I don't think an AA CHB will have trouble getting a game Dogs. Are you RT?
-
LIVE: Sydney v Brisbane Lions - 2:30PM AEST Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 61% chance -- What's your tip? -- Ticketing Buy, Sell -- Teams on Thurs »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
AFL Dream Team 2008
- Thread starter Cerpin Taxt
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
HotPiesIn08
Rookie
Does anyone know if Tippet is actually injured??
Like most people I would like to get Hill into my team, but not sure who to trade him for! I thought Tippet was meant to be injured, but i see he has been named on an extended bench
Here is my forwardline:
-B Johnson
-M Pavlich
-N Reiwoldt
-J Brown
-B Hall
-J Porplyzia
-C Rioli
Reserves:
-Ryan Gamble
-Kurt Tippet
Is it a complete waste of a trade getting Hill in?
Like most people I would like to get Hill into my team, but not sure who to trade him for! I thought Tippet was meant to be injured, but i see he has been named on an extended bench
Here is my forwardline:
-B Johnson
-M Pavlich
-N Reiwoldt
-J Brown
-B Hall
-J Porplyzia
-C Rioli
Reserves:
-Ryan Gamble
-Kurt Tippet
Is it a complete waste of a trade getting Hill in?
- Apr 28, 2007
- 4,083
- 1,819
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Um, yes. That's exactly what I said. Taylor has been impressive, but will most likely make way when Egan comes back.
I'm here to help.
tippett had a minor injury
he will be fine to play
don't see him scoring much over the year though remember that although he played awesome in the NAB cup GF he still only got like 70 points
hill's average will obviously go down but he has looked pretty good
Probably been lining that one up since Bock missed !!!
With a forward line like that I would be looking to other parts of the ground. Tippet will make money, Hill will make more, but not enough to be worthy of a trade in your situation.
I deserved that
- Apr 28, 2007
- 4,083
- 1,819
- AFL Club
- West Coast
In your case, yes. Gamble and Tippet are good reserves.
Egan wont be back playing till round 12, even then don't expect him in the seniors for at least a month.
- Dec 21, 2005
- 23,638
- 14,971
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Made my first trade this week.
Out McNamara (Why wont Woosha play him!!!)
In Trav Tuck
Out McNamara (Why wont Woosha play him!!!)
In Trav Tuck
- Apr 28, 2007
- 4,083
- 1,819
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Thanks for the info. If Harry goes well this week then I might just bring him in for SDT - especially due to the lack of cheap backmen.
HotPiesIn08
Rookie
Hmmm good point!! Think i'll let Hill slide.
Here is my team:
BACKS:
C. Cornes
J. Bowden
H. Shaw
B. Waters
D. Mundy
B. Symes
A. Proud
------
D. Pfeiffer
S. Thompson
MIDFIELD:
D. Cross
A. Goodes
N. Stevens
B. Houli
C. Morton
R. Palmer
------
B. Ebert
C. Bird
RUCKS:
D. Cox
T. Simmonds
------
M. Kreuzer
J. Meesen
FORWARDS:
B. Johnson
M. Pavlich
N. Reiwoldt
J. Brown
B. Hall
J. Porplyzia
C. Rioli
------
R. Gamble
K. Tippet
My midfield is where I will be looking to make use of cash from cows
- Apr 28, 2007
- 4,083
- 1,819
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Tuck has been very impressive so far, no doubt.
But who's to say that Tuck will keep his spot in the side? Thats far from a given. And McNamara could break into the Eagles lineup any week.
- Dec 21, 2005
- 23,638
- 14,971
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Tuck will keep it for long enough.
I couldn't care less if he doesn't get 15 games.
- Apr 28, 2007
- 4,083
- 1,819
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Hmmm good point!! Think i'll let Hill slide.
Here is my team:
BACKS:
C. Cornes
J. Bowden
H. Shaw
B. Waters [B.Jones]
D. Mundy
B. Symes
A. Proud
------
D. Pfeiffer
S. Thompson
MIDFIELD:
D. Cross
A. Goodes [T.Johnstone]
N. Stevens
B. Houli [R. Dyson]
C. Morton
R. Palmer
------
B. Ebert [J.McNamara]
C. Bird
RUCKS:
D. Cox
T. Simmonds
------
M. Kreuzer [S.Hampson]
J. Meesen [Cartledge]
FORWARDS:
B. Johnson
M. Pavlich
N. Reiwoldt [Deledio]
J. Brown
B. Hall
J. Porplyzia
C. Rioli
------
R. Gamble [LeCras]
K. Tippet
My midfield is where I will be looking to make use of cash from cows
I don't believe it. I've seen a ton of teams here on bigfooty, but yours would have to be the closest to mine that I've come across.
We only have 4 starting players different.
Although I actually like yours better! I think its the best team I've come across. No kidding.
High Ryder
Premiership Player
In Palmer out Coughlan thoughts?
- Dec 21, 2005
- 23,638
- 14,971
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
If required.
Why not wait another week though?
Palmer has only played the one game.
Why not wait another week though?
Palmer has only played the one game.
High Ryder
Premiership Player
Kind of require him, otherwise Sam Lonergan starts for my lot.
HotPiesIn08
Rookie
Cheers dude!!
The only players i want to change atm are in my midfield, but they will have to wait till later on in the round when i have more money!
richmond fanatic
Cancelled
- Banned
- #20,822
Just did the one trade, Egan out for Hill. Im currently sitting 5,186, really disappointing start after i finished 500 odd last yr. But I think I have the foundations for a pretty good team.
BACKS:
Cornes
Bowden
Shaw
Milburn
Waters
Symes
Pfeiffer
Hansen
Thompson
CENTRES:
Priddis
Cross
Dal Santo
Griffen
Stevens
Tuck
Palmer
Bird
RUCKS:
Simmonds
Laycock
Hampson
Meeson
FORWARDS
J.Brown
Riewoldt
Pavlich
Burton
Deledio
Hill
Gamble
Rioli
Tippett
Got 105,400 in the bank, thoughts???
BACKS:
Cornes
Bowden
Shaw
Milburn
Waters
Symes
Pfeiffer
Hansen
Thompson
CENTRES:
Priddis
Cross
Dal Santo
Griffen
Stevens
Tuck
Palmer
Bird
RUCKS:
Simmonds
Laycock
Hampson
Meeson
FORWARDS
J.Brown
Riewoldt
Pavlich
Burton
Deledio
Hill
Gamble
Rioli
Tippett
Got 105,400 in the bank, thoughts???
richmond fanatic
Cancelled
- Banned
- #20,823
Also I'm not sure which two to start out of Rioli, Hill, Tippett and Gamble.
Leaning towards Hill and Gamble.
Leaning towards Hill and Gamble.
KING-JAMES
Club Legend
Minor dilemma for me. I have Scott Thompson, Jake Edwards and Lachlan Hansen in my defense and not one of them has been named. I was hoping at least 1 of these would become a permanent starter with the other 2 getting regular games as well but it looks unlikely.
Do you think I should make a sideways trade one of these guys for Pfeiffer or a Harry Taylor?
Do you think I should make a sideways trade one of these guys for Pfeiffer or a Harry Taylor?
- Status
Similar threads
