Best player in the league of each number!

[Theo Funk]

My Top 3 for each number (Italics just missed out)
Your opinions?

1. Barry Hall - Peter Everitt - Mark Johnson (just missed - Steven King)
2. Robert Murphy - Aaron Hamill - Nick Davis (Josh Carr, Tom Harley)
3. Chris Judd - Michael Voss - Chris Grant (Jimmy Bartel, Brett Deledio)
4. Daniel Kerr - Paul Hasleby - Gavin Wanganeen (Daniel Cross)
5. James Hird - Nathan Buckley - Rohan Smith (Sam Mitchell, Ryan O'Keefe, Scott Thompson)
6. Brad Johnson - Luke Power - Shannon Grant (Craig Bolton, Mark Williams)
7. Scott West - Nathan Brown - Lenny Hayes (Adam Simpson, Peter Burgoyne, Chad Fletcher)
8. Nathan Bassett - James Clement - Mitch Hahn (Max Hudghton, Daniel Wells)
9. Ben Cousins - Shane Crawford - Fraser Gehrig (Tyson Edwards, David Neitz)
10. Paul Williams - Michael Braun - Nathan Eagleton (Steven Baker, Josh Francou, Troy Cook)
11. Joel Bowden - Glenn Archer - Joel Smith (Damian Peverill, Joel Corey)
12. Nick Riewoldt - Jason Akermanis - Matthew Richardson (Nic Fosdike)
13. Adem Yze - Daniel Giansiracusa - Brett Voss
14. Luke Ball - Jason Johnson - Luke Darcy (would be No.1 if not injured)
15. Luke Hodge - Mal Michael - Peter Riccardi
16. Warren Tredrea - Jonathan Brown - Travis Johnstone (Darren Jolly)
17. Tadgh Kennelly - Kane Johnson - Adam Cooney (Adam McPhee, Scott Burns)
18. Matthew Lloyd - Paul Licuria - Kane Cornes (Luke McPharlin)
19. Michael O'Loughlin - David Hille - Ben Dixon
20. Dean Cox - Simon Black - Justin Longmuir (Chris Tarrant, Luke Ablett)
21. Leo Barry - Cameron Mooney - Richie Vandenberg (Heath Black, Corey Jones)
22. Brent Moloney - Ian Perrie - Rhyce Shaw
23. Andrew McLeod - Justin Koschitzke - Shane Parker (Nathan Thompson/Anthony Rocca)
24. Jude Bolton - Nick Stevens - Brett Burton (Russell Robertson, Mark Coughlan)
25. Ben Rutten - Scott Lucas - Brendan Fevola
26. Nick Dal Santo - Saverio Rocca - Sean Dempster
27. Will Minson - Jared Rivers - Clark Keating (Jason Blake)
28. Jared Crouch - Ashley Sampi - Richard Cole
29. Matthew Pavlich - Gary Ablett - Brent Harvey (Adam Kingsley, Ashley Hansen)
30. Matthew Scarlett - Lewis Roberts-Thomson - Matthew Robbins (Campbell Brown)
31. Brett Kirk - Dustin Fletcher - Shane Tuck (Aaron Sandilands, Matt Maguire)
32. Mark Ricciuto - Peter Bell - Cameron Bruce (Amon Buchanan, Andrew Embley)
33. Jeff Farmer - Ryan Houlihan - Jarred Moore
34. Jeff White - Ben Hart - Paul Medhurst
35. Robert Harvey - Chad Cornes - Paul Chapman (Troy Makepeace)
36. Simon Goodwin - Aaron Davey - Brian Harris
37. Adam Goodes - ??? - ???
38. Luke Vogels - Dale Morris - ???
39. Darren Milburn - Adam Hunter - Andrew Kellaway
40. Adam Bentick - ??? - ???
41. ??? - ??? - ???
42. Nathan Lovett-Murray - Robert Haddrill - Paul Bevan
43. Anthony Koutoufides - Roger Hayden - Dean Rioli
44. Nigel Lappin - David Wirrpunda - Steven Milne (Corey Enright)
45. Cameron Ling - Earl Shaw - ???

Can anyone fill in the gaps or suggest anyone better?

Mate, you forgot #45 Matthew Whelan
And Nathan D Brown wears the #25 with pride.

 

[Hollow Knight]

22. Brent Moloney - Ian Perrie - Rhyce Shaw

Chris Scott may be old but its an insult to have Shaw there.

Chris Scott - Lions B&F Winner, Rising Star Winner, Two premiership medals
Rhyce Shaw - pooped himself in a grand final

 

[nonchalance]

#41: Andrew Lovett.

 

[jules101]

5 Scott Thompson?? better then Hird and Buckley I think not

 

[jules101]

#41: Andrew Lovett.

Nope he is best #13

 

[loki04]

5 - Buckley > Hird >>>>>>>>>>> Thomson

 

[Partridge]

I might be just wearing the rose coloured glasses again but I'd say Arch for #11.

5 years ago maybe, but not now. I'd have either Joel Bowden or Joel Corey. Both are reigning best & fairest winners interestingly enough.

Other ones where I'd differ.

2. Tom Harley.
7. Nathan Brown or Scott West - comfortably ahead of Lenny Hayes.
12. Akermanis ahead of Riewoldt. Matthew Richardson wears number 12 also.
20. Simon Black - easily.
24. Russell Robertson. I don't like him, but you cannot fault 73 goals in a forward pocket.
41. Josh Hunt (only number 41 I can think of).

 

[Rosella]

5 years ago maybe, but not now. I'd have either Joel Bowden or Joel Corey. Both are reigning best & fairest winners interestingly enough.

Other ones where I'd differ.

2. Tom Harley.
7. Nathan Brown or Scott West - comfortably ahead of Lenny Hayes.
12. Akermanis ahead of Riewoldt. Matthew Richardson wears number 12 also.
20. Simon Black - easily.
24. Russell Robertson. I don't like him, but you cannot fault 73 goals in a forward pocket.
41. Josh Hunt (only number 41 I can think of).

Except he's changed to number 8

 

[Rosella]

Chris Scott may be old but its an insult to have Shaw there.

Chris Scott - Lions B&F Winner, Rising Star Winner, Two premiership medals
Rhyce Shaw - pooped himself in a grand final

Have to agree - number 22 was looking pretty ordinary.

 

[peternorth]

Have to agree - number 22 was looking pretty ordinary.

nathan bower

no 4? ben holland

 

[nonchalance]

Nope he is best #13

Ha. I forgot he'd switched. Damn.

 

[Partridge]

Except he's changed to number 8

Fair call, I forgot all about that.

I hate off season jumper changes.

 

[Grave Danger]

1. Warren Tredrea - Barry Hall - Peter Everitt (just missed - Mark Johnson)

 

[jezza]

39. A. Kellaway

I would also put Coughlan in ahead of Robbo at 24, but that's with bias.

And technically Kane Johnson wears 17 at the moment, although 28 will be his when he is no longer captain.

 

[Theo Funk]

5 - Buckley > Hird >>>>>>>>>>> Thomson

Wrong discussion group - we're discussing the best, not the ugliest:

 

[davey_magik]

27- Jared Rivers definitely.
Also lock in 8 for Clement.

 

[CJH]

#28: Kane Johnson

While he is captain, Johnson wears the #17.

----------
Joel Bowden as the best #11 (back to back B&F for Richmond and also AA selection)
I would prefer Coughlan as the best #24.
Andrew Kellaway as the best #39

 

[London-Tavern-Is-Filth]

Robbo kicked 73 goals from the forward pocket last year, what more do you want?

74 goals

 

[Shrapnel]

I think the only number we can all agree on is #37 Adam Goodes

 

[StickerMan]

39 - Marty Mattner??

 

[almost_04]

#41 Danyle Pearce?

 

[James23]

25. ben rutten

 

[celtic_pride]

25. ben rutten

I rate Fevola the best No25 at the moment.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Nope he is best #13

I think Giansiracusa has him well and truly covered.

 

[sante]

Number 21 - Moooooooooooney!

Shane Tuck > Mooney and Heath black



Richo is best #12