Speedyunit
All Australian
no need to swear.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
AFLQ Premier Division
- Thread starter Sir G
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Speedyunit
All Australian
I do apologise if that was incorrect about cooparoo and mayne it was what i was told. but there is one fact didnt magpies finish infront of burleigh 08,07,06?
this was on the yeronga devils facebook page.
Would like to announce the signing of Matt Brown as a playing assistant coach and Phil Lobb as another star signing.
Welcome aboard boys, good luck this year
Go the devils!
and that was on the 25th of Jan so Maybe he might be telling clubs one thing and his mate other things.
oneeyebomber
Rookie
Do ya self a favor loud mouth have a look on the clearance website to see if he has signed
Come on mate just putting up something that was on a club page, so can only take it on face vaule, chin up phil??
The Ratta_tat_Cat
Debutant
someone should rename this the noosa chronicles, with special guest Mr Phil Lobb, with s7369 doing the maroochy weather.
Any news on teams other than the feuding sunny coast boys? The magpies going to be a force like they were when they went up to the state league?
PBC looking very strong, potentially number 1 goldy team again, shading the bombers with or without the here say of superstar lobb.. (mind you I've still never heard of this bloke) He's no dickfos, matthews x2 , white , bloom , hicks , friis , cash , tyrell , housego..or any other top 10 league player in the last 3-4 yrs?
Any news on the practise matches organised or potential line ups including the new signings around the places?
Any news on teams other than the feuding sunny coast boys? The magpies going to be a force like they were when they went up to the state league?
PBC looking very strong, potentially number 1 goldy team again, shading the bombers with or without the here say of superstar lobb.. (mind you I've still never heard of this bloke) He's no dickfos, matthews x2 , white , bloom , hicks , friis , cash , tyrell , housego..or any other top 10 league player in the last 3-4 yrs?
Any news on the practise matches organised or potential line ups including the new signings around the places?
amarooplace
Draftee
- Jul 12, 2010
- 17
- 3
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Is it true Arnold knight is back at pbc? Probably one of the most damaging players in the comp with his run off half back.
that's right. you don't have a leg to stand on if you go and complain and you don't have a time keeper checking to make sure everything is above board
Have heard that Knight is back for Palmy.Picked up a State centre Half back from Broadbeach,two vic country reps from Mildura so will be pretty red hot I`d imagine.Knight is a star,always killed Noosa with his run and decision making across half back.A lot of us had him best afield in the 2009 grand final at maroochy.I`ve heard Marto has rallied some handy recruits from State league clubs to Grange so they should improve whilst the magpies should be around the mark.Dickfos and Forbes up forward for Sandgate is extremely daunting(like a Moncur/Wallin set up at springwood a few years back)Have heard Maroochy have picked up a few very handy recruits and are quietly confident going in to 2011.Surfers are rebuilding after some big spending in 07,08,09 and not sure about Cooly,Mayne or Springwood.Always rate burleigh high as their aggression at the contest has been outstanding for many years.
thebazza
Rookie
Fev's gone!! You guys all think Noosa is spending a fortune, so who's going to pick him up in our comp? Not looking for arguments, just having a laugh!!
thebazza
Rookie
s364376;20200361[B said:
Ha Ha Ha, i cant help myself, a warm down, shit they must have been hot. Running round the square clapping their hands above their heads must have been to cool their hair down was it!!! ha ha. Hey mate, this is all in good fun. I love the Tiger/Roos rivalry, had the Roo's game pencilled in every year i played. Couldnt wait. We give each other shit on and off the ground but theres always a respect there. Were the only 2 coast teams left!!!!
thebazza
Rookie
s364376;20200361[B said:
Ha Ha Ha, i cant help myself, a warm down, shit they must have been hot. Running round the square clapping their hands above their heads must have been to cool their hair down was it!!! ha ha. Hey mate, this is all in good fun. I love the Tiger/Roos rivalry, had the Roo's game pencilled in every year i played. Couldnt wait. We give each other shit on and off the ground but theres always a respect there. Were the only 2 coast teams left!!!!
you are kidding right? i am guessing you don't mind cheating at golf, so long as you aren't caught of course.
now that both teams don't have to supply interchange stewards, if the opposition don't have one is it ok to put all 22 on so long as no one works it out?
bit hard to actually get a time keeper into the noosa timekeeper box these days. that bloke still swears he didn't do anything wrong, sometimes in football when the games on the line things can appear different to what they really are. anyway, I was talking to someone from burleigh one day at a game, and he said burleigh had the same thing happen to them a couple of years ago to, must be coincidence.
Sandgates timekeeper sits up at the supporters tent, so for the visiting team it isn't much fun sitting in amongst a bunch of drunk local supporters.
how about palmys scoreboard assistants, 2009 against maroochydore they completely f*cked the scores up and had maroochydore down with less than a minute to go when they were really 1 point up. roos threw everyone forward, and palmy kick a point, then another point to win by a point. both goal umpires had different scores, which were different to the palmy interchange steward. who knows wtf happened that day, but thats footy.
grange will have a good team this year from all report. were the only ones objecting to the new recruiting rule where players are given points, so that would lead you to think they have recruited a few guns.
magpies are putting all there efforts into getting the clubhouse and grounds repaired, so you would think they will be slow starters but class will prevail and they will play finals.
springwood had a young team last year. if they have managed to keep there kids, they should be big improvers this year, especially if they have picked up a key position player or 2.
if you don't have time keeper there keeping a check on things and you think something has gone wrong. you can't complain. because you don't have your time keeper checking it out.
that's how it is
you know what the league would ask when you put the complaint in. did you have your own time keeper there. when you say no. they will laugh in your face. have you volunteered lately
you can't complain when you don't have a time keeper yourself. if the home time doesn't know the rules to time keeping himself. they shouldn't be doing it
WilstonGrange
Draftee
Not sure if you saw what was proposed s364376? Grange (and other clubs) objected to the system suggested by the league as it was too simplistic. It would have been of absolutely no benefit and did not do enough to reward development of local/junior players or help even up the competition and reduce financial pressure on clubs to be competitive. It would have just been a waste of time and volunteer effort.
Sportingpulse provides a great opportunity for detailed player history to be a part of the ranking as it is all there in a database - makes it easy to allocate points based on certain rules and for the points tally to be visible and automated when entering team sheet. As we all know there is a big difference between a 100+ senior game Ovens & Murray player and a 6 game O&M player who mostly played reserves, yet the system suggested did not distinguish and gave them both the same points value.
Grange have been pushing for a points system in preference to a salary cap for over 7 years, and in fact late last year volunteered to convene a working party of any clubs interested in helping to design and come up with an appropriate system that is easy to manage and actually does what is intended. All clubs could then decide whether a system designed for the league's specific circumstances and detailed enough to actually do something (eg detailed player history etc..geographical location of clubs, population density, etc..) was worth proceeding with.
Be even easier if everyone just played for nothing though.
Speedyunit
All Australian
I didnt think that there would be that big of a difference in financial capabilities between the clubs in the PHC with Aspley now out. There has always been a trend especially with the coast sides of sitting around the bottom and saving up over a couple of years and then buying 4 or 5 players for a crack at the flag.Not sure if you saw what was proposed s364376? Grange (and other clubs) objected to the system suggested by the league as it was too simplistic. It would have been of absolutely no benefit and did not do enough to reward development of local/junior players or help even up the competition and reduce financial pressure on clubs to be competitive. It would have just been a waste of time and volunteer effort.
Sportingpulse provides a great opportunity for detailed player history to be a part of the ranking as it is all there in a database - makes it easy to allocate points based on certain rules and for the points tally to be visible and automated when entering team sheet. As we all know there is a big difference between a 100+ senior game Ovens & Murray player and a 6 game O&M player who mostly played reserves, yet the system suggested did not distinguish and gave them both the same points value.
Grange have been pushing for a points system in preference to a salary cap for over 7 years, and in fact late last year volunteered to convene a working party of any clubs interested in helping to design and come up with an appropriate system that is easy to manage and actually does what is intended. All clubs could then decide whether a system designed for the league's specific circumstances and detailed enough to actually do something (eg detailed player history etc..geographical location of clubs, population density, etc..) was worth proceeding with.
Be even easier if everyone just played for nothing though.
thebazza
Rookie
Not sure if you saw what was proposed s364376? Grange (and other clubs) objected to the system suggested by the league as it was too simplistic. It would have been of absolutely no benefit and did not do enough to reward development of local/junior players or help even up the competition and reduce financial pressure on clubs to be competitive. It would have just been a waste of time and volunteer effort.
Sportingpulse provides a great opportunity for detailed player history to be a part of the ranking as it is all there in a database - makes it easy to allocate points based on certain rules and for the points tally to be visible and automated when entering team sheet. As we all know there is a big difference between a 100+ senior game Ovens & Murray player and a 6 game O&M player who mostly played reserves, yet the system suggested did not distinguish and gave them both the same points value.
Grange have been pushing for a points system in preference to a salary cap for over 7 years, and in fact late last year volunteered to convene a working party of any clubs interested in helping to design and come up with an appropriate system that is easy to manage and actually does what is intended. All clubs could then decide whether a system designed for the league's specific circumstances and detailed enough to actually do something (eg detailed player history etc..geographical location of clubs, population density, etc..) was worth proceeding with.
Be even easier if everyone just played for nothing though.
Just out of curiosity, if we have a points system and lets say you have recruited well and have reached your alotted quota, whats happens when we reach the end of June and clubs get late recruits. If your maxed out on points does that mean you have to say, sorry mate, we cant have you here!! Thats the only downside i see. Or has Grange come up with a solution. And a noble idea mate, but the days of playing free for a club are well behind us.
Points system and whilst I`m not 100% sure how it works would certainly not suit Noosa with such a high player turnover rate each year.I`d imagine gold coast clubs would be in a similar boat.For example,Noosa had 11 different personell from their Grand final team in 2009 to the team that won it in 2010.Wilston grange makes some great points though,as does Bazza with recruits that turn up just prior to clearances ending.Do we need to even up the comp?Other than Mayne,all other competing PHC clubs have played finals at least in the past 5 or 6 years.Not sure if you saw what was proposed s364376? Grange (and other clubs) objected to the system suggested by the league as it was too simplistic. It would have been of absolutely no benefit and did not do enough to reward development of local/junior players or help even up the competition and reduce financial pressure on clubs to be competitive. It would have just been a waste of time and volunteer effort.
Sportingpulse provides a great opportunity for detailed player history to be a part of the ranking as it is all there in a database - makes it easy to allocate points based on certain rules and for the points tally to be visible and automated when entering team sheet. As we all know there is a big difference between a 100+ senior game Ovens & Murray player and a 6 game O&M player who mostly played reserves, yet the system suggested did not distinguish and gave them both the same points value.
Grange have been pushing for a points system in preference to a salary cap for over 7 years, and in fact late last year volunteered to convene a working party of any clubs interested in helping to design and come up with an appropriate system that is easy to manage and actually does what is intended. All clubs could then decide whether a system designed for the league's specific circumstances and detailed enough to actually do something (eg detailed player history etc..geographical location of clubs, population density, etc..) was worth proceeding with.
Be even easier if everyone just played for nothing though.
from what i understand about one of the proposed points system (which was similar to one in victoria), is that you can recruit whoever the hell you want, but you can only name a team that is under the points quota.
lucas matthews being a local boy, coming back a division i would say would get the minimum points (meaning you would pay him as much as possible to try and get him), as would any of your local players that have come through 18s etc. Any superstar players that have come from another local (less than 100km) club, would recieve the maximum points (to stop clubs with money poaching from local clubs that don't have money), and superstars that come from interstate, or from another town get middle of the range points.
that would mean that if people were to move to a town, they could relatively easily get signed up with a club who wouldn't necessarilly suffer harsh penalities. it would reward clubs who keep juniors from under 16s through to seniors (like springwood), as it would mean they have points available to poach.
in regards to players turning up mid season, if you have recruited and have your full quota of points, there are other clubs that the player can go to. it would mean that the comp is evened out a bit more as it doesn't necessarily advantage the clubs with money.
in reply to the grange bloke, i wasn't having a go at you, more just saying you sound like you have recruited well as you were very vocal in your opinion about starting something half arsed without any planning.
if you know afl qld like i know afl qld, they will spend 18 months commissioning a study in regards to whether or not clubs want the points system, then appoint someone fulltime for 2 years to come up with the points system policy, then right before the start of the season one club will object and it will all be thrown in the bin.
lucas matthews being a local boy, coming back a division i would say would get the minimum points (meaning you would pay him as much as possible to try and get him), as would any of your local players that have come through 18s etc. Any superstar players that have come from another local (less than 100km) club, would recieve the maximum points (to stop clubs with money poaching from local clubs that don't have money), and superstars that come from interstate, or from another town get middle of the range points.
that would mean that if people were to move to a town, they could relatively easily get signed up with a club who wouldn't necessarilly suffer harsh penalities. it would reward clubs who keep juniors from under 16s through to seniors (like springwood), as it would mean they have points available to poach.
in regards to players turning up mid season, if you have recruited and have your full quota of points, there are other clubs that the player can go to. it would mean that the comp is evened out a bit more as it doesn't necessarily advantage the clubs with money.
in reply to the grange bloke, i wasn't having a go at you, more just saying you sound like you have recruited well as you were very vocal in your opinion about starting something half arsed without any planning.
if you know afl qld like i know afl qld, they will spend 18 months commissioning a study in regards to whether or not clubs want the points system, then appoint someone fulltime for 2 years to come up with the points system policy, then right before the start of the season one club will object and it will all be thrown in the bin.
i think it would suit noosa. it would mean that you would have to play a couple more of your guys that have come through the system (which you have plenty of), but wouldn't penalise you harshly for getting someone from interstate.
it would mean that you wouldn't be able to take 2 of maroochys best midfielders in one year, prob have to take 1 now, 1 next year, then maybe sign whitey and ben matthews the year after
- Thread starter
- #298
Just for the record Mayne played finals in their first season in 2005 only losing to the eventual grand finalists PBC by 2 goals.
patrickmartin
Draftee
Not true at surfers the players play for nothing and any award money they get is raised by themselves doing raffles down the local pub.
Money is then split up between reserves and seniors and the workload shared among the playing group ,committee and supporters.
Speedyunit
All Australian
has that only happened recently? Tambaro wouldnt play for nothing surely....
- Status
