-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
All Australian team at Half Way
- Thread starter AussieVamp2
- Start date
- Tagged users None
McPhee would be an absolute certainty at this stage of the year to get AA
- Jul 3, 2001
- 22,488
- 9,423
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Heat, Victory, Man Utd, Redskins
I'll have a crack.
B: Ben Johnson (Col) Matthew Scarlett (Gee) Austinn Jones (StK)
HB: Luke McPharlin (Fre) Chad Cornes (PA) Adam McPhee (Ess)
C: Chris Judd (WCE) Lenny Hayes (StK) Nigel Lappin (Bris)
HF: Nathan G Brown (Ric) Warren Tredrea (PA) <reserved for C Tarrant (Col)>
F: Philip Matera (WCE) Fraser Gehrig (StK) Matthew Lloyd (Ess)
Foll: Jeff White (Mel) James Hird (Ess) Paul Haselby (Fre)
Inter: Adem Yze (Mel) Simon Black (Bri) Nick Dal Santo (StK) Mark Riciutto (Ade)
B: Ben Johnson (Col) Matthew Scarlett (Gee) Austinn Jones (StK)
HB: Luke McPharlin (Fre) Chad Cornes (PA) Adam McPhee (Ess)
C: Chris Judd (WCE) Lenny Hayes (StK) Nigel Lappin (Bris)
HF: Nathan G Brown (Ric) Warren Tredrea (PA) <reserved for C Tarrant (Col)>
F: Philip Matera (WCE) Fraser Gehrig (StK) Matthew Lloyd (Ess)
Foll: Jeff White (Mel) James Hird (Ess) Paul Haselby (Fre)
Inter: Adem Yze (Mel) Simon Black (Bri) Nick Dal Santo (StK) Mark Riciutto (Ade)
Frankly I think at times fans that vote in polls like this probably know more then the so called experts. I get continually frustrated how soem big name players get included into best week in week out when they lesser known players are clearly performiing better.
For whats it worth I think Judd > Kerr, because his disposal is cleaner though Kerr is closing the gap very quickly.
Jimmae
Brownlow Medallist
The fact of the matter is, you can't make up an All-Australian team these days... better off having two and then playing them against each other.
Bit stiff on Matthew Lappin!
Everyone has missed Leo Barry.Played on Lloyd, restricting him to **** all except for ****ing soft free kicks.
Played on that guy from the Hawks, shooter guy.Who did nothing.
Played on Gehrig at full back, got 23 touches and restricting Gehrig to two handballs, no goals.Gehrig went off the ground, Barry moved too Hamill who had no influence after Leo was moved.
Star.
Played on that guy from the Hawks, shooter guy.Who did nothing.
Played on Gehrig at full back, got 23 touches and restricting Gehrig to two handballs, no goals.Gehrig went off the ground, Barry moved too Hamill who had no influence after Leo was moved.
Star.
B: L.McPharlin ~ M.Scarlett ~ A. Jones
HB: M. Lappin ~ C.Cornes ~ A. McPhee
C: L.Hayes ~ M. Riccutio ~ N. Lappin
HF: J. Hird ~ W.Tredrea ~ N.Riewoldt
F: N.G.Brown ~ F.Gehrig ~ B.Hall
R: J.White ~ P.Hasleby ~ C. Judd
Int: J. Akermanis ~ Adem Yze~ Ben Johnson~ P.Everitt
Others: Dal santo, A. Simpson, Lloyd, Kirk
Brownlow: N. Lappin
Coleman: M. Lloyd
Rising Star: J.Rivers
Norm Smith: N. Lappin
Premiers: Brisbane
AFLPA MVP: P.Hasleby
Best First Year player: G. Richards
HB: M. Lappin ~ C.Cornes ~ A. McPhee
C: L.Hayes ~ M. Riccutio ~ N. Lappin
HF: J. Hird ~ W.Tredrea ~ N.Riewoldt
F: N.G.Brown ~ F.Gehrig ~ B.Hall
R: J.White ~ P.Hasleby ~ C. Judd
Int: J. Akermanis ~ Adem Yze~ Ben Johnson~ P.Everitt
Others: Dal santo, A. Simpson, Lloyd, Kirk
Brownlow: N. Lappin
Coleman: M. Lloyd
Rising Star: J.Rivers
Norm Smith: N. Lappin
Premiers: Brisbane
AFLPA MVP: P.Hasleby
Best First Year player: G. Richards
tim_smith321
Debutant
dont bagg me if u disagree
B: McPhee-Scarlett-B.Johnson
HB: Yze-McPharlin-M.Lappin
C: N.Lappin-Haselby-Simpson
HF: Pavlich-Tredrea-Riewoldt
F: L.Power-Lloyd-N.G Brown
R: White-Riccuto-Judd
I: Fevola-Bell-West-Gehrig
EMG: Dal Santo-Everitt-A.Jones-B.Hall
wat do yaz think?
B: McPhee-Scarlett-B.Johnson
HB: Yze-McPharlin-M.Lappin
C: N.Lappin-Haselby-Simpson
HF: Pavlich-Tredrea-Riewoldt
F: L.Power-Lloyd-N.G Brown
R: White-Riccuto-Judd
I: Fevola-Bell-West-Gehrig
EMG: Dal Santo-Everitt-A.Jones-B.Hall
wat do yaz think?
I wasn't saying all fans are biased, just some can be. I know I can be at times towards my favs, but i do agree with you that some fans do know more than 'experts'.
Generally ruckman are the only talls to start on the bench, so all those with Hall there put him at CHF.
Westener
Debutant
Good teams, all.
But what about the opposition? Are they any good?
Who will win?
Picking an All-Australian Team is just a follow on from a w*nk American Tradition.
Means absolutely nothing if there is no opposition.
But what about the opposition? Are they any good?
Who will win?
Picking an All-Australian Team is just a follow on from a w*nk American Tradition.
Means absolutely nothing if there is no opposition.
koutawalker
Team Captain
Thonrton in the backline 
- Apr 2, 2000
- 75,611
- 25,387
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Only 4 players with any sort of chance from WC this year. Judd, Kerr, Cousins and Matera.
You would think on current form that Judd and Matera are certs and Cousins is always around the mark. But us WC fans have Kerr leading the BFWCPOTY after 7 rounds, yet to tally the last 4 rounds because im slack.
All 4 are chances, depends on how the second half of the year pans out. All 4 wont make it however 3 might, depending on how Cousins second half of the year goes.
You would think on current form that Judd and Matera are certs and Cousins is always around the mark. But us WC fans have Kerr leading the BFWCPOTY after 7 rounds, yet to tally the last 4 rounds because im slack.
All 4 are chances, depends on how the second half of the year pans out. All 4 wont make it however 3 might, depending on how Cousins second half of the year goes.
- Feb 28, 2003
- 15,060
- 80
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- The Washington Generals
1 player missed by half of the experts on here - Adam Simpson.
Club loyalties aside - he'd be one of the 1st few picked (and our only rep in the AA)
His stats season to date:
Marks - 67 (ranked 13th in AFL)
Disposals - 299 (ranked 1 in AFL)
Kicks - 177 (ranked 5th in AFL)
Tackles - 30 (ranked 53rd in AFL)
Hit Outs - 21 (ranked 52nd in AFL)
I don't have the stats for centre clearances - but he'd be up near the top of the list - another of his assets.
Either on the ball as R/R or in the guts.
Club loyalties aside - he'd be one of the 1st few picked (and our only rep in the AA)
His stats season to date:
Marks - 67 (ranked 13th in AFL)
Disposals - 299 (ranked 1 in AFL)
Kicks - 177 (ranked 5th in AFL)
Tackles - 30 (ranked 53rd in AFL)
Hit Outs - 21 (ranked 52nd in AFL)
I don't have the stats for centre clearances - but he'd be up near the top of the list - another of his assets.
Either on the ball as R/R or in the guts.
You have no idea how back men play, do you?
I dont believe one of your favourite sons, 'leach' Silvagni, ever averaged 17 possies a game. Think of all the spoils, taps, tackles, etc that backmen get. Now think about how 17 possessions is a hell of a lot for a backman...
You would kill for McPhee in the Carlton backline at the moment.
Now fellas this is what it'll look like at seasons end
B: Leo Barry, Matthew Scarlett, Aussie Jones
HB: Luke McPharlin, Chad Cornes, Adam McPhee
C: Paul Haselby, Lenny Hayes, Mark Riccutio(VC)
HF: Jimmy Hird(C), Barry Hall, Warren Tredrea
F: Fido Matera, Fraser Gehrig, Matthew Lloyd
R: Jeff White, Chris Judd, Simon Black
Int: Paul Williams, Nic Riewoldt, Peter Everitt, Nigel Lappin
Well a good guess anyway?
B: Leo Barry, Matthew Scarlett, Aussie Jones
HB: Luke McPharlin, Chad Cornes, Adam McPhee
C: Paul Haselby, Lenny Hayes, Mark Riccutio(VC)
HF: Jimmy Hird(C), Barry Hall, Warren Tredrea
F: Fido Matera, Fraser Gehrig, Matthew Lloyd
R: Jeff White, Chris Judd, Simon Black
Int: Paul Williams, Nic Riewoldt, Peter Everitt, Nigel Lappin
Well a good guess anyway?
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #96
Yeah, but he was a full back, 17 not a lot for a run around the ground flanker type.
The Swans guy has done better than that this year ;-)
and a backman giving away a lot of frees? Not good.
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #97
Take McLeod ahead of McPhee, too, if we want to talk backmen this year ;-)
- Banned
- #98
Simpson and Barry are certanties
If the Australian Side had to play another country you would probably pick Scarley AND Harley because of their fantastic teamwork and amazing defense.
And isnt the All Australian selection based on form over a number of years not just "11 Rounds"
Scarlett had two bad games at the start of the year
If the Australian Side had to play another country you would probably pick Scarley AND Harley because of their fantastic teamwork and amazing defense.
And isnt the All Australian selection based on form over a number of years not just "11 Rounds"
Scarlett had two bad games at the start of the year
AussieVamp2
Debutant
- Jan 14, 2000
- 61
- 11
- Other Teams
- Carlton
- Thread starter
- #99
'It' might be, but this is not.
3 bad games by the looks, which out of 11, is a lot.
And certainlyl a hell of a lot more than none.
Why would you do that??? My idea of the AA team is that the best player for each position is in. Phil matera is the best forward pocket player, so he deserves to be in the team in that position
