Opinion Ben Sinclair - Never again

[Stifler's mom]

Surely he can't play any more senior games.

Has never been any good.
Isn't any good.
Will never be any good.


Forward press blah blah blah!

The kid hasn't got enough upside.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

Poor Benny.

 

[blaze036]

He isn't that bad, but i think Mooney takes his spot ASAP.

Will be good depth. IF he can fix his kicking will be a good player

 

[chop_me]

He isn't that bad, but i think Mooney takes his spot ASAP.

Will be good depth. IF he can fix his kicking will be a good player

But how many players have actually fixed their kicking?

Toovey is the only one I can think of

 

[dansa]

Surely he can't play any more senior games.

Has never been any good.
Isn't any good.
Will never be any good.


Forward press blah blah blah!

The kid hasn't got enough upside.

Terrible over reaction thread.

 

[Stifler's mom]

He isn't that bad, but i think Mooney takes his spot ASAP.

Will be good depth. IF he can fix his kicking will be a good player

His kicking is unlikely to be able to be fixed IMO.

Billy has taken his spot.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Terrible over reaction thread.

I have felt this way for 12 months and frustration got the better of me tonight.

 

[istillbelieve]

He isn't that bad, but i think Mooney takes his spot ASAP.

Will be good depth. IF he can fix his kicking will be a good player

Mooney can't take his spot, still on rookie list.

 

[istillbelieve]

A lot more issues than Sinclair atm, Shaw's brain fades being the most pressing.

 

[glasseye]

we

But how many players have actually fixed their kicking?

Toovey is the only one I can think of

well Cloke had a bad spell for a while there; that got fixed, Big Ant kept missing the easy ones for while and he came good - Sinclair didn't have a good day, could be time to find his form in the VFL

 

[RuFiO]

We are the Power from Port!
It's more than a sport!

I mean he tackles good! Real good!

 

[Pera]

He's 21.

And he has plenty of upside.

 

[mattys123]

He can tackle, he can harass, but he can't do anything else.

He is a good old fashioned "goer", he tries hard, but the longer he is in our 22 the worse we will become.

He's depth at best.

 

[Drizt]

His only asset is pace. Not enough to keep his spot in the team.

He gets pushed off the ball like he is a 12 year old girl. Not good enough.

 

[SuperSub17]

Surely he can't play any more senior games.

Has never been any good.
Isn't any good.
Will never be any good.


Forward press blah blah blah!

The kid hasn't got enough upside.

Bit of an overreaction, he had a bad game. That happens from time to time, especially as a small forward - its the hardest position to play IMO.

But we miss Krakouer and Didak's skills in the forward line badly

 

[Old Spice]

It's always going to be an issue with small forwards who aren't crumbers or don't have aerial skills. I think he plays a good role for us now, but at some point he will be overtaken.

Still, I agree that he was not our biggest problem, but he needs to put manic pressure on every week to keep in the side. Don't agree with dropping him though. If we had a full squad, then that makes sense.

 

[TheFreshBanana]

I'd drop him this week, but jeez, you guys are being a bit harsh and overdramatic.

He's still a kid, potential is unknown. Get a grip.

 

[Pedro]

He can tackle, he can harass, but he can't do anything else.

He is a good old fashioned "goer", he tries hard, but the longer he is in our 22 the worse we will become.

He's depth at best.

Jason Wild, Luke Godden.........Having said that , he must be doing something right. The match committee see it, but I'm not sure that I do. Pressure alone can't be it.

 

[aflife]

People judge this kid weekly! One week its how good he is next he is crap. He has value. And hopefully can learn to kick better

 

[mattys123]

Jason Wild, Luke Godden.........Having said that , he must be doing something right. The match committee see it, but I'm not sure that I do. Pressure alone can't be it.

The match committee are obsessed with this forward pressure thing, I'd prefer forwards who actually kicks goals and place pressure on.

 

[Staki_13]

The match committee are obsessed with this forward pressure thing, I'd prefer forwards who actually kicks goals and place pressure on.

I agree, prefer Macaffer who can do both

 

[Pedro]

Can't

People judge this kid weekly! One week its how good he is next he is crap. He has value. And hopefully can learn to kick better

Sorry, but I can't ever remember marvelling at how good he is. I respect the fact the he's out there trying his best, but I just don't think he cuts the mustard. I would be happier seeing Krak, Kennedy, Seedsman, Martin, Mooney and probably others in ahead of him

 

[Shade]

People judge this kid weekly! One week its how good he is next he is crap. He has value. And hopefully can learn to kick better

Will be one of these types his entire career one side will think hes good the other rubbish.

 

[half_back_flank]

I'd drop him this week, but jeez, you guys are being a bit harsh and overdramatic.

He's still a kid, potential is unknown. Get a grip.

Agree, he does a lot of things right and there is little wrong with his field kicking.

Needs to come back next year bigger and stronger though.

 

[Chronz]

Get Caff back in and let Sinclair have a spell in the VFL.