How much time did Shane Crawford spend in NSW growing up? I read somewhere he spent some years living in the Adelaide Hills as a kid.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Best NSW born and bred player of all time.
- Thread starter bloodsbigot
- Start date
- Tagged users None
How much time did Shane Crawford spend in NSW growing up? I read somewhere he spent some years living in the Adelaide Hills as a kid.
Get over it champ he was born in NSW, end of story.
willingnable
Cancelled
- Banned
- #28
Carey was so NSW he played state of orgin footy for South Australia in 1992 - don't get much more NSW then that.
nakedducks
Cancelled
- Banned
- #30
looks like you need to read title of the thread bedford given he was bred in south australia.
- Apr 17, 2007
- 5,333
- 6,252
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- #31
Sorry.
I guess it really does depend on your definition of 'bred.'
According to most NRL supporters, someone is not NSW 'bred' unless they stay in that particular state until they start playing professional footy. Other people see 'bred' as something different. I should have specified my opinion more clearly.
The reason for my opinion, is that RL trolls on other boards in general reject the idea that someone is 'from NSW' if they:
A) Are not born in that state (Nick Davis was not born in NSW, therefore, is not from NSW).
B) Are not 'culturally' a New South Welshman if they moved out of the state at the age of nine.
Now, I think these definitions are unfair, but that's what you get when you discuss the codes with such closed minded RL fanatics. They're basically grasping at straws to prove that AFL 'will never produce good players from NSW or Qld.'
Still, I'm interested to see just how many AFL players are from NSW according to 'their' definition, but feel free to name players only 'associated' with NSW anyway!
I'm also interested to see if NSW could field a team of the century side worthy of competing with the Vics, SA's and WA's.
(Btw, I'm not having a go at NRL supporters in general or the game itself)
I guess it really does depend on your definition of 'bred.'
According to most NRL supporters, someone is not NSW 'bred' unless they stay in that particular state until they start playing professional footy. Other people see 'bred' as something different. I should have specified my opinion more clearly.
The reason for my opinion, is that RL trolls on other boards in general reject the idea that someone is 'from NSW' if they:
A) Are not born in that state (Nick Davis was not born in NSW, therefore, is not from NSW).
B) Are not 'culturally' a New South Welshman if they moved out of the state at the age of nine.
Now, I think these definitions are unfair, but that's what you get when you discuss the codes with such closed minded RL fanatics. They're basically grasping at straws to prove that AFL 'will never produce good players from NSW or Qld.'
Still, I'm interested to see just how many AFL players are from NSW according to 'their' definition, but feel free to name players only 'associated' with NSW anyway!
I'm also interested to see if NSW could field a team of the century side worthy of competing with the Vics, SA's and WA's.
(Btw, I'm not having a go at NRL supporters in general or the game itself)
"Bred" is the past tense and past participle of "breed". I "breed" dogs in NSW. I "bred" dogs in NSW ten years ago.
While "born and bred" does in fact mean "born and raised", that is somewhat of an oddity, as "bred" on its own does not mean raised.
I was merely, being in somewhat of a nerdy mood, implicitly drawing attention to that point. But it seems some of the slow learners at the back of the class didn't catch it.
time on
Senior List
I have always rated Paul Kelly 'as the best N.S.W born and bred' best player of all time.His hard nosed and professionalism personifies the Sydney die hard approach.
He was the captains captain, someone everyone wanted to play under.
He was the captains captain, someone everyone wanted to play under.
Because some smartarse will say he crossed the border before he was 21, or he was born within 3 metres of the Murray and someone will say it was 10 metres making him a Victorian.
Just change the thread to born then it will be easy.
Just change the thread to born then it will be easy.
Bas44
Debutant
U11 trophy from where?
The McVeigh's played their junior football at Killarney Vale. The bar at the Club in Killarney Vale has a photo of Jarrad. No photo's of Mark though. I was at the Club on Biggest Morning Tea Saturday as my son was playing the KV Bombers. The KV Bomber have the best facilities in aussie rules on the Central Coast.
It is common for the better Central Coast boys to travel down to Pennant Hills to play. It is the closest geographical Club to the Central Coast Clubs. They get drafted to AFL from there.
So they were at KV before Pennant Hills.
Scott Reed is from Terrigal. He went/goes to Terrigal High School.
Ray Hall from Woy Woy Peninsular Swans.
Bas44
Debutant
And Bunton Snr that would knock them out eventually anyway. Try telling anyone from Albury that it's not NSW.
He managed to get games in all over the place, even played for my team once or twice.
tribey
ʎǝlʞuᴉH ʞɔɐS
Veteran
Port Adelaide - Connor Rozee Player Sponsor 2020
Port Adelaide - Zak Butters 2019 Player Sponsor
Port Adelaide - Jack Watts Player Sponsor 2018
Port Adelaide - Nathan Krakouer Player Sponsor 2015
Port Adelaide - Matthew Broadbent Player Sponsor 2013
Port Adelaide - John Butcher 2012 Player Sponsor
Carey was so NSW he played state of orgin footy for South Australia in 1992 - don't get much more NSW then that.
Carey only moved to Adelaide at 16/17 to play with North Adelaide at junior level.
He also only played for SA in 1992 because of the old eligibility rules, which counted where your first official club registration was in one of the big three states (hence Dunstall was eligible for Victoria at the time despite being from Coorparoo, Qld).
Once the eligibility rules were changed in 1993 - the state you resided most between the ages of 10 and 17 - he was designated a NSWelshman.
Born in Mt. Barker, SA.
willingnable
Cancelled
- Banned
- #41
As I said b4 carey moved to SA when he was 12/13 and played all his footy there until he was picked up by the roos when he was 17/18 (fact).
State of orgin wise carey actually played for NSW in 1990, but in 1992 he played for SA - so if what you said about the criteria changing after 1993 was true carey would of played for SA in 90 and 92 but he didnt. Bottom line carey has strong link to both SA and NSW and both areas have claims to developing his footy skills - so I will leave it to others to deside if he is clearly NSW born and bred or not.
State of orgin wise carey actually played for NSW in 1990, but in 1992 he played for SA - so if what you said about the criteria changing after 1993 was true carey would of played for SA in 90 and 92 but he didnt. Bottom line carey has strong link to both SA and NSW and both areas have claims to developing his footy skills - so I will leave it to others to deside if he is clearly NSW born and bred or not.
Sirius Black
Debutant
If we disregard Bunton, on sheer football talent it has to be Jesaulenko and daylight. Was Jessa born here, he was certainly Canberra bred?
Pykie
Cancelled
10k Posts
A Star Wars Fan
Pokemon is Life
North Melbourne - North 2007 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
He is a born and bred Wagga boy.
dyertribe said:
Again Crawford is a proud product of Finley, and spent 5 years of boarding school at the famous footy school, Assumption College, Kilmore, Vic.
themightfaulks
Rookie
Drew Christy and Brendan Bidell IMO
themightfaulks
Rookie
You could also nearly throw in Graeme "The Perv" Butler
such_is_life_9
Senior List
scott reed- lived at forresters beach, pretty much terrigal, played for bateau bay blues till roughly u/16's then went to penno played the 18's and first grade...
mark and jazz mcveigh- killarney vale juniors both went to penno both boys have their picture in the club house, mark also won the b&f in the comp 2 years running in the 11's or 13's when he was 2 years younger then every one else. and mark does go train with the seniors there at least once a year which i think is a massive effort
ray hall definetly woy woy
craig bird will be a star from nelsons bay
and surely luffy would have to be up there also from nelsons bay
mark and jazz mcveigh- killarney vale juniors both went to penno both boys have their picture in the club house, mark also won the b&f in the comp 2 years running in the 11's or 13's when he was 2 years younger then every one else. and mark does go train with the seniors there at least once a year which i think is a massive effort
ray hall definetly woy woy
craig bird will be a star from nelsons bay
and surely luffy would have to be up there also from nelsons bay
tribey
ʎǝlʞuᴉH ʞɔɐS
Veteran
Port Adelaide - Connor Rozee Player Sponsor 2020
Port Adelaide - Zak Butters 2019 Player Sponsor
Port Adelaide - Jack Watts Player Sponsor 2018
Port Adelaide - Nathan Krakouer Player Sponsor 2015
Port Adelaide - Matthew Broadbent Player Sponsor 2013
Port Adelaide - John Butcher 2012 Player Sponsor
The criteria I described was true - it only applied to the major states (again, since Dunstall played for Vic before the 1993 change).
SA also didn't play SOO in 1990 as a result of the Port Adelaide rogue bid backlash.
Sure is, but the thread says born and bred. Just pointing out Crawf doesn't satisfy the former component.
