Kong
Hall of Famer
- Oct 11, 2007
- 32,128
- 16,742
- AFL Club
- Essendon
You tell us; you're the football guru around here.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
VFL Game Day Bendigo 2010
- Thread starter ant555
- Start date
- Tagged users None
YouveBeenReimered
Team Captain
Thanks for that mate. Good news. Is Hurley playing up forward or down back?
lemon chicken
Cancelled
Hurley fwd has kicked at least 2
Colyer is not ready adjusting still to pace of senior football rushes a lot of his kicks
Hurley just kicked another
134. To 78. 10 mins to go
Colyer is not ready adjusting still to pace of senior football rushes a lot of his kicks
Hurley just kicked another
134. To 78. 10 mins to go
YouveBeenReimered
Team Captain
Good win then
To solid wins in a row is a great start!! Lets hope they can continue this form when the real stuff starts.
Ess having a small injury list will definately help!!
Ess having a small injury list will definately help!!
Bendigo Practice Match Report vs. Casey Scorpions
The result of the game was almost meaningless given that we were playing the Melbourne reserves and had a side that contained 23 Essendon listed players. We played with 26 players to ensure that all players got some decent TOG. I think we scored 20.22 to 12 goals.
Rather than talking about the game I’ll go through each player as that is what everyone is interested in. I’ve taken stats for each player but I would probably allow an extra 5-10% total possessions for each player.
Abbreviations are (K-kick, HB – handball, M- mark , G-goal, B-behind, T- tackle – H/O –hitout to advantage, C - clangers
Jake Carlisle
3K – 7HB – 4M – 1T
Played his entire TOG as a half forward presenting up and then doubling back deep forward. Was part of the forward line rotation with Hurley, Still and Daniher (generally 2 up forward at a time). He has exceptional hands below his knees and took a great mark at his ankles running at full pace. The kid has talent and will do well at Bendigo as the season progresses. Also made good decisions.
Mark McVeigh
12K – 7HB – 2M – 2T – 2G
Was the ideal tune up for him leading into the Fremantle game next week. He started the first quarter at half back and then spent the rest of the match in the guts. He looked a class above everyone else out there as you would hope he would. Didn’t win a stack of it as his TOG was managed but won plenty of hard ball and clearances. Kicked well for goal also. He cramped up at the end in his calf but he will be fine.
Anthony Long
4K – 15HB – 1C – 3T – 3M
Played off half back in the ‘Dempsey’ role that seems in vogue. He didn’t really get into the game until the 2nd half in which he started to cut off a lot of attack patrolling the area between CHB and the Centre Square. Was reluctant to kick the ball until the last quarter which put a couple of teammates under pressure, but as he became more confident he provided a lot of drive. You can see that he reads the play very well and is very calm under pressure. Looks the goods.
Sam Lonergan
9K – 8HB – 3M – 2G
It took him a half to really get into the game but he got better as the match progressed. Kicked some nice goals on the lead when playing deep forward for short periods (Winderlich style). Worked really well with Bellchambers and McVeigh in the centre clearances in the last quarter with the 3 combining to win 4 clearances in a row. I’m not sure he did enough to replace Howlett next week though, although he could provide the extra forward option.
Jake Melksham
9K – 7HB – 4M – 1T – 1C - 1G
Spent his time on the wing and little in the centre. He has the confidence to take the game on and make the play which is encouraging. A couple of times he lacked awareness and was chased down. His skills were clean and he managed to run to the right spots when in space. I don’t think he is ready just yet but could play seniors later in the season as he gets a higher level of fitness.
Michael Hurley
12K – 1HB – 7M – 3G -2B
Played exclusively up forward as per Knights’ announcement 2 weeks ago – by forward I mean CHF. Was part of the same forward rotation and didn’t really hit his straps until the last 45 minutes of the game (5 of his 6 scoring shots were in the last quarter). His first 3 kicks were from marks on the lead and then swung around on his left foot and pumped it into the 50. His hands weren’t quite as clean as usual but he worked hard on the lead and presented well. Was a little sore at the end of the game but nothing to concern ourselves with. Didn’t appear to have any issue with his thumb (which was strapped). Will be ready to fire Round 4.
David Myers
8K – 9HB – 1C
Played exclusively in the back line. He was also the designated kick out when he was on the ground. His kicking was quite good today in field play although some of his long bomb kick outs went straight to the opposition. His work in close is excellent. There are times when he will hit a pack get the ball and feed it out with 3 opposition players around him. Defensively he was sold and he looked to be running freely. Another few weeks to gain match fitness then he will put his hand up for selection.
John Williams
8K – 12HB – 4M – 2C
He played HBF for the entire match and really impressed me with his work rate and ball winning ability. He attacks the contest hard and provided plenty of drive. He made a few bad errors which you would expect from a player in a new role but showed enough promise to make me think he could be work persevering with. Didn’t try to take any species just spoilt his opponent.
Michael Still
3K – 6HB - 4M – 2B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He presented well and took some solid marks leading up the ground. Should have kicked 2 but missed them. Looks to have very good hands in a contested marking situation and his second efforts at ground level today were also very good. It will be good to see him develop as the season progresses.
Jason Laycock
2K – 7HB – 1G - 1T – 6H/O
The 3 ruckman rotated with 1 in the ruck, 1 FF and the other on the bench. Laycock was the 2nd choice ruckman and started FF. The stats don’t look great but his work rate today was exceptional. He has picked up his pace and was chasing midfielders and defenders all day with great intent. His hands looked good when he was on the lead and his ruckwork got better as the match wore on. However I think Bellchambers may have the running for next week if Hille is suspended.
Darcy Daniher
7K – 3HB – 4M – 1T – 2G – 1B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He started really well but had less TOG in the 2nd half as they used Hurley more frequently. He took some solid pack marks and generally used the ball quite well. Also did some good crumbing work up forward and created some chances. I thought he was quite solid without being a standout.
Travis Colyer
4K – 4HB – 1G -1B - 2T
Kicked a sensational goal running through the midfield and get a 1-2 (similar to the YouTube footage from the TAC Cup). He started in the midfield and then spent more time down forward as a crumber. He didn’t win a lot of the ball but what he did when he had it was good. His size didn’t appear to be an issue at all and he went in hard for the ball.
Kyle Hardingham
12K – 3HB – 3M
Was rotating with Myers down back but would also find himself at FB at times. He looked quite solid in defence and provided a bit of drive from HBF. His spoiling was also quite good and he won some solid ball in close. His use of the ball was good without being fantastic. I wouldn’t have him in the seniors yet though.
Taite Silverlock
10K – 6HB – 2M – 2T – 4C
Spent time in the centre square in the first half and then time up forward in the second half. He is quick and has an excellent ability to win the ball and get 2-3 possessions in the same chain of play. His kicking today was quite ordinary at times as he was trying to do too much. He goes in hard and laid some solid tackles.
Tyson Slattery
6K – 5HB – 3M – 1T
Played in the back half and looked like he had missed a chunk of pre season. He was tired at the end which you would expect. He linked up well with Myers at times when running the ball out of defence. His disposal still needs a little bit of work but he just needs a solid month of training behind him before we see him start to hit his straps.
Jarrod Atkinson
4K – 8HB – 1B
Played off the back flank and hardly saw the ball until the last 45 minutes. Gave away a stupid 50 when he was sucked in by Newton. He tries hard but I just don’t see him in the Best 22. He runs over the ball, his disposal is a little suspect and he isn’t tight enough on his opponent. He looks the same player he was when I watched Bendigo reserves 9 months ago (and he got a senior spot 4 weeks later) so who knows.
Michael Quinn
8K – 6HB – 3M – 4T
Played half forward and he looks like a footballer now. You don’t get the sense of confusion when he has the ball as he is much more settled and aware. His use of the ball was good and his pressure was also excellent. Didn’t win a lot of the ball but he did win some contested possessions which was great to see. Had some nice goal assists.
Bachar Houli
13K – 8HB – 5M – 1B
Was playing on the wing for the entire game. I thought he was quite good today. He accumulated the ball and set up quite a bit of play from the HBF on the rebound. He made a few errors with his handball but nothing to be too concerned about. He chased well today I thought and wouldn’t be too far from pushing for a senior spot.
Nathan Lovett Murray
14K – 7HB – 5M – 2G – 1B – 1C
Played exclusively in the centre square today. He dominated the first quarter and was part of everything. He wins the hard ball so well that perhaps he could spend some time in the square this season to assist the likes of Jobe. He had plenty of running bounces forward of the centre today and should have kicked a few more goals. He looks very fit and primed to slot into the seniors Round 3.
Tom Bellchambers
4K – 5HB – 5M – 13H/O – 2B
He really impressed me today with his ruckwork and work around the ground. He looks a terrific athlete. His work in the centre square with Lonergan, McVeigh and NLM was outstanding. He also took some terrific contested marks up forward and should’ve had 2 goals. I would have him before Laycock if we were looking for a pure ruckman to replace Hille next week. He is going to be a very good player.
Stuart Crameri
5K – 7HB – 3M – 1G
He is a solidly built player and played a bit of everywhere today. His left foot disposal is good but his handballing is an issue. Too many times he would miss targets or put teammates under pressure. Has good tackling pressure and impacts contests. Will be solid for Bendigo again this season.
Christian Bock
2K – 5HB – 2G – 1B 1M – 1T 3H/O
Part of the 3 ruckman combination. He actually looked very sharp up forward and got into good positions deep to score his two goals. His work around the ground also improved dramatically from what we saw in the NAB Cup. He competed well in the ruck without being too effective. He is improving with each game which is what you want from a rookie listed ruckman.
Marcus Marigliani
6K – 10HB – 2M – 5T – 1G
Was in everything in the first quarter when given time in the centre square. He hits the contest hard and throws his body into everything. He didn’t get as much opportunity in the middle after quarter time and also had a hit to the nose which bled for a while. He is a wholehearted player he gives you everything in the Luke Ball mould (without being anywhere near as good). Solid right foot disposal.
The result of the game was almost meaningless given that we were playing the Melbourne reserves and had a side that contained 23 Essendon listed players. We played with 26 players to ensure that all players got some decent TOG. I think we scored 20.22 to 12 goals.
Rather than talking about the game I’ll go through each player as that is what everyone is interested in. I’ve taken stats for each player but I would probably allow an extra 5-10% total possessions for each player.
Abbreviations are (K-kick, HB – handball, M- mark , G-goal, B-behind, T- tackle – H/O –hitout to advantage, C - clangers
Jake Carlisle
3K – 7HB – 4M – 1T
Played his entire TOG as a half forward presenting up and then doubling back deep forward. Was part of the forward line rotation with Hurley, Still and Daniher (generally 2 up forward at a time). He has exceptional hands below his knees and took a great mark at his ankles running at full pace. The kid has talent and will do well at Bendigo as the season progresses. Also made good decisions.
Mark McVeigh
12K – 7HB – 2M – 2T – 2G
Was the ideal tune up for him leading into the Fremantle game next week. He started the first quarter at half back and then spent the rest of the match in the guts. He looked a class above everyone else out there as you would hope he would. Didn’t win a stack of it as his TOG was managed but won plenty of hard ball and clearances. Kicked well for goal also. He cramped up at the end in his calf but he will be fine.
Anthony Long
4K – 15HB – 1C – 3T – 3M
Played off half back in the ‘Dempsey’ role that seems in vogue. He didn’t really get into the game until the 2nd half in which he started to cut off a lot of attack patrolling the area between CHB and the Centre Square. Was reluctant to kick the ball until the last quarter which put a couple of teammates under pressure, but as he became more confident he provided a lot of drive. You can see that he reads the play very well and is very calm under pressure. Looks the goods.
Sam Lonergan
9K – 8HB – 3M – 2G
It took him a half to really get into the game but he got better as the match progressed. Kicked some nice goals on the lead when playing deep forward for short periods (Winderlich style). Worked really well with Bellchambers and McVeigh in the centre clearances in the last quarter with the 3 combining to win 4 clearances in a row. I’m not sure he did enough to replace Howlett next week though, although he could provide the extra forward option.
Jake Melksham
9K – 7HB – 4M – 1T – 1C - 1G
Spent his time on the wing and little in the centre. He has the confidence to take the game on and make the play which is encouraging. A couple of times he lacked awareness and was chased down. His skills were clean and he managed to run to the right spots when in space. I don’t think he is ready just yet but could play seniors later in the season as he gets a higher level of fitness.
Michael Hurley
12K – 1HB – 7M – 3G -2B
Played exclusively up forward as per Knights’ announcement 2 weeks ago – by forward I mean CHF. Was part of the same forward rotation and didn’t really hit his straps until the last 45 minutes of the game (5 of his 6 scoring shots were in the last quarter). His first 3 kicks were from marks on the lead and then swung around on his left foot and pumped it into the 50. His hands weren’t quite as clean as usual but he worked hard on the lead and presented well. Was a little sore at the end of the game but nothing to concern ourselves with. Didn’t appear to have any issue with his thumb (which was strapped). Will be ready to fire Round 4.
David Myers
8K – 9HB – 1C
Played exclusively in the back line. He was also the designated kick out when he was on the ground. His kicking was quite good today in field play although some of his long bomb kick outs went straight to the opposition. His work in close is excellent. There are times when he will hit a pack get the ball and feed it out with 3 opposition players around him. Defensively he was sold and he looked to be running freely. Another few weeks to gain match fitness then he will put his hand up for selection.
John Williams
8K – 12HB – 4M – 2C
He played HBF for the entire match and really impressed me with his work rate and ball winning ability. He attacks the contest hard and provided plenty of drive. He made a few bad errors which you would expect from a player in a new role but showed enough promise to make me think he could be work persevering with. Didn’t try to take any species just spoilt his opponent.
Michael Still
3K – 6HB - 4M – 2B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He presented well and took some solid marks leading up the ground. Should have kicked 2 but missed them. Looks to have very good hands in a contested marking situation and his second efforts at ground level today were also very good. It will be good to see him develop as the season progresses.
Jason Laycock
2K – 7HB – 1G - 1T – 6H/O
The 3 ruckman rotated with 1 in the ruck, 1 FF and the other on the bench. Laycock was the 2nd choice ruckman and started FF. The stats don’t look great but his work rate today was exceptional. He has picked up his pace and was chasing midfielders and defenders all day with great intent. His hands looked good when he was on the lead and his ruckwork got better as the match wore on. However I think Bellchambers may have the running for next week if Hille is suspended.
Darcy Daniher
7K – 3HB – 4M – 1T – 2G – 1B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He started really well but had less TOG in the 2nd half as they used Hurley more frequently. He took some solid pack marks and generally used the ball quite well. Also did some good crumbing work up forward and created some chances. I thought he was quite solid without being a standout.
Travis Colyer
4K – 4HB – 1G -1B - 2T
Kicked a sensational goal running through the midfield and get a 1-2 (similar to the YouTube footage from the TAC Cup). He started in the midfield and then spent more time down forward as a crumber. He didn’t win a lot of the ball but what he did when he had it was good. His size didn’t appear to be an issue at all and he went in hard for the ball.
Kyle Hardingham
12K – 3HB – 3M
Was rotating with Myers down back but would also find himself at FB at times. He looked quite solid in defence and provided a bit of drive from HBF. His spoiling was also quite good and he won some solid ball in close. His use of the ball was good without being fantastic. I wouldn’t have him in the seniors yet though.
Taite Silverlock
10K – 6HB – 2M – 2T – 4C
Spent time in the centre square in the first half and then time up forward in the second half. He is quick and has an excellent ability to win the ball and get 2-3 possessions in the same chain of play. His kicking today was quite ordinary at times as he was trying to do too much. He goes in hard and laid some solid tackles.
Tyson Slattery
6K – 5HB – 3M – 1T
Played in the back half and looked like he had missed a chunk of pre season. He was tired at the end which you would expect. He linked up well with Myers at times when running the ball out of defence. His disposal still needs a little bit of work but he just needs a solid month of training behind him before we see him start to hit his straps.
Jarrod Atkinson
4K – 8HB – 1B
Played off the back flank and hardly saw the ball until the last 45 minutes. Gave away a stupid 50 when he was sucked in by Newton. He tries hard but I just don’t see him in the Best 22. He runs over the ball, his disposal is a little suspect and he isn’t tight enough on his opponent. He looks the same player he was when I watched Bendigo reserves 9 months ago (and he got a senior spot 4 weeks later) so who knows.
Michael Quinn
8K – 6HB – 3M – 4T
Played half forward and he looks like a footballer now. You don’t get the sense of confusion when he has the ball as he is much more settled and aware. His use of the ball was good and his pressure was also excellent. Didn’t win a lot of the ball but he did win some contested possessions which was great to see. Had some nice goal assists.
Bachar Houli
13K – 8HB – 5M – 1B
Was playing on the wing for the entire game. I thought he was quite good today. He accumulated the ball and set up quite a bit of play from the HBF on the rebound. He made a few errors with his handball but nothing to be too concerned about. He chased well today I thought and wouldn’t be too far from pushing for a senior spot.
Nathan Lovett Murray
14K – 7HB – 5M – 2G – 1B – 1C
Played exclusively in the centre square today. He dominated the first quarter and was part of everything. He wins the hard ball so well that perhaps he could spend some time in the square this season to assist the likes of Jobe. He had plenty of running bounces forward of the centre today and should have kicked a few more goals. He looks very fit and primed to slot into the seniors Round 3.
Tom Bellchambers
4K – 5HB – 5M – 13H/O – 2B
He really impressed me today with his ruckwork and work around the ground. He looks a terrific athlete. His work in the centre square with Lonergan, McVeigh and NLM was outstanding. He also took some terrific contested marks up forward and should’ve had 2 goals. I would have him before Laycock if we were looking for a pure ruckman to replace Hille next week. He is going to be a very good player.
Stuart Crameri
5K – 7HB – 3M – 1G
He is a solidly built player and played a bit of everywhere today. His left foot disposal is good but his handballing is an issue. Too many times he would miss targets or put teammates under pressure. Has good tackling pressure and impacts contests. Will be solid for Bendigo again this season.
Christian Bock
2K – 5HB – 2G – 1B 1M – 1T 3H/O
Part of the 3 ruckman combination. He actually looked very sharp up forward and got into good positions deep to score his two goals. His work around the ground also improved dramatically from what we saw in the NAB Cup. He competed well in the ruck without being too effective. He is improving with each game which is what you want from a rookie listed ruckman.
Marcus Marigliani
6K – 10HB – 2M – 5T – 1G
Was in everything in the first quarter when given time in the centre square. He hits the contest hard and throws his body into everything. He didn’t get as much opportunity in the middle after quarter time and also had a hit to the nose which bled for a while. He is a wholehearted player he gives you everything in the Luke Ball mould (without being anywhere near as good). Solid right foot disposal.
Sorry mate, I've got no idea. Does he play full back? If so he may have been #22.
We played with 26 players (8 interchange) and the only non Essendon listed players were Skipworth, Cloke and #22.
We played with 26 players (8 interchange) and the only non Essendon listed players were Skipworth, Cloke and #22.
- May 11, 2003
- 2,438
- 31
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I randomly put $100 on bendigo to win the VFL at 86-1.
Any ideas how they will go this year?
Any ideas how they will go this year?
- May 6, 2007
- 42,019
- 25,596
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
Yeah, it is James Flaherety. Captain of the Bendigo Bombers.
MARC_
Club Legend
- Mar 7, 2010
- 1,033
- 256
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
From BomberBlitz.
From: kevin walsh's moustache
From: CJohns
The final score was:
141-78 I think, we won.
Photos:http://www.bomberblitz.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=55180&st=105
From BomberBlitz.
From: kevin walsh's moustache
From: CJohns
The final score was:
141-78 I think, we won.
Photos:http://www.bomberblitz.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=55180&st=105
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
I posted this in the Bendigo thread but will put it here too.
Bendigo Practice Match Report vs. Casey Scorpions
The result of the game was almost meaningless given that we were playing the Melbourne reserves and had a side that contained 23 Essendon listed players. We played with 26 players to ensure that all players got some decent TOG. I think we scored 20.22 to 12 goals.
Rather than talking about the game I’ll go through each player as that is what everyone is interested in. I’ve taken stats for each player but I would probably allow an extra 5-10% total possessions for each player.
Abbreviations are (K-kick, HB – handball, M- mark , G-goal, B-behind, T- tackle – H/O –hitout to advantage, C - clangers
Jake Carlisle
3K – 7HB – 4M – 1T
Played his entire TOG as a half forward presenting up and then doubling back deep forward. Was part of the forward line rotation with Hurley, Still and Daniher (generally 2 up forward at a time). He has exceptional hands below his knees and took a great mark at his ankles running at full pace. The kid has talent and will do well at Bendigo as the season progresses. Also made good decisions.
Mark McVeigh
12K – 7HB – 2M – 2T – 2G
Was the ideal tune up for him leading into the Fremantle game next week. He started the first quarter at half back and then spent the rest of the match in the guts. He looked a class above everyone else out there as you would hope he would. Didn’t win a stack of it as his TOG was managed but won plenty of hard ball and clearances. Kicked well for goal also. He cramped up at the end in his calf but he will be fine.
Anthony Long
4K – 15HB – 1C – 3T – 3M
Played off half back in the ‘Dempsey’ role that seems in vogue. He didn’t really get into the game until the 2nd half in which he started to cut off a lot of attack patrolling the area between CHB and the Centre Square. Was reluctant to kick the ball until the last quarter which put a couple of teammates under pressure, but as he became more confident he provided a lot of drive. You can see that he reads the play very well and is very calm under pressure. Looks the goods.
Sam Lonergan
9K – 8HB – 3M – 2G
It took him a half to really get into the game but he got better as the match progressed. Kicked some nice goals on the lead when playing deep forward for short periods (Winderlich style). Worked really well with Bellchambers and McVeigh in the centre clearances in the last quarter with the 3 combining to win 4 clearances in a row. I’m not sure he did enough to replace Howlett next week though, although he could provide the extra forward option.
Jake Melksham
9K – 7HB – 4M – 1T – 1C - 1G
Spent his time on the wing and little in the centre. He has the confidence to take the game on and make the play which is encouraging. A couple of times he lacked awareness and was chased down. His skills were clean and he managed to run to the right spots when in space. I don’t think he is ready just yet but could play seniors later in the season as he gets a higher level of fitness.
Michael Hurley
12K – 1HB – 7M – 3G -2B
Played exclusively up forward as per Knights’ announcement 2 weeks ago – by forward I mean CHF. Was part of the same forward rotation and didn’t really hit his straps until the last 45 minutes of the game (5 of his 6 scoring shots were in the last quarter). His first 3 kicks were from marks on the lead and then swung around on his left foot and pumped it into the 50. His hands weren’t quite as clean as usual but he worked hard on the lead and presented well. Was a little sore at the end of the game but nothing to concern ourselves with. Didn’t appear to have any issue with his thumb (which was strapped). Will be ready to fire Round 4.
David Myers
8K – 9HB – 1C
Played exclusively in the back line. He was also the designated kick out when he was on the ground. His kicking was quite good today in field play although some of his long bomb kick outs went straight to the opposition. His work in close is excellent. There are times when he will hit a pack get the ball and feed it out with 3 opposition players around him. Defensively he was sold and he looked to be running freely. Another few weeks to gain match fitness then he will put his hand up for selection.
John Williams
8K – 12HB – 4M – 2C
He played HBF for the entire match and really impressed me with his work rate and ball winning ability. He attacks the contest hard and provided plenty of drive. He made a few bad errors which you would expect from a player in a new role but showed enough promise to make me think he could be work persevering with. Didn’t try to take any species just spoilt his opponent.
Michael Still
3K – 6HB - 4M – 2B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He presented well and took some solid marks leading up the ground. Should have kicked 2 but missed them. Looks to have very good hands in a contested marking situation and his second efforts at ground level today were also very good. It will be good to see him develop as the season progresses.
Jason Laycock
2K – 7HB – 1G - 1T – 6H/O
The 3 ruckman rotated with 1 in the ruck, 1 FF and the other on the bench. Laycock was the 2nd choice ruckman and started FF. The stats don’t look great but his work rate today was exceptional. He has picked up his pace and was chasing midfielders and defenders all day with great intent. His hands looked good when he was on the lead and his ruckwork got better as the match wore on. However I think Bellchambers may have the running for next week if Hille is suspended.
Darcy Daniher
7K – 3HB – 4M – 1T – 2G – 1B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He started really well but had less TOG in the 2nd half as they used Hurley more frequently. He took some solid pack marks and generally used the ball quite well. Also did some good crumbing work up forward and created some chances. I thought he was quite solid without being a standout.
Travis Colyer
4K – 4HB – 1G -1B - 2T
Kicked a sensational goal running through the midfield and get a 1-2 (similar to the YouTube footage from the TAC Cup). He started in the midfield and then spent more time down forward as a crumber. He didn’t win a lot of the ball but what he did when he had it was good. His size didn’t appear to be an issue at all and he went in hard for the ball.
Kyle Hardingham
12K – 3HB – 3M
Was rotating with Myers down back but would also find himself at FB at times. He looked quite solid in defence and provided a bit of drive from HBF. His spoiling was also quite good and he won some solid ball in close. His use of the ball was good without being fantastic. I wouldn’t have him in the seniors yet though.
Taite Silverlock
10K – 6HB – 2M – 2T – 4C
Spent time in the centre square in the first half and then time up forward in the second half. He is quick and has an excellent ability to win the ball and get 2-3 possessions in the same chain of play. His kicking today was quite ordinary at times as he was trying to do too much. He goes in hard and laid some solid tackles.
Tyson Slattery
6K – 5HB – 3M – 1T
Played in the back half and looked like he had missed a chunk of pre season. He was tired at the end which you would expect. He linked up well with Myers at times when running the ball out of defence. His disposal still needs a little bit of work but he just needs a solid month of training behind him before we see him start to hit his straps.
Jarrod Atkinson
4K – 8HB – 1B
Played off the back flank and hardly saw the ball until the last 45 minutes. Gave away a stupid 50 when he was sucked in by Newton. He tries hard but I just don’t see him in the Best 22. He runs over the ball, his disposal is a little suspect and he isn’t tight enough on his opponent. He looks the same player he was when I watched Bendigo reserves 9 months ago (and he got a senior spot 4 weeks later) so who knows.
Michael Quinn
8K – 6HB – 3M – 4T
Played half forward and he looks like a footballer now. You don’t get the sense of confusion when he has the ball as he is much more settled and aware. His use of the ball was good and his pressure was also excellent. Didn’t win a lot of the ball but he did win some contested possessions which was great to see. Had some nice goal assists.
Bachar Houli
13K – 8HB – 5M – 1B
Was playing on the wing for the entire game. I thought he was quite good today. He accumulated the ball and set up quite a bit of play from the HBF on the rebound. He made a few errors with his handball but nothing to be too concerned about. He chased well today I thought and wouldn’t be too far from pushing for a senior spot.
Nathan Lovett Murray
14K – 7HB – 5M – 2G – 1B – 1C
Played exclusively in the centre square today. He dominated the first quarter and was part of everything. He wins the hard ball so well that perhaps he could spend some time in the square this season to assist the likes of Jobe. He had plenty of running bounces forward of the centre today and should have kicked a few more goals. He looks very fit and primed to slot into the seniors Round 3.
Tom Bellchambers
4K – 5HB – 5M – 13H/O – 2B
He really impressed me today with his ruckwork and work around the ground. He looks a terrific athlete. His work in the centre square with Lonergan, McVeigh and NLM was outstanding. He also took some terrific contested marks up forward and should’ve had 2 goals. I would have him before Laycock if we were looking for a pure ruckman to replace Hille next week. He is going to be a very good player.
Stuart Crameri
5K – 7HB – 3M – 1G
He is a solidly built player and played a bit of everywhere today. His left foot disposal is good but his handballing is an issue. Too many times he would miss targets or put teammates under pressure. Has good tackling pressure and impacts contests. Will be solid for Bendigo again this season.
Christian Bock
2K – 5HB – 2G – 1B 1M – 1T 3H/O
Part of the 3 ruckman combination. He actually looked very sharp up forward and got into good positions deep to score his two goals. His work around the ground also improved dramatically from what we saw in the NAB Cup. He competed well in the ruck without being too effective. He is improving with each game which is what you want from a rookie listed ruckman.
Marcus Marigliani
6K – 10HB – 2M – 5T – 1G
Was in everything in the first quarter when given time in the centre square. He hits the contest hard and throws his body into everything. He didn’t get as much opportunity in the middle after quarter time and also had a hit to the nose which bled for a while. He is a wholehearted player he gives you everything in the Luke Ball mould (without being anywhere near as good). Solid right foot disposal.
I posted this in the Bendigo thread but will put it here too.
Bendigo Practice Match Report vs. Casey Scorpions
The result of the game was almost meaningless given that we were playing the Melbourne reserves and had a side that contained 23 Essendon listed players. We played with 26 players to ensure that all players got some decent TOG. I think we scored 20.22 to 12 goals.
Rather than talking about the game I’ll go through each player as that is what everyone is interested in. I’ve taken stats for each player but I would probably allow an extra 5-10% total possessions for each player.
Abbreviations are (K-kick, HB – handball, M- mark , G-goal, B-behind, T- tackle – H/O –hitout to advantage, C - clangers
Jake Carlisle
3K – 7HB – 4M – 1T
Played his entire TOG as a half forward presenting up and then doubling back deep forward. Was part of the forward line rotation with Hurley, Still and Daniher (generally 2 up forward at a time). He has exceptional hands below his knees and took a great mark at his ankles running at full pace. The kid has talent and will do well at Bendigo as the season progresses. Also made good decisions.
Mark McVeigh
12K – 7HB – 2M – 2T – 2G
Was the ideal tune up for him leading into the Fremantle game next week. He started the first quarter at half back and then spent the rest of the match in the guts. He looked a class above everyone else out there as you would hope he would. Didn’t win a stack of it as his TOG was managed but won plenty of hard ball and clearances. Kicked well for goal also. He cramped up at the end in his calf but he will be fine.
Anthony Long
4K – 15HB – 1C – 3T – 3M
Played off half back in the ‘Dempsey’ role that seems in vogue. He didn’t really get into the game until the 2nd half in which he started to cut off a lot of attack patrolling the area between CHB and the Centre Square. Was reluctant to kick the ball until the last quarter which put a couple of teammates under pressure, but as he became more confident he provided a lot of drive. You can see that he reads the play very well and is very calm under pressure. Looks the goods.
Sam Lonergan
9K – 8HB – 3M – 2G
It took him a half to really get into the game but he got better as the match progressed. Kicked some nice goals on the lead when playing deep forward for short periods (Winderlich style). Worked really well with Bellchambers and McVeigh in the centre clearances in the last quarter with the 3 combining to win 4 clearances in a row. I’m not sure he did enough to replace Howlett next week though, although he could provide the extra forward option.
Jake Melksham
9K – 7HB – 4M – 1T – 1C - 1G
Spent his time on the wing and little in the centre. He has the confidence to take the game on and make the play which is encouraging. A couple of times he lacked awareness and was chased down. His skills were clean and he managed to run to the right spots when in space. I don’t think he is ready just yet but could play seniors later in the season as he gets a higher level of fitness.
Michael Hurley
12K – 1HB – 7M – 3G -2B
Played exclusively up forward as per Knights’ announcement 2 weeks ago – by forward I mean CHF. Was part of the same forward rotation and didn’t really hit his straps until the last 45 minutes of the game (5 of his 6 scoring shots were in the last quarter). His first 3 kicks were from marks on the lead and then swung around on his left foot and pumped it into the 50. His hands weren’t quite as clean as usual but he worked hard on the lead and presented well. Was a little sore at the end of the game but nothing to concern ourselves with. Didn’t appear to have any issue with his thumb (which was strapped). Will be ready to fire Round 4.
David Myers
8K – 9HB – 1C
Played exclusively in the back line. He was also the designated kick out when he was on the ground. His kicking was quite good today in field play although some of his long bomb kick outs went straight to the opposition. His work in close is excellent. There are times when he will hit a pack get the ball and feed it out with 3 opposition players around him. Defensively he was sold and he looked to be running freely. Another few weeks to gain match fitness then he will put his hand up for selection.
John Williams
8K – 12HB – 4M – 2C
He played HBF for the entire match and really impressed me with his work rate and ball winning ability. He attacks the contest hard and provided plenty of drive. He made a few bad errors which you would expect from a player in a new role but showed enough promise to make me think he could be work persevering with. Didn’t try to take any species just spoilt his opponent.
Michael Still
3K – 6HB - 4M – 2B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He presented well and took some solid marks leading up the ground. Should have kicked 2 but missed them. Looks to have very good hands in a contested marking situation and his second efforts at ground level today were also very good. It will be good to see him develop as the season progresses.
Jason Laycock
2K – 7HB – 1G - 1T – 6H/O
The 3 ruckman rotated with 1 in the ruck, 1 FF and the other on the bench. Laycock was the 2nd choice ruckman and started FF. The stats don’t look great but his work rate today was exceptional. He has picked up his pace and was chasing midfielders and defenders all day with great intent. His hands looked good when he was on the lead and his ruckwork got better as the match wore on. However I think Bellchambers may have the running for next week if Hille is suspended.
Darcy Daniher
7K – 3HB – 4M – 1T – 2G – 1B
Again part of the same forward rotation. He started really well but had less TOG in the 2nd half as they used Hurley more frequently. He took some solid pack marks and generally used the ball quite well. Also did some good crumbing work up forward and created some chances. I thought he was quite solid without being a standout.
Travis Colyer
4K – 4HB – 1G -1B - 2T
Kicked a sensational goal running through the midfield and get a 1-2 (similar to the YouTube footage from the TAC Cup). He started in the midfield and then spent more time down forward as a crumber. He didn’t win a lot of the ball but what he did when he had it was good. His size didn’t appear to be an issue at all and he went in hard for the ball.
Kyle Hardingham
12K – 3HB – 3M
Was rotating with Myers down back but would also find himself at FB at times. He looked quite solid in defence and provided a bit of drive from HBF. His spoiling was also quite good and he won some solid ball in close. His use of the ball was good without being fantastic. I wouldn’t have him in the seniors yet though.
Taite Silverlock
10K – 6HB – 2M – 2T – 4C
Spent time in the centre square in the first half and then time up forward in the second half. He is quick and has an excellent ability to win the ball and get 2-3 possessions in the same chain of play. His kicking today was quite ordinary at times as he was trying to do too much. He goes in hard and laid some solid tackles.
Tyson Slattery
6K – 5HB – 3M – 1T
Played in the back half and looked like he had missed a chunk of pre season. He was tired at the end which you would expect. He linked up well with Myers at times when running the ball out of defence. His disposal still needs a little bit of work but he just needs a solid month of training behind him before we see him start to hit his straps.
Jarrod Atkinson
4K – 8HB – 1B
Played off the back flank and hardly saw the ball until the last 45 minutes. Gave away a stupid 50 when he was sucked in by Newton. He tries hard but I just don’t see him in the Best 22. He runs over the ball, his disposal is a little suspect and he isn’t tight enough on his opponent. He looks the same player he was when I watched Bendigo reserves 9 months ago (and he got a senior spot 4 weeks later) so who knows.
Michael Quinn
8K – 6HB – 3M – 4T
Played half forward and he looks like a footballer now. You don’t get the sense of confusion when he has the ball as he is much more settled and aware. His use of the ball was good and his pressure was also excellent. Didn’t win a lot of the ball but he did win some contested possessions which was great to see. Had some nice goal assists.
Bachar Houli
13K – 8HB – 5M – 1B
Was playing on the wing for the entire game. I thought he was quite good today. He accumulated the ball and set up quite a bit of play from the HBF on the rebound. He made a few errors with his handball but nothing to be too concerned about. He chased well today I thought and wouldn’t be too far from pushing for a senior spot.
Nathan Lovett Murray
14K – 7HB – 5M – 2G – 1B – 1C
Played exclusively in the centre square today. He dominated the first quarter and was part of everything. He wins the hard ball so well that perhaps he could spend some time in the square this season to assist the likes of Jobe. He had plenty of running bounces forward of the centre today and should have kicked a few more goals. He looks very fit and primed to slot into the seniors Round 3.
Tom Bellchambers
4K – 5HB – 5M – 13H/O – 2B
He really impressed me today with his ruckwork and work around the ground. He looks a terrific athlete. His work in the centre square with Lonergan, McVeigh and NLM was outstanding. He also took some terrific contested marks up forward and should’ve had 2 goals. I would have him before Laycock if we were looking for a pure ruckman to replace Hille next week. He is going to be a very good player.
Stuart Crameri
5K – 7HB – 3M – 1G
He is a solidly built player and played a bit of everywhere today. His left foot disposal is good but his handballing is an issue. Too many times he would miss targets or put teammates under pressure. Has good tackling pressure and impacts contests. Will be solid for Bendigo again this season.
Christian Bock
2K – 5HB – 2G – 1B 1M – 1T 3H/O
Part of the 3 ruckman combination. He actually looked very sharp up forward and got into good positions deep to score his two goals. His work around the ground also improved dramatically from what we saw in the NAB Cup. He competed well in the ruck without being too effective. He is improving with each game which is what you want from a rookie listed ruckman.
Marcus Marigliani
6K – 10HB – 2M – 5T – 1G
Was in everything in the first quarter when given time in the centre square. He hits the contest hard and throws his body into everything. He didn’t get as much opportunity in the middle after quarter time and also had a hit to the nose which bled for a while. He is a wholehearted player he gives you everything in the Luke Ball mould (without being anywhere near as good). Solid right foot disposal.
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
Great read Boucks09. Cheers.
Sounds very promising - can't wait to see McVeigh, NLM and Hurley in the 22 where they belong.
Great read Boucks09. Cheers.
Sounds very promising - can't wait to see McVeigh, NLM and Hurley in the 22 where they belong.
I was going to ask this exact question - it seems like there is a fair bit of improvement to be had at Bendigo this year. With no current injuries, there is some talented blokes running around in the Magoos!
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
Did anyone here go today? Interested to see how the Melbourne listed players went, I think Watts played a half?
Did anyone here go today? Interested to see how the Melbourne listed players went, I think Watts played a half?
- Nov 28, 2006
- 28,854
- 11,890
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
Did we win?
Did we win?
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
Haha I just pulled all of those stats from the preverbial
Watts did play and as was mentioned he was #60. He played a little more than half of the TOG throughout each quarter. Look he didn't stand out much but then then quality of ball going into the forward 50 was rubbish most of the day.
He doesn't look to have bulked up much and his skills weren't too flash but when you have missed as much footy as he has you would expect as much. He did look happy though which is a good sign for you guys.
Haha I just pulled all of those stats from the preverbial
Watts did play and as was mentioned he was #60. He played a little more than half of the TOG throughout each quarter. Look he didn't stand out much but then then quality of ball going into the forward 50 was rubbish most of the day.
He doesn't look to have bulked up much and his skills weren't too flash but when you have missed as much footy as he has you would expect as much. He did look happy though which is a good sign for you guys.
The only thing is that we haven't really seen many of the Bendigo listed players apart from Cloke, Skipworth etc. With the limits placed on the number of Essendon players I'm not sure how they will match up.
I agree with you. I'm seriously confused about what is happening with Myers. They talk about him as a midfield in the media (Knights has mentioned this a few times), but then play him exclusively in the back line.
His long left foot could be an asset for us in the backline but I just think his ability to win the hard ball is something that we are screaming out for.
Kong
Hall of Famer
- Oct 11, 2007
- 32,128
- 16,742
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Make that three.
I think his kicking is solid while overrated, and his clearance work is outstanding and somewhat underrated. To me, he's a clearance midfielder; play him there, Knights.
Kong
Hall of Famer
- Oct 11, 2007
- 32,128
- 16,742
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Re: Reveiw of Bendigo v Casey
Cheers, Boucks.
Outstanding.
Cheers, Boucks.
Outstanding.
