A summary of Hawthorn's best 22 ....

Remove this Banner Ad

BYWs Dimi Pumpa

Senior List
Oct 11, 2009
240
0
Thomaslavia aka Thomastow
AFL Club
Hawthorn
BY NO MEANS IS THIS A 'NAME YOUR HAWKS BEST 22' OR A PUT DOWN TO ANY HAWTHORN POSTER

I don't mind threads going into overdrive as sometimes it's a hot topic & a great read, but the 265 threads of 'Hawthorns best 22' is now exhausted. Let's face it, we ALL know our list on paper is one of the best in the league & that if fully fit only few teams would be able to compete against it. Especially with the additions of players such as Gibson, Burgoyne & Hooper. If all 3 can bring their goods to the table (which I'm sure burgers & gibbo will (not sure about hooper but am crossing my fingers & you would expect him to try his guts out.) then everything will be A!.

The depth over the park is quite good & there will be no doubt that players of good quality will see themselves @ box hill due to competition within the team. You can see that the Hawks are preparing for a big season & players will continously be knocking on the door (repeat of 2008).

People that think Gilham is only good for the third best forward are kidding themselves aswell. If you don't remember who was it that took the best 1 & 2 forward combo in 2008? Croad & Gilham. Gilham has come along way since his departure from port & you have to give credit where it is due. He is a clean cut player who uses the ball extremly well & even though you find that he is exposed @ times, it is rare that their is a defender in the comp that can contain every player he plays on week in & week out. If he becomes the 'take' the third best forward, then that is saying that the Gibbo & Schoe (if this eventuates) combo is running like a dream. Just remember Gilham was taking the best forward last year. You can never have a more than strong enough defence & to be quite honest I don't think our defence has many flaws in it especially if Croad could make a return. At worst if he doesn't then we are without him. Hawthorn recruited Stratton as another defender & with Murphy (who will come good), Suckling & Milney also lurking we should be right for depth in defence. Remember their are other players with the skill & class to play a defensive post if required. That's reality & the versatility is what makes our list so good.


Campbell Brown is by far in Hawthorns best 22. For you who go to the games you would notice his on field leadership is of the highest quality, he can guide players to the hot spots, rev the troops up when required & is the heart & soul of the club. IMO it would be great to see him used as a utility playing back as a majority & going forward for a quarter here & there to slot a couple of goals (could release another player i.e cyril/ burgers into the midfield)

Like everyone else, I can't wait to watch the new & improved 2010 Hawthorn hawks, but with the PD & RD to go, I can see the beginning of another Hawthorns best 22 thread. End of the day we don't know the internal situation of players, who is right & who is not. I will just wait for the first week of the footy show to see the best 22 available for Hawthorns first game.
 
Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

Why did you post this?

I'm actually really interested to know why you thought it necessary to start a new post when there is already one going. Despite your god like pronoucment that:

'I don't mind threads going into overdrive as sometimes it's a hot topic & a great read, but the 265 threads of 'Hawthorns best 22' is now exhausted.'
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

Ironic thread, considering history.

No, this is ironic, considering history.

ironictattoo.jpg
 
Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

Given he is the only current player to have the number 22 on his guernesy, surely Travis Tuck is the best 22 we currently have. Seems pretty obvious when you think about it...:p
 
Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

We should have a "Hawthorn's best 22 MEGA THREAD" stickied at the top of the board.

Yep delete this thread, sorry Pumpa I just dont understand what its real purpose was, and sticky a best 22 MEGA THREAD after the PSD/RD:thumbsu:
 
Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

If anyone learned anything from 2008, it is that there is no "Best 22" anymore. you can have a best 22 players, however, it is now a best team for any given week.


We arent living in the 90's anymore guys
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

If anyone learned anything from 2008, it is that there is no "Best 22" anymore. you can have a best 22 players, however, it is now a best team for any given week.


We arent living in the 90's anymore guys
Exactly.

The biggest reason behind a teams drop-off is injuries. St Kilda were stuffed for years until they got Misson. Always had the cattle, just could not get them on the park.

Hawthorn last year was a classic, from premiers to pathetic, purely because we couldn't get them regularly on the park and playing together (also because other teams worked out our cluster).

Successful teams need to have at least 27 fit players ready to play each week for a tilt at serious finals. Because you need your team healthy and match fit, playing with each other week in, week out.

Great thread idea BTW. I'm still working on my best 22 (really 27) and hopefully will get back before this thread is closed. LOL.
 
Re: A summary of Hawthorns best 22 ....

Maybe start a "Best of the Best 22's" thread where we discuss the best 22 threads dedicated to Hawthorn's 2010 Best 22.
 
Grizzlym's best 22


FB: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
HB: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
C: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
HF: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
F: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
R: Nathan Carroll - Who Cares - Who Cares
I: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares – Who Cares
 
Grizzlym's best 22


FB: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
HB: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
C: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
HF: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
F: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares
R: Nathan Carroll - Who Cares - Who Cares
I: Who Cares - Who Cares – Who Cares – Who Cares
Amcal.PNG
 
Here is my go at Hawthorn's worst 22 if you're sick of the best 22s

B: Jordan Lisle, Rhan Hooper, Sam Grimley
HB: Taylor Duryea, Garry Moss, Luke Lowden
C: Will Sierakowski, Luke Breust, Ryan Schoenmakers
HF: Riley Milne, Cameron Stokes, Matthew Suckling
F: Jordan Williams, Liam Shiels, Brent Renouf
R: Carl Peterson, Jarryd Morton, Beau Dowler
I: Benjamin Stratton, Thomas Murphy, Brendan Whitecross, Beau Muston
 
Here is my go at Hawthorn's worst 22 if you're sick of the best 22s

B: Jordan Lisle, Rhan Hooper, Sam Grimley
HB: Taylor Duryea, Garry Moss, Luke Lowden
C: Will Sierakowski, Luke Breust, Ryan Schoenmakers
HF: Riley Milne, Cameron Stokes, Matthew Suckling
F: Jordan Williams, Liam Shiels, Brent Renouf
R: Carl Peterson, Jarryd Morton, Beau Dowler
I: Benjamin Stratton, Thomas Murphy, Brendan Whitecross, Beau Muston

LOL at Hooper getting the FB spot over Murphy in worst team
 
coop.jpg



Coop Black is a good font. Got that Solo Man retro feel about it.

But is this our best 22? Do we need something more classical or authoritative to deliver the message?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

A summary of Hawthorn's best 22 ....

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top