Brownlow Medal 2011 (Part 1)

[Rustin Cohle]

3. Blair
2. Yarran
1. Judd/Shaw/Johnson/Scotland

 

[half_back_flank]

3 Judd
2 Blair
1 Shaw/Beams

 

[mike262]

3 Shaw
2 Judd
1 Blair

Judd was impressive, may get the 3

 

[Jonno_]

Feels like I'm going mad watching you guys' votes for this game. Unless it is based off entirely voting history, no way will Judd get votes. He was ineffectual, made next to no impact on the game. Garlett was a far more influential player for the Blues.

 

[mike262]

Judd has very good around the stoppages. Didnt rlly notice Garlett that much. Only really recall him when he had the ball with acres of space around him and no real pressure.

 

[danielnajdek]

just lock judd in for three umps love him

 

[rocketmac360]

2.5 Judd
2.5 Blair
1 Shaw

 

[blue_boys]

3: Judd
2: Shaw
1: Blair

Judd was very good and is playing Pies so 3 votes. Shaw was pies best over the whole game and won his ball running off half back so should stand out. Blair the 1 vote for his goals

 

[adii_7]

judd will win the brownlow.. again

 

[Michael Scarn]

3. Blair
2. Judd
1. Shaw

 

[s1bbald]

just lock judd in for three umps love him

Your votes, mate?

Mine:
3. Shaw - clear best on for mine, plenty of kicks, and lot of marks from opposition kicks, really caught the eye from row BB in the 'G.
2. Judd - ran the lines well all night, quite similar to his game last year R6, a lot of contested footy too. Can't be blamed for what his mates did with the ball once he hit them with it...

1. Blair - 5 straight. Nuff said.

 

[danielnajdek]

Your votes, mate?

Mine:
3. Shaw - clear best on for mine, plenty of kicks, and lot of marks from opposition kicks, really caught the eye from row BB in the 'G.
2. Judd - ran the lines well all night, quite similar to his game last year R6, a lot of contested footy too. Can't be blamed for what his mates did with the ball once he hit them with it...

1. Blair - 5 straight. Nuff said.

3.Blair
2.Shaw
1.Yarran

There you go

 

[s1bbald]

3.Blair
2.Shaw
1.Yarran

There you go

Not bad mate, it'll be interesting to see how Yarran polls if he keeps up this current form, as he could get amongst the votes in the very near future. Same applies for Garlett...

 

[Hard Ball Get]

3. Shaw
2. Judd
1. Blair

 

[mdc]

2. Judd - ran the lines well all night, quite similar to his game last year R6

Unlike some others, I really rated his R6 game last year and thought he was pretty clearly BOG. This time around was nowhere near as influential.

That said, I still think he could poll 2 or 3. All the best players - Shaw, Garlett, Reid, Blair, Robinson in that order imo - were outside the midfield, so I'm a bit skeptical that they'll actually poll well.

At a guess:
3 - Judd
2 - Blair
1 - Swan

 

[Tigertriumph]

I'd say Shaw 3, Judd 2 and Blair 1. I'm most comfortable with Shaw for the 3 he absolutely tore it up and continually did more than his fair share in the back half. I'm more concerned about Judd for the 2 but think he;ll take it due to his accumulation of posi's and line breaking capabilities (and freak like polling) more so than his kicking and delivery which at times was very, well...un-Juddy. Lastly, Blair gets the 1 for kicking 5 straight. Even though I think as a player in a one on one situation he would struggle dearly, Carltons defenders made it easy for him to find space in the forward line and bag goals as all of the Pies superstars drew open large areas (by attracting the attention of Carltons backline) up front for Blair to run into and snag goals. Nuff said...

 

[mike262]

adel v freo

3 fyfe
2 Thompson
1 Hill

wce v syd
3 Goodes
2 Bolton - 19 tackles
1 Cox

Naitanui was decent could snag the 1?

 

[mike262]

any1 catch wbd v gc?

 

[StringyDog]

any1 catch wbd v gc?

3. Cross
2. Ablett
1. Higgins

Boyd, Griffen or Murphy could also get that 1 vote but Cross and Ablett were a fair way ahead of the others.

 

[weagles_fan]

3. Cross
2. Ablett
1. Higgins

Boyd, Griffen or Murphy could also get that 1 vote but Cross and Ablett were a fair way ahead of the others.

You sure Cross? IIRC he hasn't polled very much through his whole career?

 

[Dr Awkward]

3. Cross
2. Ablett
1. Higgins

Boyd, Griffen or Murphy could also get that 1 vote but Cross and Ablett were a fair way ahead of the others.

Thought it might be more like

3 Higgins
2 Boyd
1 Cross / Ablett

 

[laam]

Just watched the Geelong game, my votes were

3 - Bartel
2 - Kelly
1 - Selwood

Think it will be definately between those 3.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

I thought Cross was easily BOG. Polling history counts against him but I try and call it as I see it.

3. Cross
2. Boyd
1. Ablett/Higgins

 

[weagles_fan]

A couple of games I had trouble with but this is what I came up with.

Collingwood v Carlton
3 - J Blair
2 - C Judd
1 - H Shaw

Bulldogs v Gold Coast
3 - M Boyd
2 - G Ablett
1 - D Cross

Adelaide v Fremantle
3 - N Fyfe
2 - D Mundy
1 - S Thompson

Richmond v Hawthorn
3 - S Burgoyne
2 - S Savage
1 - L Hodge (not sure if Franklin will poll here????)

West Coast v Sydney
3 - A Goodes
2 - J Bolton
1 - D Cox

Melbourne v Brisbane
3 - B Moloney
2 - T Rockliff
1 - L Power

Geelong v Port Adelaide
3 - J Bartel
2 - J Kelly
1 - J Selwood

St Kilda v Essendon
3 - J Watson
2 - D Zaharakis
1 - P Ryder

Leaderboard
8 - C Judd
7 - J Watson
6 - B Moloney
6 - J Bartel
5 - M Boyd
5 - S Burgoyne
5 - A Goodes
5 - D Cox
5 - J Bolton
4 - D Swan
4 - N Fyfe

The rest 3 or lower.

Please give me your thoughts.

 

[mike262]

Leaderboard
8 - C Judd
7 - J Watson
6 - B Moloney
6 - J Bartel
5 - M Boyd
5 - S Burgoyne
5 - A Goodes
5 - D Cox
5 - J Bolton
4 - D Swan
4 - N Fyfe

The rest 3 or lower.

Please give me your thoughts.

i have watson leading on 7 aswell.

could be the judd of 2011, the stand out player of essendon