3kzisfootball
Debutant
I gues the pointy end of the argument is.
Who wins out of Wal-Mart/Coles/Woolworths/Super Big Supermarket and the local corner-store?
That is at the root of the argument.
Even if the corner-store wins that particular battle - there are still plenty of Wal-Marts/Coles'/Woolworths' all over the place.
But, if Wal-Mart/Coles/Woolworths win that particular battle - that corner store is gone forever - it is unique and exists in only one place.
That is the crux of the matter.
I like both sports, but I can tell you - there are many countries around the world I can enjoy my Soccer fix, when it comes to Australian Football - there's really only 1.
That is the point of the matter.
Being No.1 in Australia is absolutely vital and imperative for our native game, being No. 1 here for other sports is far less important.
Its for that reason, that Australian Football must do all it can to be No. 1 in Australia - and if that means setting up teams in new areas that don't have a history of playing the game - then that means the AFL should do just that.
If it can't spread the game nationwide around Australia, then its as a good as a dead duck long-term. I'm talking 40-60 years.
It is an interesting analogy McCrann, but I think you (and other AFL fans) overstate the 'soccer juggernaut'. Just because a particular game is dominant in the world, does not mean that it will swamp everything in its path.
Cultural aspects are very important. I live in Melbourne which is the birthplace of Australian Rules football and the game is intrinsically interwoven in the fabric of the city. I don't really think that any other code is going to break that. And I expect that would be the same in Adelaide, Hobart, Perth and Darwin.
Of course fans will add another sport to the smogarsboard on offer if they want. And I think that is what's happening. I don't think fans are turning away from Australian Rules and to soccer. They still follow their AFL team and have an A-League team to follow as well.
Culture is very important. If FIFA was unable to crack the USA after giving them a world cup and a ridicolusly easy path to qualify for the World Cup and all the money poured in the country, I can't see FIFA being that interested in domination of Australia with its relatively small population.
And also look at Ireland. If there is a place where soccer could have swamped indigenous games that would be it. Made a couple of World Cups, have players in the EPL which is next door and in UEFA which is one of the strongest and best confederations in the world. But it seems to me that Gaelic Football and Hurling are still popular.
Of course in areas which are 'new markets' there will be competition for players and fans. And that is to be expected.
Hoewever I don't think Australian Rules have anything to fear from any other codes in its traditional areas.