Game Day AFL Round 17 - Matchday Discussion West Coast@Collingwood(MCG – 1:10PM)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Collingwood and West Coast will meet at the MCG for a huge top four clash. The result of this game could have huge ramifications for where these sides finish by season’s end. Both sides are coming off testing wins, in which each side had to dig deep in order to get the four points. The two teams will also be bolstered with some huge inclusions. For the Eagles, their three best forwards return, and for the Magpies, Darcy Moore and Varcoe both return.

Collingwood

Collingwood improved its finals prospects last week, managed to fend off a plucky Bombers outfit. The second quarter was perhaps the worst quarter played by the Magpies all season, but they managed to dig deep in the other quarters to pull off a remarkable win. Scott Pendlebury put in superb performance, winning crucial clearances as well as steadying the ship when the team appeared to buckle. De Goey and Grundy were also outstanding. A win for Collingwood is not only important for their finals chances, but it is also needed to improve their credentials. In recent weeks, critics have cited that Collingwood has only defeated one top eight team. The Magpies will be keen to grab this week and silence the critics. Collingwood’s backline will have its work cut out for them with the Eagles bringing back Jack Darling, Josh Kennedy, and Mark LeCras. This is incredibly difficult for Collingwood as they will be without key backman Lynden Dunn. Collingwood will be relying on Jeremy Howe, Matthew Scharenberg, and Darcy Moore to cover these players.

The man to watch for Collingwood is Darcy Moore. Moore has had an injury interrupted season, and his expiring contract has caused some nervousness around the club. However, regardless of his contract, he is still an important asset to this Collingwood team. Many assume that Moore will be playing down back, and will be faced with the daunting task on either Kennedy or Darling. Moore will at least need to restrict their impact on the game.

West Coast

After a mid-season lull, West Coast seem to be clicking back into gear, showing some good form against the Giants last week. Like Collingwood, the Eagles were tested, but like all good side should, they managed to put GWS away in the end. Jack Redden and Andrew Gaff were both excellent for the Eagles. Shannon Hurn also played well, establishing himself as one of the premier captains in the competition. The West Coast will be bolstered with the inclusion of half their forward line, which has convinced many that the West Coast should come away with the four points on Sunday. However, their record at the MCG causes much doubt to be cast over the side. The Eagles have not beaten Collingwood at the MCG since round two, 1995. Since 2015, the Eagles have only beaten one side at the MCG, Carlton. These statistics are damning, and are going to sit in the players minds during the game.

The man to watch is Jack Darling. Midway through the season, Darling put forth his credentials as one of the best key forwards in the competition. However, he has been out since mid-season, and in his first game back he will be looking to make an impact, with many also wondering if he can recapture that form he had earlier in the season.


Changes
West Coast


In: Jack Darling, Mark LeCras, Josh J. Kennedy, Jake Waterman

Out: Brendon Ah Chee (Omitted), Nathan Vardy (Omitted), Brayden Ainsworth (Omitted), Oscar Allen (Omitted)

Collingwood

In: Travis Varcoe, Darcy Moore

Out: Ben Crocker (Omitted), Flynn Appleby (Injured)

Head to Head Odds
West Coast: $2.50

Collingwood: $1.55

TV

Live on Channel 7. WA Only.
Live on Fox Footy, Commercial Free


Radio

SEN
ABC

IPTV

AFL Live Pass
Foxtel Now
WatchAFL

Congratulations Jack Crisp

The ever consistent Crisp chalks up his 100th game this week. The man who was classed as “steak knives” in the Dayne Beams trade has well and truly cemented his spot in the best 22 with his hard running and long booming kicks.

Tip

While Collingwood do have a major advantage playing at the MCG, the inclusions for the Eagles will be too much to handle for an undermanned Collingwood backline.

West Coast by 15.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

We will feed them to the ponies.

Pies by 33
 
We’ll win.

And nicely :)

And still we’ll have beaten nobody above us.
 
This is the game people.....forget all the rest so far.

Win this and we make finals and make the rest of the competition take us seriously.

Very nervous and excited about this one.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The importance of this game can not be understated. We win and it’s a massive confidence boost, beating a top 4 team and continuing our good form into the latter rounds of the season should see us push for a top 2 spot. But if we loose badly things could go down hill and the drop in confidence could easily see us drop out of the top 4.
Despite Kennedy and Darling coming back in I still think we’re getting WC at a good time. Both players are underdone so shouldn’t dominate, and you would think WC would need 7 or so goals between them to win, which I don’t see happening.
Would be nice to have Toovey back just in case tho .
 
Disagree with the OP. Our defence isn't undermanned. Also Darling isn't the man to watch. He will be nullified if we win the midfield battle in which I think we will. Le Cras always plays well at the G and against us. He in my mind is who we need to keep under control. We got this.
 
Disagree with the OP. Our defence isn't undermanned. Also Darling isn't the man to watch. He will be nullified if we win the midfield battle in which I think we will. Le Cras always plays well at the G and against us. He in my mind is who we need to keep under control. We got this.

Agree, don’t think we’re undermanned back there, in fact the flexible mix of talls ( Moore, Scharenberg, Langdon and Howe) and smalls (Crisp, Maynard, Greenwood, Varcoe) is one of our strongest assets.

I think the biggest danger is the resting ruckman, Lycett, who could expose Langdon for height, however you back in the team defence to provide coverage.

Even if we do get exposed, most of the contenders (Richmond, Port, Sydney) play with mobile forward lines with at max 2 key talls. We’ll learn our lesson and bank it for September.

In saying that I’m confident we’ll out do them in the middle and win well. Can’t wait for the 5am kickoff (the perils of being in sunny Sicily)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top