Injury Brown -- Now say 4-5 weeks out (BS loading not included)

[Baltimore Jack]

When Scharenberg is back Frost is out as he loses his spot on the list

Not necessarily, there are other Rookie elevation rules

 

[motr]

Disagree. Reid, brown, seedsman and josh thomas are all probable best 22. Add williams (although not injured) and we are pretty depleted at moment especially in the backline. Thats not even mentioning the injured rookies.

Josh Thomas is certainly a class player, but he is a distance from replacing Ball and both Adams and Blair are the preferred options at the moment.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Right now I think our best 22 looks something like this:

Toovey, Brown, Williams
Young, Frost, Seedsman
O'Brien, Beams, Thomas
Swan, Cloke, White
Steele, Reid, Billy

F: Grundy, Pendlebury, Macaffer
I: Maxwell, Adams, Fasolo, Ball

That's Brown for Keefe, Reid for Goldsack, Thomas for Dwyer, Williams for Langdon and Seedsman for Blair.

So we're not too far away. Reid and Williams are extremely important though, as is Seedsman IMO. He is very unique on our list and offers us plenty of things we lack. When you look at a full team like that we look excellent.

Subjective.
Keeffe isn't best 22 but he's in the leadership group.
Langdon has been the shining light with Frost. Certainly wouldn't drop in form blokes.
Goldsack is depth I agree. Struggling.
Dwyer is a match winner. Best 22 IMO.

 

[Apex36]

Not necessarily, there are other Rookie elevation rules

I would assume Frost is a lock for the mid season elevation if Scharenberg is back by then.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Subjective.
Keeffe isn't best 22 but he's in the leadership group.
Langdon has been the shining light with Frost. Certainly wouldn't drop in form blokes.
Goldsack is depth I agree. Struggling.
Dwyer is a match winner. Best 22 IMO.

Of course it's subjective, it's my view. There are only twenty-two spots so inevitably some good players miss out. I rate Langdon but he's a first year player and would struggle to stay in if everyone was available. Dwyer is good I just rate Thomas and Seedsman higher. I actually think Keefe is better than Brown but there is little doubt Brown is the one who would be picked out of the two.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Blair is best 22 every day of every week of every year of every decade.

He's really not. I like the guy but this is just way over the top.