Birchall/Mclean IMO. Johncock is average and Bruce is too expensive. Save some money for other areas.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
AFL Dream Team 2007
- Thread starter theone5
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
thurgood, i dont rate him, dont think the hawks fans to either. RAph clarke, injured for about 8 weeks i think. Montgomery, i dont know how he will go this year, dont know if he will even get a game.
The players you have taken out makes sense, roo is old and injured, bizzell could come good and is very cheap, maybe keep him on the bench. Heard mixed responses to hartlett.
Max 3? I have 5 lions
Would you agree Goddard is too expensive? What about Judd?
How do you guys determine if a good player that is a proven scorer is too expensive?
I think Brad Johnson is too exspensive but I have the little bastard!
I'm a massive Goddard fan as far as this goes.
GusIsBack
Senior List
- Feb 23, 2007
- 170
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
give it up! What does it matter?
Gus what general startegies would you care to share with a novice?
That brings up another point... we should be able to f***in say what we think works without everyone doing the same.
with all the tools on here with an unfinished team I cant say anything about my team or strategy
- Thread starter
- #4,732
Max 3? I have 5 lions
By any chance, are those five players:
Adcock
Black
Rischitelli
Lappin
Brown
- Thread starter
- #4,733
He is worth it IMO.
- Banned
- #4,734
Bruce is worth it imo. averaged 100 last season, got 146 against hawthorn in the nab cup.
i wouldnt have johno personally. I know i will probably get proven wrong because he is one of the true champions of the game. But the way i see it, with a fit murphy and darcy, the inclusion of aker and doogs and the fact his legs are a year older means that he could drop off a couple of points. Not much, but i dont think he will average 100.
GusIsBack
Senior List
- Feb 23, 2007
- 170
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
That's a very stupid bet, this guy knows the most out of anyone on this board... and i'd bet on him coming to 10 this year.
goddard or Brad Johnson?
I hate the forwards in this game. I enjoy picking the rest.
I think the forwards category forces you to spend a bit more than the others...less decent options imo
steainsy
Team Captain
IMO, it doesnt particulary matter how expensive they are if your looking for a few gun starting 22 players. Doesn't matter a lot if they go down in value a bit because you shouldnt be buying them with the intenition of trading at all. You also need a few gun players to hold together your team and to rotate as captain. No point in buying 30 cash cows when u only get 20 trades.
So, if you think Judd, Johnno and Goddard are all going to average about the same as last year, get on them.
Oh and, Akermanis or Fev (assuming he lines up for round 1)?
- Thread starter
- #4,739
Think all three are overpriced but then again they are all very solid DT performers. If Judd wasn't at West Coast at the moment I'd consider him for my squad.
Goddard is a little too pricey for my liking but definitely worth it if you've got the money and IMO everyone should wait for Johnson to go down before putting him in there team this season. Not going to be as influencial as the past couple of years I don't think.
I like your thoughts...and
Fev is a player I would happily trade from Carlton. So my opinion is biased. His knee is a worry.
And Aker wouldn't be in my team. But that is why I am a dud at this game. I let my opinion of players get in the way. Too emo.
But if I had to have one of the two I would go Fev.
Goddard
Close.....4 out of those 5 are correct
what be ya theory then lad? do tell?
Is it that he is a gun and true blue Carlton fan that was stolen by the AFL?
- Thread starter
- #4,746
Close.....4 out of those 5 are correct
Damn.
I hate being wrong.
Lol.
Tell which the position of the 5th player and i will find out the difference.
The RPM
Team Captain
- May 12, 2006
- 404
- 0
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I have Aker atm. Had Fev for ages though.
Aker has been consistently brilliant (even last year when he played he was amazing for all the turmoil surrounding him).
Either he goes to WBD, gels immediately and has a huge 'revenge' tour this year. Or he takes a while to fit in and is slow off the mark. I have no idea really. Here's hoping for scenario one.
Aker has been consistently brilliant (even last year when he played he was amazing for all the turmoil surrounding him).
Either he goes to WBD, gels immediately and has a huge 'revenge' tour this year. Or he takes a while to fit in and is slow off the mark. I have no idea really. Here's hoping for scenario one.
I like your thoughts...and
Fev is a player I would happily trade from Carlton. So my opinion is biased. His knee is a worry.
And Aker wouldn't be in my team. But that is why I am a dud at this game. I let my opinion of players get in the way. Too emo.
But if I had to have one of the two I would go Fev.
your a Carlton supporter and you want the Blues to get rid of Fev?How the **** are you going to kick goals then?
- Banned
- #4,749
True, but Shaw isn't a good example. I think he'll improve on last season but dunno if that'll translate into more DT points. He is a bit overpriced at the moment and tends to give away 3-4 free kicks a game so that has scared me off him a bit.
GusIsBack
Senior List
- Feb 23, 2007
- 170
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Status
Similar threads
