Can Prestia and Miles both play?

[I Rock]

Apparently going to piss rain on Sunday, so should both play this weekend at least.

 

[HTT]

Taking one alone, it's miles for now but I reckon Prestia has greater potential. No guarantee to fulfill it but he's shown glimpses of being a genuine A grader. Miles is a B+. Honest but very good footballer. Would get a run pretty easily in all teams, but not quite able to get into that top bracket. That said, there's enough room for both in there.

 

[Snooza 100]

Both if Dusty leaves!!

 

[cannot]

If it's a choice, easily Miles.

13 contested possies and 8 clearances tonight. I don't think Prestia would've had those numbers all year. Oh and 8 tackles.

Plus Miles actually has good disposal. Still laughing that the people on here who said Miles wasn't in our best team. He's our ******* 3rd best midfielder on the whole list.

Prestia:

- 13 contested possessions, 30+ touches
- 7 clearances
- 6 tackles

ranks very well in comparison to richmond and hawthorn players

didnt look like a dickhead missing an open goal either

 

[tora tora tora]

Miles has been underwhelming. Interestingly, he only played 60% of game time this week. I loved him a couple of years ago, but like Lloyd, they're not quite doing it in the firsts this year.

 

[cannot]

Miles has been underwhelming. Interestingly, he only played 60% of game time this week. I loved him a couple of years ago, but like Lloyd, they're not quite doing it in the firsts this year.

rubbish

mistake dropping the lad

 

[French Tiger]

Gives us more midfield depth when he plays. Not everyone needs to get 30 disposals a game

 

[Tigerturbulance]

 

[cannot]

Miles is a good player and proven in finals

would be risky to go into the games without him

 

[HumanMeatball]

Need to keep in mind we have played our best footy the few weeks with no miles in the side. Need to consider weather ect

 

[Bobby Sands]

Was best on today pretty easily.

 

[evo]

Was best on today pretty easily.

Yep. Should definitely play.

We need as many hard nuts at the coalface as we can muster.

 

[cannot]

Need to keep in mind we have played our best footy the few weeks with no miles in the side. Need to consider weather ect

against a poor saints and very poor freo

 

[HumanMeatball]

against a poor saints and very poor freo

And he was shit against Hawthorn Depends on weather as he is slow

 

[cannot]

And he was shit against stkilda. Depends on weather as he is slow

the whole team was bad in st kilda game #1

hardly miles fault that

 

[HumanMeatball]

the whole team was bad in st kilda game #1

hardly miles fault that

Meant Hawthorn game

 

[UpTheTigs]

I'd bring in Miles for Graham and Caddy for Markov. Gonna be a tough slog.

 

[tugga]

No.

 

[Hoos]

Room for both. A bit tricky on who to leave out, but both should play against Geelong. Miles has already shown he can play well in a final.

 

[tugga]

I like Miles. Don't get me wrong. He has been very unlucky this year due to our changed gameplan.
If it's wet as predicted, he could well come in and I wouldn't have one single problem with it.
But if it's not, then there's simply no room for him because of our run and spread and helter skelter game plan.
Similar to Lloyd and Lennon, they don't fit in to out structures.
Doesn't mean they are bad players one bit.
I hope he can find a new home next year if he is not happy staying. I think he could offer a club some real grunt.

 

[TigerImposter]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-02/miles-mounts-his-case-for-tigers-selection

 

[Tiger2709]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-09-02/miles-mounts-his-case-for-tigers-selection

Got a ton of it today but lacked a touch of class and pace, Prestia if fit is a step above Miles and I love Miles, just too slow for the ones at the moment, imo.

 

[Bobby Sands]

Prestia is much better, but I don't think need to compete for a spot.

I like Miles as a trenches specialist.

 

[THE_GUN]

If its a wet game i wouldn't be against Miles playing but that would mean Graham misses out

I really like to get games into Graham , specially finals game against Geelong

 

[richcogs]

Prestia was an unnecessary 800k addition to the team. Would of preferred to have kept Miles (who played with me at North Albury and will likely take another offer this year) and got someone like Motlop or A decent FF.

When Prestia has the ball I cringe, he in fairness, like Miles doesn't have that penetration with his feet when kicking the ball.