AFL overtaking NRL in QLD

[PhatBoy]

Australian Football is played regularly in over 55 countries and add hoc in a further 10 countries.
Australian Football is played in Nauru much more passionately than in Australia.
Here are the top twenty ranked countries.

1. Australia 1 1
2. Papua New Guinea 61.99 2 2 39
3. New Zealand 57.88 3 3 43
4. Ireland 56.68 4 4 77
5. Nauru 52.97 5 5 32
6. Great Britain 52.11 7 8 79
7. United States 49.86 6 6 57
8. Denmark 47.45 9 7 51
9. South Africa 46.61 10 9 32
10. France 45.32 8 10 33
11. Canada 43.46 11 11 55
12. China 39.91 12 12 23
13. Croatia 39.87 13 13 24
14. Fiji 38.01 14 14 19
15. Germany 35.50 15 15 32
16. Japan 35.06 16 16 34
17. Sweden 34.18 17 17 39
18. Indonesia 30.94 18 18 12
19. Pakistan 29.14 19 19 10
20. India 20.71 20 20 21

Up until Covid there was a "world cup", the AFL International Cup, every three years.
This has replaced by four regional competitions with Queensland being the hub of the Pacific competition.
Queensland plays a large part in the pathway for PNG players.

Couldn’t be more pleased for you.

 

[RedV3x]

Couldn’t be more pleased for you.

Especially these guys from the PNG into Queensland AFL.

Hewego Paul Oea | AFL

Follow Hewego Paul Oea's progress through AFL

www.goldcoastfc.com.au

Young PNG star set to make AFL debut for Brisbane Lions

The numbers of AFL players of Papua New Guinean descent is gradually catching up to the list of NRL players from the same homeland, after Bruce Reville missed a call from coach Chris Fagan about debut...

nit.com.au

 

[PhatBoy]

Especially these guys from the PNG into Queensland AFL.

Hewego Paul Oea | AFL

Follow Hewego Paul Oea's progress through AFL

www.goldcoastfc.com.au

Young PNG star set to make AFL debut for Brisbane Lions

The numbers of AFL players of Papua New Guinean descent is gradually catching up to the list of NRL players from the same homeland, after Bruce Reville missed a call from coach Chris Fagan about debut...

nit.com.au

That’s great mate. My sister was good friends with the late Sanford Wheeler: it’s not about to rival the World Series 30 years on from him playing with the swans is it. Geelong just pumped more than half a decade trying to get one of the first Pacifika-descended players (yes I realise Esava isn’t actually FROM Fiji) after NicNat into elite territory without it working. We have had 3 Irishmen in our team at one time in the last 12 months. I am aware that there are other nationalities that have experienced the sport.

 

[RedV3x]

That’s great mate. My sister was good friends with the late Sanford Wheeler

That makes you quite old.

I am aware that there are other nationalities that have experienced the sport.

Yes, there are loads of "other nationalities that have experienced the sport."
The players from the 55 counties regularly play Australian Rules Football are quite different to those people.
The PNG players are the first to follow a pathway from local league, state league to AFL.
Queensland is playing an ever increasing role in this pathway.

The AFLW is quite different with women players coming from a variety of countries with local leagues to the AFLW.

 

[PhatBoy]

That makes you quite old.



Yes, there are loads of "other nationalities that have experienced the sport."
The players from the 55 counties regularly play Australian Rules Football are quite different to those people.
The PNG players are the first to follow a pathway from local league, state league to AFL.
Queensland is playing an ever increasing role in this pathway.

The AFLW is quite different with women players coming from a variety of countries with local leagues to the AFLW.

I’m 40. Of course there are other nationalities that have experienced it. That’s not tantamount to it taking over the world, is it. Bayern Munich aren’t about to abandon the round ball game and go chips-in on Australian Football because it has a minuscule niche presence here and there.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

That makes you quite old.



Yes, there are loads of "other nationalities that have experienced the sport."
The players from the 55 counties regularly play Australian Rules Football are quite different to those people.
The PNG players are the first to follow a pathway from local league, state league to AFL.
Queensland is playing an ever increasing role in this pathway.

The AFLW is quite different with women players coming from a variety of countries with local leagues to the AFLW.

There's nuance to this. Almost all international play is not organic to the location and has links back to Australia for some reason, either to serve the expat Australian community or as a top-down approach by clubs to find athletic talent in a Cat B sense.

There's really not 55 countries playing it outside of that. There's maybe not even enough players to fill 55 teams doing that, outside of PNG, Nauru and New Zealand.

AFL London etc. is basically all expat Australians at the lower levels and maybe six teams at the top level of which they're required to play half locals - so many 3-4 teams worth of locals.

USA Nationals has, what, 40 teams with half Americans, so what, 20 teams' worth of players.

Saying "55 countries" is a bit meaningless without nuance and context. Outside of the geographically close Pacific countries, there's probably, what, 2000 genuinely local non-Australians actively playing Aussie Rules consistently? And many of those 2000 only have a team to play in because of the fact that such a team develop for largely expat Australian reasons (e.g. of the 75 or so non-Australians who play in the AFL London competition, they can only do so because there's a framework for them to play in to support the other 750 Australians in London who want to play AFL).

There's some limited historical development of the sport due to government and geopolitical reasons in South Africa, Pacific, Canada etc.

Outside of expat Australians or by extension servicing expat Australians there is basically zero cultural relevance of a playing Aussie Rules.

 

[RedV3x]

Outside of expat Australians

Here are the top twenty ranked countries
When they play internationally, expats are prohibited from playing.
The last column is the number of international games played.
PNG is ranked #2 because it has over 70,000 players across the country.

1. Australia 1 1
2. Papua New Guinea 61.99 2 2 39
3. New Zealand 57.88 3 3 43
4. Ireland 56.68 4 4 77
5. Nauru 52.97 5 5 32
6. Great Britain 52.11 7 8 79
7. United States 49.86 6 6 57
8. Denmark 47.45 9 7 51
9. South Africa 46.61 10 9 32
10. France 45.32 8 10 33
11. Canada 43.46 11 11 55
12. China 39.91 12 12 23
13. Croatia 39.87 13 13 24
14. Fiji 38.01 14 14 19
15. Germany 35.50 15 15 32
16. Japan 35.06 16 16 34
17. Sweden 34.18 17 17 39
18. Indonesia 30.94 18 18 12
19. Pakistan 29.14 19 19 10
20. India 20.71 20 20 21

AFL PNG Development | AFL Queensland

www.aflq.com.au

"AFLPNG Development are the AFL’s development arm in Papua New Guinea, with 21 full-time staff and a strong focus on development and talent.
The team at AFLPNG Development conduct Coaching, Umpiring and Match play programs across six provinces of PNG, with approximately 70,000 boys, girls, men & women annually, aged from 5 – 40 years taking part.

With a direct link to the AFLQ Talent pathway you will also see the AFL PNG National Academy Teams competing in the AFL QLD Youth Academy Pathway each year.

The world beating national men’s Mozzies and women’s Flames teams are continually at the pointy end the International Cup every three years with the Mozzies winning the past two competitions."

 

[RedV3x]

Of course there are other nationalities that have experienced it.

Yes, there are loads of "other nationalities that have experienced the sport."
The players from the 55 counties regularly play Australian Rules Football are quite different to those people.
The PNG players are the first to follow a pathway from local league, state league to AFL.
Queensland is playing an ever increasing role in this pathway.

The AFLW is quite different with women players coming from a variety of countries with local leagues to the AFLW.

That’s not tantamount to it taking over the world,

It's more like the world's coming to Australia.

I have travelled widely and umpired Australian Football in many countries.
The common denominator with these players is the love of the game of Australian football.
Another common denominator with these players is that they want to play for their country.
A.T.M. women from around the world want to play in the AFLW.
Now, a few men form the PNG are being given that opportunity.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

1. Australia 1 1
2. Papua New Guinea 61.99 2 2 39
3. New Zealand 57.88 3 3 43
4. Ireland 56.68 4 4 77
5. Nauru 52.97 5 5 32
6. Great Britain 52.11 7 8 79
7. United States 49.86 6 6 57
8. Denmark 47.45 9 7 51
9. South Africa 46.61 10 9 32
10. France 45.32 8 10 33
11. Canada 43.46 11 11 55
12. China 39.91 12 12 23
13. Croatia 39.87 13 13 24
14. Fiji 38.01 14 14 19
15. Germany 35.50 15 15 32
16. Japan 35.06 16 16 34
17. Sweden 34.18 17 17 39
18. Indonesia 30.94 18 18 12
19. Pakistan 29.14 19 19 10
20. India 20.71 20 20 21

Many of these teams have not functionally had a team since the last Australian-based IC in 2017. Including them in supposed World Rankings is a bit pointless when they potentially haven't been active for 7 years.

So they were able to get 25 locals to come to Australia, doesn't prove anything. Just that there's 500 active locals playing the game overseas, which I've conceded. The AFL Germany podcast on the International Board (10 years old) said they had six teams with about 1/3 German IC eligible players. So they formed one team out of half the eligible players, many of whom couldn't take work leave/pay for a trip to Australia. Anyone who was an active player and qualified for Germany could effectively represent their national team. It's not really a sign of an expansive participation base, is it?

Many of these 500 players are only engaged in the game because of a preexisting relationship (such as a friendship) with an AFL expat, or that simply the ability to play in a club was formed by an expat. How many of the USAFL's clubs were founded or functionally developed by an non-Australian? Hardly any. It's not organic growth outside of just the Australian expat community bringing its culture along with it. It's like saying that you can get Vegemite in some stores around the world so Vegemite is growing in popularity globally organically. It isn't. It's just expat Austrlaians bringing vegemite along with them for cultural reasons.

"AFLPNG Development are the AFL’s development arm in Papua New Guinea, with 21 full-time staff and a strong focus on development and talent.
The team at AFLPNG Development conduct Coaching, Umpiring and Match play programs across six provinces of PNG, with approximately 70,000 boys, girls, men & women annually, aged from 5 – 40 years taking part.

With a direct link to the AFLQ Talent pathway you will also see the AFL PNG National Academy Teams competing in the AFL QLD Youth Academy Pathway each year.

The world beating national men’s Mozzies and women’s Flames teams are continually at the pointy end the International Cup every three years with the Mozzies winning the past two competitions."

So AFL exists in PNG largely due to historic reasons (that it was literally once an Australian territory). It's not replicable as there is only one other location in the world that is also a former Australian territory (Nauru), which is also dominated by AFL. There's also an small but meaningful existing presence in NZ, too, due to similar cultures. It's not replicable around the world, because there are literally no other countries that are former Australian territories.

Aussie rules is also dying in both PNG and Nauru. Aussie Rules was actually a more popular sport in PNG at the time of PNG independence in 1975, but Rugby League has grown and dominated since. And Rugby Union/Sevens has been the code of choice in Nauru in recent years with former national team players in the small country code-switching after some small investment by World Rugby (bigger than the AFL's investment) to play in local tournaments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nauru_national_rugby_sevens_team

 

[threenewpadlocks]

The PNG players are the first to follow a pathway from local league, state league to AFL.
Queensland is playing an ever increasing role in this pathway.

It's hardly creating a dent in the pathway though.

Home and Away competition fixtures | PlayHQ

View U16 Boys International Tri-Series fixture and ladder for the AFL Cairns Juniors 2024 season

www.playhq.com

The PNG U16 team lost all of their matches against Cairns A, Cairns B and Cape York U16 teams.

The fact that Hewago Oea (and to a lesser extent Gideon Simon), a positive story that they are, have added the "pathways" is minute to be meaningless.

The AFL would arguably get more talented players in their pathways by investing in the 18,000, primarily Rugby-League loving population of Cape York, shown by the fact that their U16 team defeated the U16 team of PNG.

 

[RedV3x]

Many of these teams have not functionally had a team since the last Australian-based IC in 2017. Including them in supposed World Rankings is a bit pointless when they potentially haven't been active for 7 years.

Well that's Covid for you. It's all about to change before December with
Transatlantic Cup Canada, Colombia, USA, Great Britain, France and Ireland
Pacific Cup Fiji, Nauru, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Tonga, Vanuatu, South Africa
Asia Cup Cambodia, China, India, Indonesia, Japan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Vietnam

So they were able to get 25 locals to come to Australia, doesn't prove anything.

But the thousands coming to australia do.

Just that there's 500 active locals playing the game overseas, which I've conceded.

The official figure is 100,000 people play Australian Football overseas.

The AFL German

AFL Germany has expanded from a national league to regional leagues and to metro leagues in some cases
.

Many of these 500 players

Many of these 100,000 players !

As I have said before, I have travelled and umpired AFL in many countries
and I take note of who's playing and I try and ask as many players what attracted them to the game.
There are many reasons. Maybe if you go to International board i can further the discussion.

How many of the USAFL's clubs were founded or functionally developed by an non-Australian?

W.R.T. development blessed be what works.

It's not organic growth outside of just the Australian expat community

In some places in wonder if we've lost the "Australian" in Australian football with a foreign takeover.

So AFL exists in PNG largely due to historic reasons

Yes, post WWII, Australian football became PNG's game.

It's not replicable

I'd argue that.You've given examples.

There's also an small but meaningful existing presence in NZ,

Yes, that was going admirably untill Covid came along.

 

[RedV3x]

It's hardly creating a dent in the pathway though.

So now we're arguing about degree.
First there was no pathway, then a respectable number of PNG players found their way to state leagues
and now and handful are making it to the AFL.

I'd say that was case for celebration rather then looking at dents wouldn't you say.

 

[threenewpadlocks]

Well that's Covid for you. It's all about to change before December with
Transatlantic Cup Canada, Colombia, USA, Great Britain, France and Ireland
Pacific Cup Fiji, Nauru, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Tonga, Vanuatu, South Africa
Asia Cup Cambodia, China, India, Indonesia, Japan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Vietnam

So we've gone from 18 to 22 teams from the 2017 IC despite it being signficantly functionally cheaper and shorter and easier to play regionally than in Australia. Brilliant growth.

But the thousands coming to australia do.

850 players men and women were registered for the 2017 IC. Not thousands.

The official figure is 100,000 people play Australian Football overseas.

You cannot honestly believe these figures.

Assuming that an average of 100 people "play" the game per club, that would suggest 1,000 clubs.

There are not 1,000 clubs outside Australia.

Find your club - AFL Europe

afleurope.org

USAFL Clubs

usafl.com

Among various other actual registers of clubs.

Or maybe you're counting the "70,000" who play in PNG as part of that 100,000 which is just silly. If 70,000 people genuinely did play, their most talented U16 team would not be losing games to the Cairns B U16 team or the Cape York team.

Have some common sense, please.

As I have said before, I have travelled and umpired AFL in many countries
and I take note of who's playing and I try and ask as many players what attracted them to the game.
There are many reasons. Maybe if you go to International board i can further the discussion.

I have interacted (not played or umpired, but functionally interacted) with Aussie rules team overseas, and had similar discussions.

I don't deny that there are thousands of non-Austrlaians playing the sport. But just that - thousands. Not high 10's of thousands. You just interacted with the thousands.

Many of the clubs were run by Australians.

W.R.T. development blessed be what works.

In some places in wonder if we've lost the "Australian" in Australian football with a foreign takeover.

I'm not passing value judgement on this - whether or not the AFL should invest to develop the game internationally, and if they do, if it should be organic or through supporting it as an Australian cultural export or just as a sport as is. I'm just stating the realities - I'll leave the moral obligations and policy debate and value judgements to you.

I'd argue that.You've given examples.

PNG and Nauru were once Australian territories.
That resulted in an influx of Australian workers and culture, and many residents spending time back and forth between the two countries in schooling and administration by virtue of the fact that it was a territory of Australia. There isn't the natural back and forth movement of people and culture in countries that aren't Australian territories.

Countries in which Aussie Rules has once been a primary sport: PNG and Nauru
Countries that have at one stage in their history been an Austrlaian territory: PNG and Nauru

The list is literally the one and the same. There's no Venn diagram. The circles literally overlap.

Yes, that was going admirably untill Covid came along.

Development efforts are just nominal (especially compared to Qld and NZ).

There's a small but constant presence of active AFL participation in NZ since the 70s that ebbs and flows in popularity with AFL and club investment in schools and talent ID also ebbing and flowing but by virtue of some cultural similaries and transfer of individuals back and forth between the countries that is greater than any other country, this cannot be replicated in any other country to have a small and constant presence.

 

[RedV3x]

So we've gone from 18 to 22 teams from the 2017 IC despite it being signficantly functionally cheaper and shorter and easier to play regionally than in Australia. Brilliant growth.

So we've gone from 18 to 22 teams from the 2017 IC with it being signficantly functionally cheaper and shorter and easier to play regionally than in Australia. Brilliant growth.

You cannot honestly believe these figures.

I certainly cannot believe your figures.

maybe you're counting the "70,000" who play in PNG as part of that 100,000

You seem to question every official figure.

Many of the clubs were run by Australians.

Yes. The most inspirational are not.

I'm not passing value judgement on this - whether or not the AFL should invest to develop the game internationally, and if they do, if it should be organic or through supporting it as an Australian cultural export or just as a sport as is.

That's subject for the international page. meet you there.

this cannot be replicated in any other country to have a small and constant presence.

WRONG. For example Australian Football is an official sport of Canada.

 

[010203]

Where I'm weird is I like both rugby codes and AFL. I want them all to succeed in this country but I know that's not realistic or probably more accurately, not possible.

 

[Fire]

Where I'm weird is I like both rugby codes and AFL. I want them all to succeed in this country but I know that's not realistic or probably more accurately, not possible.

I mean they absolutely can. Both codes are competing for sponsorships and players, but if there's enough sports fans who enjoy following two teams then there's no reason for one to die out. The major sports over here in the US overlap each other. Some are bigger than others, but none are about to collapse.

Clubs in the AFL and NRL are financially sustainable, either on their own or through the value tgey bring their sports governing body. Yeah it's unusual for a country the size of Australia to have so many professional sports teams, but those two codes are making it work. It's more a problem for soccer, union and basketball.

 

[RedV3x]

I mean they absolutely can.

Both AFL and NRL succeed a.t.m. and rugby has and could again.

Both codes are competing for sponsorships and players,

The real competition is for sponsorships. Not so much players at professional level.
Supporters tend to find their code of choice whilst followers watch moe.

but if there's enough sports fans who enjoy following two teams then there's no reason for one to die out.

The AFL has good distribution across Australia whilst the NRL is consolidated on the East coast.

The major sports over here in the US overlap each other. Some are bigger than others, but none are about to collapse.

Different situation. You don't have four football codes "competing"
The U.S.A. has far more cities than sports teams.
The potential player pool is so much larger than Australia's when divided by number of teams.

Clubs in the AFL and NRL are financially sustainable, either on their own or through the value they bring their sports governing body. Yeah it's unusual for a country the size of Australia to have so many professional sports teams, but those two codes are making it work. It's more a problem for soccer, union and basketball.

Basketball has a very sustainable mode.
Rugby union has messed things up and IMO has no clear path back.
Soccer would have a very sustainable model if they aimed at having sustainable model.
NRL would have a very sustainable model if they aimed at having sustainable model rather than trying to emulate AFL.
The AFL has a problem in that it hasn't the support of government.,

 

[raskolnikov]

.Copped a fair bit of gAyFL and the like whenever I donned a bit of Lions merch so naturally kept it to myself to avoid the dickheads who get so worked up and defensive when people follow the “Victorian Game”.

lived in Toowoomba for years and went to uni there. I played in the DDAFL. Never copped a word about it.

 

[GC2015]

lived in Toowoomba for years and went to uni there. I played in the DDAFL. Never copped a word about it.

It's primary and secondary school years where it's the most prominent. That also happens to be the most important period when it comes to choosing your preferred sport. I went to primary and secondary school on the Gold Coast as well as uni on the GC - I don't think I ever heard the 'gAyFL' comments in uni either, but I certainly heard it at school.

 

[Bjo187]

It's primary and secondary school years where it's the most prominent. That also happens to be the most important period when it comes to choosing your preferred sport. I went to primary and secondary school on the Gold Coast as well as uni on the GC - I don't think I ever heard the 'gAyFL' comments in uni either, but I certainly heard it at school.

I was thinking the same thing, people are more educated and open to trying new things in uni years. School is where you're most impressionable and teasing is a lot more prevalent, it would definitely deter at least 50 percent of kids if it's common and regular mocking.

I actually think though seeing the kids coming through the gc academy, surely guys like Graham, Walter, Rogers and Lombard would be the cool kids in the school yard. So the culture has likely changed even in the past 5 years, on the gold coast anyway.

 

[Macca180]

I can guarantee you that not one of these bogan simpletons that call footy G**FL have ever played.

Go play a game then see how 'G*Y' it is when you have to stand under high balls. back up into packs not knowing what's coming and put your head over the ball any 50/50 contest.

They wouldn't get a kick, touch the footy, would be throwing up in 5 or ten minutes from the running.

****ing losers.

No one that has played the game at any sort of level it calls in 'G*YFL'. There is a reason for that.

 

[Aucklander]

I've heard the term for years, long before I even arrived in Victoria, it's a bit like the bumsniffer one used by people to slur people who follow Rugby league.

When you watch early footage of Australian football it can hardly be described as gAyFL as it's so much more violent than it is today. I've got no doubt the tight shorts and "singlet" were behind it all from where I sat and it's obviously stuck through the generations which has followed. Eventually it will pass as those generations do. For some of us it's already has.

Long live the growth of Australian football in QLD.

 

[Bjo187]

Good news for QLD footy with the liberals winning the election last night. They have already said they won't be going with the ridiculous QSAC idea, but also they won't be building a new stadium either.

So that leaves the only options as the gabba rebuild (which cost labor big time, so would be a mistake), or as some believe private investors building a new stadium.

No doubt our friends in rugby league will be lobbying hard in the background to stop a new and flash oval stadium from being built in Brisbane, like they did with the last government, but really there is no common sense alternative, other than a new stadium.

 

[GC2015]

Good news for QLD footy with the liberals winning the election last night. They have already said they won't be going with the ridiculous QSAC idea, but also they won't be building a new stadium either.

So that leaves the only options as the gabba rebuild (which cost labor big time, so would be a mistake), or as some believe private investors building a new stadium.

No doubt our friends in rugby league will be lobbying hard in the background to stop a new and flash oval stadium from being built in Brisbane, like they did with the last government, but really there is no common sense alternative, other than a new stadium.

Doesn't that mean the Lions (and Heat?) will be required to play home games on the Gold Coast for multiple years while the Gabba is being rebuilt? Might be time to start talking about upgrading the capacity at Carrara. The Suns sold out 4 of 9 home games at Carrara this year and I'm sure the Lions would pull 25k+ on a fairly regular basis as well. Fill in the open section at Carrara and the capacity should increase to 32-35k. Seems suitable for all parties.

 

[Bjo187]

Doesn't that mean the Lions (and Heat?) will be required to play home games on the Gold Coast for multiple years while the Gabba is being rebuilt? Might be time to start talking about upgrading the capacity at Carrara. The Suns sold out 4 of 9 home games at Carrara this year and I'm sure the Lions would pull 25k+ on a fairly regular basis as well. Fill in the open section at Carrara and the capacity should increase to 32-35k. Seems suitable for all parties.

Yes it would mean that if they chose to rebuild the gabba, but that would be a disaster for the lions being out of Brisbane for 4 or 5 years. They would need to be compensated handsomely from the government for the displacement and that's one of the main reasons the gabba redevelopment fell over in the first place.

The Victoria park new stadium proposal addresses all issues in one go, the only thing holding it back is cost (although it actually works out cheaper than the QSAC proposal when you crunch the numbers, politicians don't care about that though, it's all about the figure the public believe) and some meddling from a certain John Coates and a rectangular sport that don't wanna give the AFL a leg up in Brisbane. Which a new stadium would definitely do.