Best 22 2010-Assuming trade happens

[Juddbemetron]

How do you see our best 22 with the new 3 addititons to our club

Jamsion Thornton Joseph
Bower Waite Armfield
Simpson Gibbs Rischetelli
Murphy Kreuzer Corrazzo
Betts Bradshaw Ohalpin
Ruck: Warnock Judd Mclean
Int; Yarran/garlett scotland/ grigg/walker hamspon Browne/Russel/Austin
Houlihan, wiggins, cloke, jacobs robinson anderson hadley and johnson all not too far away

 

[james Dean]

Maybe it's Carlton bias showing but i'd have Tex and Hoops in before Rischitelli.

 

[AlecDuncan]

Thornton Jamsion Joseph
Bower Waite Russell
Simpson Gibbs Murphy
garlett Ohalpin Yarran
Betts Sparkle Kreuzer
Ruck: hamspon Judd Mclean
Int: Grigg Scotland/Carazzo/Walker Warnock Browne/Armfield/Austin
Inj: Bradshaw

We're ****ed.

 

[james Dean]

Thornton Jamsion Joseph
Bower Waite Russell
Simpson Gibbs Murphy
garlett Ohalpin Yarran
Betts Sparkle Kreuzer
Ruck: hamspon Judd Mclean
Int: Grigg Scotland/Carazzo/Walker Warnock Browne/Armfield/Austin
Inj: Bradshaw

We're ****ed.

Fish-Bulb at full-forward?

 

[kreuze_missile]

Play our Bullants side, trade all our players to the GC at the end of the year and start again

 

[nfc25]

dont even know if that side can make the eight.
for a club that usually gets the best out of all our trades this is a disgrace

 

[Close to 17]

Fish-Bulb at full-forward?

ha ha

Mr sparkle

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

What would you all rather have happened ... realistically?

 

[jonoman89]

FB: Thornton Jamsion Joseph
HB: Russell Bower Walker
C: Simpson(vc) Gibbs Rischetelli
HF: Murphy Waite Yarran
FF: Betts Bradshaw Kreuzer

R: Warnock Judd(c) McLean

INT: Hampson, Carrazzo, Grigg, Garlett

EMG: Austin, Robinson, Browne, Scotland, Jacobs, Houlihan, Wiggins, Hadley
---------------------------------------
Seriously fearsome midfield brigade. Very capable defense. Untested forward line.

Will be more than good enough to make the 8.

 

[95blues]

What would you all rather have happened ... realistically?

they wanted to replace our 90 goal FF with ROK a 13 goal midfielder going into his 11th season..

As far as replacing the 90 goals we will miss, i think bradshaw was the best AVAILABLE option. We were never gonna get buddy or roughead or j.brown.

 

[dekkar]

FB: Thornton Jamsion Joseph
HB: Russell Bower Walker
C: Simpson(vc) Gibbs Rischetelli
HF: Murphy Waite Yarran
FF: Betts Bradshaw Kreuzer

R: Warnock Judd(c) McLean

INT: Hampson, Carrazzo, Grigg, Garlett

EMG: Austin, Robinson, Browne, Scotland, Jacobs, Houlihan, Wiggins, Hadley
---------------------------------------
Seriously fearsome midfield brigade. Very capable defense. Untested forward line.

Will be more than good enough to make the 8.

Wiggins still on our list lol

 

[CUG81]

i think we are lucky to have got bradshaw to be honest. the club wanted to get fev out of the club so much, i was expecting filth in return, in particular from the pies.

bradshaw, mclean and rischitelli joining the club is a fair lot of trades.

Just keep in mind, the club had to take a major stance with fev, it would have been the hardest decision any club would have ever had to make. A superstar goal scoring machine!! to walk away with bradshaw is a major effort.

Carlton are not stupid...they wouldnt trade fev without having a plan B without him.

 

[Ryan Dixon Webb]

Let's hope Mark Austin comes on this year...
​

B: Bret Thornton; Michael Jamison; Dennis Armfield
HB: Jordan Russell; Mark Austin; Paul Bower
C: Kade Simpson; Brock McLean; Chris Judd
HF: Mark Rischetelli; Jarrad Waite; Chris Yarran
F: Eddie Betts; Daniel Bradshaw; Andrew Walker
foll: Matthew Kreuzer; Marc Murphy; Bryce Gibbs
I/C: Andrew Carrazzo; Aaron Joseph; Robert Warnock; Jeff Garlett
EMG: Shaun Grigg; Shaun Hampson; Mitch Robinson
​

 

[oreos]

Joseph Jamison Thornton
Walker Bower Rischetelli
Simpson Judd Gibbs
Carazzo Kruezer Waite
Yarran Bradshaw Betts
Warnock Judd McLean

Hampson Grigg Russell O'hailpin

In from the Brisbane final:
Jamison, Rischetelli, Waite, Yarran, Bradshaw, Warnock, McLean & O'Hailpin

Out: Fevola, Stevens, Scotland, Houlihan, Wiggins, Garlett, Cloke & Wiggins

Happy to axe/trade Stevens, Scotland, Houlihan and Cloke if we want to send a real message.

30-40 goals from each of Bradshaw, Kruez and Waite would be ideal

 

[Ryan Dixon Webb]

who's the other Judd... Ashley?

 

[oreos]

Cant we have two Murphy, the mini Judd

 

[Jeremias]

B: Aaron Joseph - Michael Jamison - Mark Austin
HB: Bret Thornton - Paul Bower - Jordan Russell
C: Kade Simpson - Brock McLean - Bryce Gibbs
HF: Andrew Walker - Jarrad Waite - Chris Yarran
F: Eddie Betts - Daniel Bradshaw - Matthew Kreuzer
R: Robert Warnock - Marc Murphy - Chris Judd
INT: Shaun Hampson - Dennis Armfield - Michael Rischitelli - Andrew Carrazzo

 

[Faz 2000]

I'd just like to say that, amidst all the doom and gloom, our midfield with two mature-bodied, tackling tractor-types looks f*&king bad-a$$.

 

[Kramer1]

Let's hope Mark Austin comes on this year...​

B: Bret Thornton; Michael Jamison; Dennis Armfield
HB: Jordan Russell; Mark Austin; Paul Bower
C: Kade Simpson; Brock McLean; Chris Judd
HF: Mark Rischetelli; Jarrad Waite; Chris Yarran
F: Eddie Betts; Daniel Bradshaw; Andrew Walker
foll: Matthew Kreuzer; Marc Murphy; Bryce Gibbs
I/C: Andrew Carrazzo; Aaron Joseph; Robert Warnock; Jeff Garlett
EMG: Shaun Grigg; Shaun Hampson; Mitch Robinson​

Better learn his name...looks like it's going ahead.
That's as strong if not stronger than anything we put our this year. I wouldn't be putting Judd ona wing, and Robinson or Browne gets a crack before Garlett in my team, but that's pretty well it. McLean and Rischitelli allow us to throw Gibbs back or forward as required.

I'd still like a little something more for Fev, but I can cop it. If we were offered up 14 from the Swans most would probably take it. Looks like we'll get 120+ games of reasonable standard football from Rischitelli. In context I'd take that from anyone picked at 14.

Hope for the best, expect the worst and take what comes. This could resign us to a few more years of making up the numbers, it could well be a defining moment in our club's history. Either way I'm on board!

 

[Sin City]

B: Joseph Jamison Thornton
HB: Russell Waite Bower
C: Simpson Gibbs Rischitelli
HF: Murphy Kreuzer Yarran
F: Walker Bradshaw Betts
R: Warnock Judd McLean
INT: Hampson Robinson Carrazzo Grigg
EMG: Garlett Browne Armfield Austin Stevens?

 

[PeeKay]

He we go, only 6 more months of this speculation. We still need to get rid of at least 6 players. Who are they going to be????

Joseph Jamison Austin
Bower Thornton Armfield
Walker Gibbs Waite i
Yarran O'hAlipin Rischetelli
Kruezer Bradshaw Betts

Ruck: Warnock, Judd, Murphy

Int; McLean, Hampson /Russell /Robinson/
Em; Houlihan, Wiggins, Cloke, Hartlett

 

[Ryan Dixon Webb]

Don't hit panic just yet hombres! quality players can pop from anywhere. This year we need to draft some big boys and put some solid development into them.

Regarding the full forward position post-Fev/Bradshaw... players will stand up, our club knows what they are doing. Hampson, Warnock & O'hAilpin could be anything... Kreuzer, Austin, Waite & Walker are already looking good and are all more than capable at providing options up forward. Then you add blokes like Yarran, Garlett, Robinson, Browne, Tiller etc. into the mix and they could become anything (superstars hopefully!).

So don't fret my friends, we'll slay next year and for many years to come!

 

[pokerchamp86]

Then you add blokes like Yarran, Garlett, Robinson, Browne, Tiller etc.

Browne???

 

[jk20]

i know everyone wont like this but if the fev - brisbane trade does happen i think we need to make a play at david hale. yes he had a bad year but he is still young. we could offer fisher and maybe a late pick. i think he would just add something else to our forward line.
it probly wont happen but i can wish..

B-Thornton Jamison Russell

HB-Rischitelli Waite Bower

C-Simpson Judd Gibbs

HF-Robinson Kruezer Walker

F-Betts Bradshaw Hale

R-Warnock Murphy Mclean

IC-Carrazzo Hampson Armfield Grigg

EM- Austin, Yarran, Gartlett, Hoops, Scotland

 

[blues4flag]

Kreuzer, Warnock, Hampson and Hale in the one side cripples our midfield rotations.

Big no from me.