iluvdanielkerr
Senior List
daniel kerr is better than chris judd!!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
All Australian team at Half Way
- Thread starter AussieVamp2
- Start date
- Tagged users None
B: L.McPharlin ~ M.Scarlett ~ A.Jones
HB: R.Smith ~ C.Cornes ~ M.Lappin
C: L.Hayes ~ A.Simpson ~ J.Akermanis
HF: J.Hird ~ W.Tredrea ~ N.Riewoldt
F: N.G.Brown ~ F.Gehrig ~ B.Hall
R: J.White ~ P.Hasleby ~ S.Black
Int: M.Ricciuto ~ C.Judd ~ N.D.Brown ~ P.Everitt
Others: A.McPhee, Ben Johnson, M.Michael, M.Lloyd, N.Dal Santo
Brownlow: J.Hird / A.McLeod
Coleman: F.Gehrig
Rising Star: J.Rivers
Norm Smith: A.Jones
Premiers: St Kilda
AFLPA MVP: P.Hasleby
Best First Year player: A.Davey
HB: R.Smith ~ C.Cornes ~ M.Lappin
C: L.Hayes ~ A.Simpson ~ J.Akermanis
HF: J.Hird ~ W.Tredrea ~ N.Riewoldt
F: N.G.Brown ~ F.Gehrig ~ B.Hall
R: J.White ~ P.Hasleby ~ S.Black
Int: M.Ricciuto ~ C.Judd ~ N.D.Brown ~ P.Everitt
Others: A.McPhee, Ben Johnson, M.Michael, M.Lloyd, N.Dal Santo
Brownlow: J.Hird / A.McLeod
Coleman: F.Gehrig
Rising Star: J.Rivers
Norm Smith: A.Jones
Premiers: St Kilda
AFLPA MVP: P.Hasleby
Best First Year player: A.Davey
not from a Victorians point of view.
Hall has been marginally better than Fevola this year but yet some aren't even considering him?
Almost half of his goals come from outside 50 on tight angles... surely this would break the deadlock? 50/50 really.
Almost half of his goals come from outside 50 on tight angles... surely this would break the deadlock? 50/50 really.
iluvdanielkerr
Senior List
you victorians only love juddy cos he's a fellow victorian... daniel kerr has been rated higher than juddy this year
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #31
Been out drinking with Leo, Daniel?
Hate to burst your bubble but i think most people would choose Chris Judd and even Cousins who hasnt been at his peak this year over Kerr. Id say Judd has been the best eagle so far this year
Falchoon
Brownlow Medallist
- Feb 15, 2002
- 29,803
- 11,033
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Bluestar Airlines, Anacott Steel
Neitz
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #34
An interesting argument could be made for Mal Michael - again the best spoiler, so that good enough to get you the AA FB spot?
- Sep 9, 2003
- 27,578
- 28,760
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- FGR
I would have Harley ahead of Chad Cornes. Not based on stats of course, but in terms of beating your opponent consistently which is what key position defenders should be based on.
Chad Cornes racks up the stats, but he plays too loose for my liking.
Chad Cornes racks up the stats, but he plays too loose for my liking.
iluvdanielkerr
Senior List
hate to burst your bubble too, but check this out http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=115871
- Banned
- #37
Originally posted by AD_03
Step back and let me show you how its done
B: Nathan Brown (melb), Matthew Scarlett, Ben Johnson
HB: Aussie Jones, Chad Cornes, Matthew Lappin
C: Nick Dal Santo, Paul Hasleby, James Hird
HF: Jason Akermanis, Warren Tredrea, Nick Riewoldt
F: Phillip Matera, Fraser Gehrig, Brendan Fevola
FOLL: Jeff White, Chris Judd, Mark Ricciuto
INTER: Adam McPhee, Nigel Lappin, Luke McPharlin, Peter Everitt
That'll have to do.
this is the best team for AA so far in this thread.
the only thing i can see wrong with it is that there is only 2 tall defenders.
in which case i think harley or mcpharlin would be the next 2 tall backs in line but dont think they would be in front of any of the 4 small backs here
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #38
Although then might make McPharlin CHB and take Mal Michael at FB on the 'take the better defender' argument
- Jan 13, 2001
- 15,903
- 6,945
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Man City
The only problem with these teams is that they play no-one and really at the end of the day mean nothing, that's why we need a full weekend off and bring back state of origin footy. Even if you make it the end of the season and but the International Rules back to a bi-annual event rotating with state of origin.
Originally posted by iluvdanielkerr
hate to burst your bubble too, but check this out http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=115871
Yes, but thats voted on by the fans, who as you can say are biased. But from memory in the 'official' poles on TV and the papers have judd in front of kerr.
iluvdanielkerr
Senior List
really? as of two weeks ago kerr was ahead of judd in the official pole in the paper... but i haven't checked lately so you could be right.
anyway, there is no doubt that kerr is underrated, especially by Victorians...
Chad Cornes can not possibly get All Australian Center-Half-Back, the main reason is because he doesn’t play there, he plays loose man in the back line. Its out of McPharlin and Harley. Also anyone who doesn’t have Scarlett at full back has no idea
Neitz – 0
Lloyd – 2
Tredrea – 0
Rawlings – 0
Not bad last four weeks hey?
Neitz – 0
Lloyd – 2
Tredrea – 0
Rawlings – 0
Not bad last four weeks hey?
You are joking aren't you.Barry kills him in every stat category except goals where he is 3 behind.
He has taken 40 more marks more importantly from a forwards point of view.
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #44
yeah, contrasted with first few weeks though
and its not the last 4 weeks AA
or he'd be in ;-)
and its not the last 4 weeks AA
or he'd be in ;-)
Originally posted by iluvdanielkerr
really? as of two weeks ago kerr was ahead of judd in the official pole in the paper... but i haven't checked lately so you could be right.
anyway, there is no doubt that kerr is underrated, especially by Victorians...
I do agree with you that Kerr is underated and that would probably would be why Judd would get picked before Kerr if they has equal performances through the year. I just think in my opinion Judd has performed better, as Kerr can get a bit hotheaded when he is frustrated and lose frees for the team.
Its not whether Fevola makes the AA team. Its whether or not he would make the 2nd AA.
Possessions don't matter for full-forwards. And I said Hall is marginally better than Fevola. Stick Fevola into a team like the Saints and with the quality delivery he gets, he'll kick 100 no worries. Besides, Hall is more of a CHB type - but you're stupid if you think Fevola is not in his class in terms of a forward player.
Almost half his goals (16.4) have been outside 50 - and he's won matches for us this year. Has Hall won matches for his side this year? That saud, why can't they both be in at this stage? There is not much difference between the two at the moment - and doesn't Fev have more scoring shots at goal despite two 100+ thrashings?
And he would make that 2nd AA list. If Hall can make the first list and Fev just misses can't see why he can't fit into the 2nd side.
And what about the other matches? You can't just ignore seven other matches.
- Banned
- #50
they were pretty good too i think
