Biggest dud eagle, ever

[Bleedblueandgold]

Weedon
Notte
Swift
McDougall
Ebert?

 

[Monocle]

I challenge anyone to top this as our most dud pick EVER,

1998 National Draft Selection # 10.

Brandon Hill . games played for WC ......... drum roll...... 0

and just to make you really depressed who went # 11 Lenny Hayes.

Can you imagine the midfield that could have been:

Judd, Cousins, Kerr and Hayes

 

[ioppolo]

Jeremy Humm was pretty shit

And an ugly mofo.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

And an ugly mofo.

Doesn't hold a candle to Josh Wooden.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Liam Bedford owns this thread, worst player to ever be put on a WCE list.
Really really struggled at Claremont reserves level.

 

[Shane Sheridan]

Dizzy O'Connell, terrible, terrible footballer

 

[Barney44]

Liam Bedford owns this thread, worst player to ever be put on a WCE list.
Really really struggled at Claremont reserves level.

Only AFL listed player I can ever remember being dropped from a WAFL reserves team.

 

[Monocle]

Dizzy O'Connell, terrible, terrible footballer

**** off Shane , if you are looking for dud picks then please drop back home to your own clubs board .... plenty of low hanging fruit there lol.

Mr Sheridan your about as welcome on our board as Ham Sandwich at a Bar Mitzvah. Pun intended Visy Board excel at this stuff.

Trolls are not welcome so just **** off home to the land of brown paper bags.

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

Liam Bedford owns this thread, worst player to ever be put on a WCE list.
Really really struggled at Claremont reserves level.

Didn't really cost us anything though as a rookie selection, only took a punt on him because he was on the list of a very good team at the time, wonder if he was even doing well in the VFL.

 

[mattyc75]

99 games of pure ugly.
Truth be old, I actually didn't mind him.

Far better than Arse Smith.

dajesmac

symmons to Cummings.they were a great team for a season or 2

 

[mattyc75]

theres been plenty but ash smith made me angry every time someone ran past him to get the ball...fast you say?

 

[swannies]

Excuse me? Sure they're no Michael Embley, Tony Notte or Bendan Retzlaff but hey, who is?

Notte doesn't belong in the same breath as those others. Young Michael found his soul home at the cardies, didn't he?

 

[Shane Sheridan]

**** off Shane , if you are looking for dud picks then please drop back home to your own clubs board .... plenty of low hanging fruit there lol.

Mr Sheridan your about as welcome on our board as Ham Sandwich at a Bar Mitzvah. Pun intended Visy Board excel at this stuff.

Trolls are not welcome so just **** off home to the land of brown paper bags.

Just an opinion, no need to get so upset.
Well aware Carlton has had, does have, will have plenty of spuds. My pick as biggest dud ever - Warren McKenzie.
Make you feel better, give you my pick as the best ever Eagle - Chris Mainwaring. Not as flashy as many others, but was outstanding for many years, and during 89 when everything was going to shit, stood up week after week after week.

 

[wadistance]

As far as duds go, Andrew McDougall would be up there.

andrew mcdougall dislikes this

 

[Hap Hapablap]

patrick mcginnity. makes mcdougall look elite

 

[Keys]

patrick mcginnity. makes mcdougall look elite

Imagine if we could have transferred mcginnitys heart and effort into mcdougalls body

Patrick mcdougally would have been quite the player

 

[Brolga]

Laurie Bellotti
What a useless spud!

Played one good game against Carlton where he nullified Kouta and we thought he could be anything! But...

 

[mick06]

Played one good game against Carlton where he nullified Kouta and we thought he could be anything! But...

I remember chad morrison doing the same. He was some sorta kouta kryptonite

 

[JADED]

Didn't really cost us anything though as a rookie selection, only took a punt on him because he was on the list of a very good team at the time, wonder if he was even doing well in the VFL.

He won Geelongs reserves B&F iirc, funny that they were happy to let him go. Classic case of other clubs over rating your list when you're in flag mode.
I always question this no cost thing with Bedford because Jeff Garlett went in the same rookie draft and to this day, would have been very handy for us.

Anyway, saw thread title, came to post David Antonowicz but someone already did (and it only took a few posts)
Wasn't fit to accept the number 4 guernsey from Sumich.

 

[Bleedblueandgold]

He won Geelongs reserves B&F iirc, funny that they were happy to let him go. Classic case of other clubs over rating your list when you're in flag mode.
I always question this no cost thing with Bedford because Jeff Garlett went in the same rookie draft and to this day, would have been very handy for us.

Also a few other decent players taken later in that rookie draft, like Breust, Blair, Jacobs, Picken, Suckling, etc.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_AFL_Draft

 

[Boohemian]

Callum Chambers fo shiz

 

[Scotland]

Chambers? Doogs? Josh Wooden? GTFO people.

The biggest dud Eagle ever isn't going to be someone who played 40 or 50 games and was even named in the bests.

There are plenty of guys who played 1 or 2 games for the Eagles, and guys who made it onto the list but never cracked a game.

 

[mick06]

Chambers? Doogs? Josh Wooden? GTFO people.

The biggest dud Eagle ever isn't going to be someone who played 40 or 50 games and was even named in the bests.

There are plenty of guys who played 1 or 2 games for the Eagles, and guys who made it onto the list but never cracked a game.

One's dud is another's judd

 

[KO_KO]

Karl langdon and Tom Swift

 

[Beutbrute]

Tim Watson. The guy only lasted 1 week of preseason at the club.