show on fox though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

That list on the whiteboard in the background is our rankings for players in order of preference for this upcoming draft. :sweatsmile:


Luckily for us we're picking at 34. But still a bit of a brain fade.
I might be going blind at an extreme rate, but that is blurry as ****. Aint nobody working those names out
 
Some fun facts about Shiel and Treloar:
  • Both weigh in at 81kg
  • Both are the same height, 1.81m and 1.82m (Shiel taller)
  • Both born on 09/03/1993
  • Both played for Dandenong Stringrays
  • Both players were picked up before the draft
  • Both players grew up as mad Carlton supporters, however;
  • Treloar left to play with Collingwood
  • Shiel left to play with Essendon
What's my point?

F@RK CARLTON.
 
  • Both are the same height, 1.81m and 1.82m (Shiel taller)



tenor.gif
 
It’s like the Capulets and the Montagues, except with significantly less scurvy and polio on the Essendon side, and significantly more on the Collingwood side
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Player # 9: Dylan Shiel - Sticking around for 2025 18/10

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top