Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Semi Finals
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Out with Lloyd in with Wright?
![]()
Pies reshuffle looms as footy boss departs
Graham Wright won't return to Collingwood after taking extended leave this yearwww.afl.com.au
He'd be a big upgrade to our Footy Dept.
I reckon next year he'll be ready to go again, don't reckon he'll stay out long.
That's a good call - He's Tasmanian, so that would almost be penciled in I reckon.Reckon he might have Tassie lined up.
Would be a great get though.
Happy for him to be on-board in some role, but not sure it should be Head of Football.Jimmy Bartel. Recently resigned from the board of GWS serving his role as footy director. Also had some experience with Brisbane in a List Management capacity prior to the GWS appointment.
Has a good relationship with Brian Cook....
edit; could be a replacement for Diesel?
watch this space
Another good call, he'd be a great fit and is switched on, either of those two cant be worse than Lloyd.Jimmy Bartel. Recently resigned from the board of GWS serving his role as footy director. Also had some experience with Brisbane in a List Management capacity prior to the GWS appointment.
Has a good relationship with Brian Cook....
edit; could be a replacement for Diesel?
watch this space
don’t even think Diesel is even aware of his position as Director of FootballJimmy Bartel. Recently resigned from the board of GWS serving his role as footy director. Also had some experience with Brisbane in a List Management capacity prior to the GWS appointment.
Has a good relationship with Brian Cook....
edit; could be a replacement for Diesel?
watch this space
ThisJust presided over one of the most poorly executed seasons by a football department possible, should be moved on asap.
So where are the improvements coming from?We are erecting dart boards everywhere it seems
Bullseye.We are erecting dart boards everywhere it seems
So where are the improvements coming from?
Do you think that Lloyd should be reemployed?Not sure what relevance that has with this thread
Do you think that Lloyd should be reemployed?
Apart from a couple of genuine ITK posters, no one here knows if he is ticking the boxes Cook set out for him, so none of us can answer it
Somewhat like assist coaches
Players - We can all see their strengths and weaknesses.
Austin - We can analyse his draft hits/misses and or list build. At this level, HP crosses over somewhat
Voss - Gauge and analyse his gameplan, tactics, perhaps get understanding if he can motivate/drive buy in
Beyond those 3-4 areas, it would be difficult to gauge succes or failure of role
And he comes the strawman response. I've never disappeared from any topicSuch a waste of a post on a fan forum. You made the same non argument in defense of Russell. Despite player fitness being an equally obvious indicator. You ended up proven wrong on that one and just disappeared from the conversation. You'll do the same here no doubt.
I take it you can share what Lloyd's responsibilities entailI think Lloyd has been OK in general but what can you say when we got so much wrong as a club this year?
How do you know if he has made mistakes if you don't know his briefThis is a big boy sport and getting the big title / pay check means you own responsibility for the mistakes.
You really think in an organisation, one person signs off on strategies?He must have signed off on what Russell was doing and match committee/ team selection.
Cook, along with all senior leaders will review the year, determine what worked and what didn't2024 was one long succession of awful mistakes that cost us a better than good chance of a premiership.
Cook has to be looking at Lloyd's role very closely right now.
In fairness, every post on a forum is essentially a waste. We're hardly resolving any issues here & whether for or against, it's no more beneficial.Such a waste of a post on a fan forum. You made the same non argument in defense of Russell. Despite player fitness being an equally obvious indicator. You ended up proven wrong on that one and just disappeared from the conversation. You'll do the same here no doubt.
I think Lloyd has been OK in general but what can you say when we got so much wrong as a club this year? This is a big boy sport and getting the big title / pay check means you own responsibility for the mistakes. He must have signed off on what Russell was doing and match committee/ team selection.
2024 was one long succession of awful mistakes that cost us a better than good chance of a premiership.
Cook has to be looking at Lloyd's role very closely right now.
Like Mick, Pagan and others think we got Cook at the weakest of his cycle. Like Pies with Mick there was a reason Geelong thought Cooks time was nigh. From his two page Robbo spread yesterday get the feeling Cook has been a lot more laid back with us and is craving retirement.Such a waste of a post on a fan forum. You made the same non argument in defense of Russell. Despite player fitness being an equally obvious indicator. You ended up proven wrong on that one and just disappeared from the conversation. You'll do the same here no doubt.
I think Lloyd has been OK in general but what can you say when we got so much wrong as a club this year? This is a big boy sport and getting the big title / pay check means you own responsibility for the mistakes. He must have signed off on what Russell was doing and match committee/ team selection.
2024 was one long succession of awful mistakes that cost us a better than good chance of a premiership.
Cook has to be looking at Lloyd's role very closely right now.
Perhaps, but when the argument boils down to "you cant comment on anything about the club or its staff because you don't know 100% where the root cause is" stifles proper conversation and debate. We all want the same thing, we all have slightly different opinions on how best to get there - shutting down people you disagree with when you have similar gaps in knowledge doesn't achieve the desired goal of forum participation.In fairness, every post on a forum is essentially a waste. We're hardly resolving any issues here & whether for or against, it's no more beneficial.
Arrow & I were disagreeing with some of the arguments put forward with Russell, both were open to him being moved on if that was found to be the optimal outcome, so to state he was wrong is a significant reach & one only used to prop up your argument here.
We are erecting dart boards everywhere it seems
Has anyone stated that?As opposed to .... let's not discuss it ... nothing to see here .... all went well?
It didn't feel like it went well, and since we aren't privy to the kpi's for the position, we can only speculate as to who needs to take responsibility.
If it's not the footy manager, what exactly is he responsible for, and if it's not the onfield stuff and making sure we have what we need to be successful on field, what's the point of the position?
I don't think it's right that if the club can keep somebody's role sufficiently vague enough, that nobody can hold them accountable.
Has anyone stated that?
The entry point to the recent flurry in activity was essentially a reactionary, sakc Lloyd post.
As with all personnel, his performance would be reviewed on an ongoing basis - if he's not up to it, he'll be moved on.
I understand being frustrated with our season, I also back Cook to make the appropriate informed decision.