All Australian team at Half Way

[Fall Out Boy]

Scarlett's form dictates he simply must be there.

Since his poor first two weeks, he hasn't been beaten, and has destroyed some quality players like Neitz and Rawlings.

I'd also like to think that as pure CHB's go, Tom Harley would get serious consideration.

 

[AussieVamp2]

Yeah, don't think Michael has had more than 2 goals? Maybe Rocca?


Whereas 7 for Gehrig and 5 for Fevola is a few ;-)

 

[Barry Schneider]

Originally posted by Thrawn
Fevola has been marginally better than Hall this year but yet some are taking him over Fevola?

Almost half of his goals come from outside 50 on tight angles... surely this would break the deadlock? 50/50 really.

This what you said.
Fevola marginally better than Hall.Which I strongly disagree.Barry is our main goal scoring option but runs up the field when our players can't get it to him.
Nothing against Fevola but I don't think he is in the same class as Barry.

 

[lamby29]

B. Jones Scarlett McPhee
HB. Yze McPharlin N.Lappin
C. Judd Hasleby Power
HF. Hird Tredrea NG.Brown
F. Riewoldt Gehrig Matera
R. White Ricciuto Simpson
Int. Green, Everitt, Ball, Hall

Probably forgotten someone obvious.

 

[Thrawn]

Originally posted by Barry Schneider
This what you said.
Fevola marginally better than Hall.Which I strongly disagree.Barry is our main goal scoring option but runs up the field when our players can't get it to him.
Nothing against Fevola but I don't think he is in the same class as Barry.

Opps, apologies. Looking back at the marks both players have taken, I changed my mind. Swap the two around please, as I will do with my post.

And why isn't Fevola in the same class as Hall? Being third on the goalkicking ladder tells me that he is - including his sealer against the Crows, his wonderful kicking outside 50 and his matchwinning performances. And if you do watch a little bit more of Carlton, you will see that Fevola also works up the ground too.

 

[AussieVamp2]

Originally posted by iluvdanielkerr
hate to burst your bubble too, but check this out http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=115871

So they've all been out drinking too

Judd leads Kerr in disposals and is probably about number 1 in the league in both possessions and clearances

I think all the sober guys would take Judd ;-)

 

[skipper kelly]

Originally posted by Thrawn
And he would make that 2nd AA list. If Hall can make the first list and Fev just misses can't see why he can't fit into the 2nd side.

Thrawn. I didnt mention Hall. I wouldnt have Hall in the AA team ATM.

 

[Thrawn]

Originally posted by skipper kelly
Thrawn. I didnt mention Hall. I wouldnt have Hall in the AA team ATM.

I know you didn't mention Hall... I was taking example from other AA lists on this thread.

Wait until we get a top line midfield - may take a few years but Fevola is only 23. He is a step away from becoming a 100+ FF IMO.

 

[Barry Schneider]

Originally posted by Thrawn
Opps, apologies. Looking back at the marks both players have taken, I changed my mind. Swap the two around please, as I will do with my post.

And why isn't Fevola in the same class as Hall? Being third on the goalkicking ladder tells me that he is - including his sealer against the Crows, his wonderful kicking outside 50 and his matchwinning performances. And if you do watch a little bit more of Carlton, you will see that Fevola also works up the ground too.

I just think Fevola is not as consistent and as hard working as Barry.I admit I haven't seen much of Carlton but I did enjoy that wonderful victory over Collingwood.
I think Fevola is more brilliant than Barry and can kick bigger bags of goals but he is not as consistent.As to winning matches without Barry we would not have won a game and will not win another.He is vital to us.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Originally posted by AussieVamp2
Yeah, don't think Michael has had more than 2 goals? Maybe Rocca?

Everitt and Neitz (moved onto Neitz after about 10 minutes).

But yes, an outstanding defender is Mal Michael.

Originally posted by AussieVamp2


Whereas 7 for Gehrig and 5 for Fevola is a few ;-)

And since then, he has kept Hall and Lloyd to 2 goals, Tredrea to 1, Neitz and Rawlings goalless.

Two bad weeks, followed by 9 outstanding ones.

 

[skipper kelly]

Originally posted by Thrawn
I know you didn't mention Hall... I was taking example from other AA lists on this thread.

Wait until we get a top line midfield - may take a few years but Fevola is only 23. He is a step away from becoming a 100+ FF IMO.

Very good player ATM. Potential 100 a year player. But not there yet and certainly not AA after 11 rounds.

 

[AD_03]

Originally posted by iluvdanielkerr
daniel kerr is better than chris judd!!!

Sorry but no! Kerr is underrated anywhere out of WA, but he is not up to Judd's standard. You can argue your point all you like but its hard to take you seriously on this topic when your username is 'iluvedanielkerr' and you have your location as 'under daniel kerrs bed' .

Any person without a biased point of view would take Judd 99/100 times.

 

[AussieVamp2]

yeah, so that would be 11 outstanding weeks for Mal Michael then

 

[AD_03]

I think Dal Santo should be in everyones team.

 

[AussieVamp2]

and think Troy Simmonds got 5 as well?

 

[welshy12]

from a bombers point of view there are two certainties

mcphee and hird

maybe lloyd in a pocket, but think can only fit gehrig out of the ff.

lloyd has been better than fevola and hall though.

mcphee definently is a cert. 5 games at least where he has been in the top 3 on the ground. in rare touch.

 

[skipper kelly]

Originally posted by welshy12
from a bombers point of view there are two certainties

mcphee and hird

maybe lloyd in a pocket, but think can only fit gehrig out of the ff.

lloyd has been better than fevola and hall though.

mcphee definently is a cert. 5 games at least where he has been in the top 3 on the ground. in rare touch.

Hall has clearly had a better 11 weeks than Lloyd.

 

[welshy12]

please explain how hall has been better?

 

[skipper kelly]

Originally posted by welshy12
please explain how hall has been better?

You made the call my friend. The onus is on you.

 

[AussieVamp2]

Why McPhee, he has played well, and would appear to be quite improved

but only around 17 disposals a game, not a league leader in clearances or possessions or anything

and would be near the top of the league in giving away frees from what I have seen

don't see how that makes him an All Australian?

 

[benbergin]

Originally posted by AussieVamp2
but only around 17 disposals a game, not a league leader in clearances or possessions or anything

not his job (mcphee)

 

[westernnugget]

Riewolt????????????

 

[AussieVamp2]

It is not his job to get the ball??

 

[Barry Schneider]

Originally posted by welshy12
please explain how hall has been better?

28 more marks,47 more disposals, LLoyd has 8 more goals but received 9 more free kicks.Hall has to work for his goals LLoyd gets quite a few given to him.

 

[skipper kelly]

Originally posted by Barry Schneider
28 more marks,47 more disposals, LLoyd has 8 more goals but received 9 more free kicks.Hall has to work for his goals LLoyd gets quite a few given to him.

Thanks Barry. Add in that Hall is not a sook and doesnt stage for free kicks. Plus plays further away from goal and will always give off to someone in a better position.