Cam Spudderson

[bontshow]

Shame he doesn't even know how to rush a behind properly though. Did only see the 2nd half but that shithouse attempt to punch through a shot on the line, which was well within reach, surely cancels out any possible good things I might have missed (and I seriously doubt there were any of those).

Possibly a bit rusty down back. I think North played him down back, but you guys have played him forward?

 

[Elite Master]

I've got it at Pedersen 12, Gysberts 0

I've got em at Pedo 0, Gysberts 0.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

I've got em at Pedo 0, Gysberts 0.

Don't you get it? We won the trade. You lost. Now if you'll excuse me, all this talk has made me hungry.

Possibly a bit rusty down back. I think North played him down back, but you guys have played him forward?

Forward, back and ruck. Jack of all trades, master of none. Can't wait for Jamar, Gawn, Hogan and Dawes to return.

 

[royals1922]

Don't you get it? We won the trade. You lost. Now if you'll excuse me, all this talk has made me hungry.

Forward, back and ruck. Jack of all trades, master of none. Can't wait for Jamar, Gawn, Hogan and Dawes to return.

You could have put in a young kid to see how he would go in a competitive game and if you lost, lost nothing, but wait.....

 

[bontshow]

I've got em at Pedo 0, Gysberts 0.

But Pedo has played 12 games

 

[van peebles]

But Pedo has played 12 games

yeah,but brett thornton could get a game with dees.

 

[bontshow]

Forward, back and ruck. Jack of all trades, master of none. Can't wait for Jamar, Gawn, Hogan and Dawes to return.

He's a good spare parts player isn't he. Racked up 10 games last year despite not being your number 1 choice for any position.

 

[IanW]

But Pedo has played 12 games

Oh which he's contributed how much over, say, a stuffed Tony Lockett jumper thats left in the goal square ?

 

[bontshow]

yeah,but brett thornton could get a game with dees.

Then don't trade him there unless you get something back you can use

 

[bontshow]

Oh which he's contributed how much over, say, a stuffed Tony Lockett jumper thats left in the goal square ?

He was BOG against GWS last year

 

[Elite Master]

But Pedo has played 12 games

So 12 mediocre/bad games by a mid aged spud that squibs, hurts the team with his badness and is actually taking up a spot that could be better used on a promising kid makes it all alright? So bascially regardless of the quality of the output as long as he gets games it means he is the winner?

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

yeah,but brett thornton could get a game with dees and win the B and F.

EFA.

 

[bontshow]

So 12 mediocre/bad games by a mid aged spud that squibs, hurts the team with his badness and is actually taking up a spot that could be better used on a promising kid makes it all alright? So bascially regardless of the quality of the output as long as he gets games it means he is the winner?

That's all Elite Master's opinion. Melbourne are choosing to play him because they believe they are better off playing him than somebody else, therefore they are benefiting from having him on their list.

See how that was objective, and not full of personal views on how good he is?

 

[IanW]

He was BOG against GWS last year

In round 4 ? 8 possessions, 4 marks and 2 goals, as versus, say, Mr Nathan Jones with 28 possies, 2 marks and a goal, or even Jeremy Howe with 4 goals ?

In round 19 ? 23 possessions, 7 marks and 1 goal (and 74% disposal efficiency and 4 clangers) ... heck, Jack Watts had more marks and more goals than Cam Spudderson that game, and Id still say Mr Nathan Jones with 29 disposals and 10 (!) clearances was - as usual - BOG for the Dees.

 

[Elite Master]

That's all Elite Master's opinion. Melbourne are choosing to play him because they believe they are better off playing him than somebody else, therefore they are benefiting from having him on their list.

See how that was objective, and not full of personal views on how good he is?

More like they are playing him because they essentially have no one else to replace him with, add to that the crazy amount of injuries to key forwards. They delisted Sellar and Davis who according to YDKJ could have played his role.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

More like they are playing him because they essentially have no one else to replace him with, add to that the crazy amount of injuries to key forwards. They delisted Sellar and Davis who according to YDKJ could have played his role.

Only reason we delisted them and kept Pedo is that Nutty Neeld gave Pedo a 3 year deal. That Neeldy, he's so nutty!

You could have put in a young kid to see how he would go in a competitive game and if you lost, lost nothing, but wait.....

And with that, a mighty cheer went up from the heroes of Norf. They had banished the awful lemon tree forever, because it was haunted. Now let's all celebrate with a cool glass of turnip juice.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

He's a good spare parts player isn't he. Racked up 10 games last year despite not being your number 1 choice for any position.

Spare parts, yes. Good, no.

He was BOG against GWS last year

Yep, he's a bog alright.

 

[bontshow]

In round 4 ? 8 possessions, 4 marks and 2 goals, as versus, say, Mr Nathan Jones with 28 possies, 2 marks and a goal, or even Jeremy Howe with 4 goals ?

In round 19 ? 23 possessions, 7 marks and 1 goal (and 74% disposal efficiency and 4 clangers) ... heck, Jack Watts had more marks and more goals than Cam Spudderson that game, and Id still say Mr Nathan Jones with 29 disposals and 10 (!) clearances was - as usual - BOG for the Dees.

Round 19. Highest SC score for Melbourne, one of the few to stand up in what was GWS' only win last year.

 

[bontshow]

More like they are playing him because they essentially have no one else to replace him with, add to that the crazy amount of injuries to key forwards. They delisted Sellar and Davis who according to YDKJ could have played his role.

So he's better than Sellar & Davis

Don't confuse the opinions of Bigfooty posters with actual footy club decision making.

 

[Elite Master]

So he's better than Sellar & Davis

Don't confuse the opinions of Bigfooty posters with actual footy club decision making.

I think you missed the part about Nutty Neeld being actually nutty. It was probably one of a long list of decision making things that lead to his sacking.

 

[Elite Master]

Only reason we delisted them and kept Pedo is that Nutty Neeld gave Pedo a 3 year deal. That Neeldy, he's so nutty!

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

David Parkin eat your heart out.

 

[royals1922]

More a chicken and the egg argument but was Neeld nutty before he got there or was he turned nutty while he was there.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

More a chicken and the egg argument but was Neeld nutty before he got there or was he turned nutty while he was there.

He was a massive squib when he played. Reckon getting belted in the Geelong league turned him.

So he's better than Sellar & Davis

Don't confuse the opinions of Bigfooty posters with actual footy club decision making.

Not really, we could delist them without paying out a contract. He's probably better than Troy Davis, but Davis was still young and in saying that, is not much of an achievement. Were Christian Howard and Brett Goodes better players than Daniel Cross?

 

[bontshow]

I think you missed the part about Nutty Neeld being actually nutty. It was probably one of a long list of decision making things that lead to his sacking.

Nutty Roosy is still playing him