Pentatonic Flat Fifth
All Australian
- Apr 18, 2021
- 959
- 1,480
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Whitnall?Fev maybe? Agreed it's getting rarer by the year.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Whitnall?Fev maybe? Agreed it's getting rarer by the year.
We still have half a season, with nothing to play for....
9 months until we can be excited about footy again
Might be interesting with Power stepping up into Barker's role. Will he push for some of the younger players he's worked with all year to be selected in the seniors? Will we see the stoppage setup change? Be it configuration, the strategy, or the personnel?
Going off last week's team, this year we've got potential debuts from Kemp, Carroll, Durdin, Ramsay. Honey almost counts here with the one game (2 because of that time as the sub?). Also players who may return to the side after suspension/injury/demotion with the likes of Plowman, Charlie, McGovern, Fogarty, SPS, O'Brien, Williamson, Parks, Kennedy, Gibbons. Not sure we'll see the two new guys Mirvok and Boyd this year.
There's a lot of names there that could make the team, and I'd be pretty keen to see some of the elder statesmen handing the torch to their successors.
Positional changes too. I'd like to see Stocker play more inside mid, Fish get some wing time along with hhf (and a little resting as small forward), etc.
Hopefully no more moves like let's play Ed on the back flank ahead of actual defenders like Docherty/Williamson/Kemp/Parks/etc. If Ed ain't tagging a mid then don't play him. Don't play inside mids as defensive wingers.
Also don't play underdone/injured/cooked players just because we want to hold a structure. If we play with one less genuine key forward but have a fit and in form alternative that's a bit smaller then that's ok.
This is an interesting point in the wider sporting context as it's something happening in sport around the world.Well put, getting this vibe with a lot of first rounders lately.
Who's the last player to carve out a seriously successful career on sheer talent and poor work rate? It used to be pretty common, it absolutely just does not happen these days, the modern era is ruthless and you are weeded out within 4 years.
Brad Hill was forging a good career but has been found out.
Stewie Dew maybe?
I don't think Fev is a good example as he worked very hard - he was just a bit of a dickhead when not training. He used to ignore sports scientists/trainers and do extra training at parks around the place in his own time. Not sure anyone who does more training than is allowed qualifies as someone who makes it off talent alone.Fev maybe? Agreed it's getting rarer by the year.
Trade week in Oct/Nov - our Grand Final basically
We still have half a season, with nothing to play for....
9 months until we can be excited about footy again
What do you mean..
Trade week is Carltons grand final every year...
Yeah not a bad call, peaked at 21 before the bourbon and cokes took priority.Whitnall?
He certainly didn't work hard in the early years, would usually come back into prepared season with shocking skin folds and work it off fairly quickly. First time I've heard of him doing extras.I don't think Fev is a good example as he worked very hard - he was just a bit of a dickhead when not training. He used to ignore sports scientists/trainers and do extra training at parks around the place in his own time. Not sure anyone who does more training than is allowed qualifies as someone who makes it off talent alone.
At least one Mitchell from Hawthorn is likely to be at Carlton in 2022.
Also:
If soothsayers are lyon it’s from an experienced and reliable sos*
* sorry I meant ‘source’ apologies for the typo!
Can Boyd play as a lockdown defender on small fast forwards or does he lack speed/endurance running? If he can he should be straight in.It's a nice wish list and for some/most, there are variations, which is also appealing
There will certainly be aspects that will remain the same, but hopefully it will be viewed in a positive way.
For me, I feel that some needed tweaks to the gameplan, will have a positive effect for other areas, such as player output and development
Just on Boyd, I sense he will get a look in sooner than we think. We are poor for ground balls, speed and disposal by foot, all the qualities he has.
Of the Sam variety?Hope it's the good one.
I have my doubts.
I'm surprised it's the first time you've heard it; he's talked about it several times over the years. He's talked about how he'd do extra goal kicking practice at footy fields around town because the trainers wouldn't let him do it at the club due to "load management", so he'd nick a back of footy's and go to parks where he'd kick for goal.He certainly didn't work hard in the early years, would usually come back into prepared season with shocking skin folds and work it off fairly quickly. First time I've heard of him doing extras.
Well goal kicking practice isn't what I'd classify as physically demanding. If he was doing sprints I'd agree with you. Fev was a long way from a driven individual.I'm surprised it's the first time you've heard it; he's talked about it several times over the years. He's talked about how he'd do extra goal kicking practice at footy fields around town because the trainers wouldn't let him do it at the club due to "load management", so he'd nick a back of footy's and go to parks where he'd kick for goal.
Can Boyd play as a lockdown defender on small fast forwards or does he lack speed/endurance running? If he can he should be straight in.
We are in the box seat then.Was massive Tigers supporter as a junior. Chances of him moving to them high, although appears like he's after more money?
From memory he got concussed.I havent watch any other game for the vfl dogs, but in our game against him, he popped up, did a couple of nice things… then disappeared again.
Can Boyd play as a lockdown defender on small fast forwards or does he lack speed/endurance running? If he can he should be straight in.
I have a strategy to deal with this.We still have half a season, with nothing to play for....
9 months until we can be excited about footy again
Every game is something to be excited about..thats what footy is all about.We still have half a season, with nothing to play for....
9 months until we can be excited about footy again
You are such a tease - I would hate to see you in a social environment.
He didn't need to do sprints, he was a full forward back when full forward actually meant something. He didn't need to get back into a zone defense and sprint forward on the rebound. He more or less lived out of the goal square and his most important thing was knowing when to lead and being a good kick for goal. He never lacked acceleration on the lead and he was also strong in marking contests. He did extra curricular work to make sure the other crucial part of his game was on point. That to me disqualifies him from being someone who got by on talent alone.Well goal kicking practice isn't what I'd classify as physically demanding. If he was doing sprints I'd agree with you. Fev was a long way from a driven individual.
Poor workrate. Poor overall fitness base and low stamina.
If there are three things that will prevent you from getting AFL games he's hitting the trifecta.
Will be a gun but needs to work for it. Word on the street? At this stage he's never had to.