-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Traded Bryce Gibbs [traded to Adelaide] - (cont. in Part 2)
- Thread starter Ian Dunross
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 85,025
- 89,625
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
I'm sure Essendon will happily take him in the psd if you don't come to the party...but we know SOS will.
- May 29, 2009
- 29,806
- 14,801
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
I liked Grigg and Kelly as juniors. What's their SANFL form like? Do you reckon they could become regular AFL players at another club?
Kelly is reliable shut down player as honest as the day is long . Emergency many times this year but Cheney 's form kept him out
Grigg burst onto the scene in 2013 and looked a gun in the making - not sure if it's mental or not but just hasn't cracked it despite very good SANFL form
Griggs SANFL form easily eclipses Matty Wright and shades Kerridge
No team's giving up 2 first rounders for a 28 year old, especially one that isn't all that great.
So what do you think GWS will accept for Marchbank?
- Sep 19, 2015
- 2,530
- 1,709
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 85,025
- 89,625
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
Pick 5
gillo94
Norm Smith Medallist
Gibbs for Matt & Brad Crouch and we might throw a second Rd pick back to you
Nah .. gibbs and 2nd for 13.
.
NCHammertime
Team Captain
- Jun 23, 2015
- 377
- 575
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I'm sceptical of this "just need player A and we will have a premiership team" thinking. When has that ever worked?
So it'd be nice to have Gibbs, but as he'll be 28 I'd be just as happy to have pick #13 ....we should get a pretty good player with a decade's service ahead. (We got Smith and Talia and Lever around that pick number). Not getting Gibbs and keeping #13 would not be a disaster for us. I'd be happy to retain our first round picks for this year and next.
So it'd be nice to have Gibbs, but as he'll be 28 I'd be just as happy to have pick #13 ....we should get a pretty good player with a decade's service ahead. (We got Smith and Talia and Lever around that pick number). Not getting Gibbs and keeping #13 would not be a disaster for us. I'd be happy to retain our first round picks for this year and next.
Carlton are in effect tring to protect their pick 5 with this trade ... cant see how they can say no to 13 ... they will cave unless they want to do marchbank for 5.
- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,564
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #2,317
We will have other contingencies.
The potential trade with GWS might end up something like Pick 5, Pick 24 and Pick 45 for Marchbank, Pickett, Stewart, Pick 15 and Pick 31.
Carlos Danger
Club Legend
- Sep 9, 2016
- 1,969
- 2,500
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
My take is had gibbs left under FA carlton wouldve got pick 8.
So 13 + a second rounder is about right based on what they wouldve got.
Lyons is worth about a 2nd round or future pick or pick upgrades tossed in will get it done eventually.
But hopefully they wait till the last minute cos this thread is so entertaining
So 13 + a second rounder is about right based on what they wouldve got.
Lyons is worth about a 2nd round or future pick or pick upgrades tossed in will get it done eventually.
But hopefully they wait till the last minute cos this thread is so entertaining
Wouldnt u rather have pick 5 and marchbank or gibbs and marchbank and pick 15? I know which one id chose.
- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,564
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #2,320
The second option for sure. As I have posited all week, Gibbs is worth more than Pick 13 to us and is not easily replaced.
Given how even the draft is, there is still lots of talent available in the teens and we'd be able to still nab a talented young player to inject into the team.
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #2,321
Would have been Pick 6 and next years Crows 2nd rounder is unlikely to bridge the gap between 6 and 13 regardless of what the points system tells you. It could end up near 40.
What the hell do you want Matt Crouch for? Watching Carlton and the Crows doing this trade is like watching 2 cars playing chicken at 60km/hr its not going to happen fast but its still going to be a wreck at the end.
Fascinating statement considering Gibbs approached us, as he wants to come back for family reasons. While you guys took SOS from GWS and he continually raids them (contracted players included). But yes Carlton will get everything they want out of this trade period for the best deals, like every other year...
Edit: quoted wrong post but same poster.
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Carlos Danger
Club Legend
- Sep 9, 2016
- 1,969
- 2,500
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
It wouldve been 8. Carlton traded 7 for whiley n jacksch so compensation comes after that. Picks got pushed back one cos of frawley compo.
Well if worried about crows finishing too high trading lyons & banking the pick of definitive value would be the option.
Maybe crows future 2nd for carltons future 3rd could be the sweetener depending on what number th lyons pick comes in at
If we trade a first and second for Gibbs our clib is going to have to defend why we gave up for Gibbs what we got for Dangerfield.
Not only that but Gibbs just isnt worth what Carlton supporters want.
You can say that we have to pay overs all you wont, but we wont.
For instance if we gave away a Crouch, Lever, Gov, Cameron for Gibbs then we have fone nowhere. Whats the point of that?
His worth is pick 13 as a 28 year old B grader.
Wanting more because he is in contract is going to get you steak knives, not a first 22 player as well.
Similar threads
