Speculation Chad Warner [OOC 2025]

[eaglespremiers]

Price / value would have taken a hit after today’s GF

Really?
Warner absolutely went missing in the critical 2nd and 3rd quarters but he was was not alone.
Outside of Rowbottom there was no good Swans player today.
And he's still a couple of years away from likely peaking as a player.
If he was on the table we'd have to give up pick 3 plus some other good pick to satisfy Sydney.
Not that I expect him to be keen to leave this year.

 

[Jeremias]

Had a bad day, so too did most of his team mates.

But let’s be honest. It would have zero impact on his value.

 

[THE_GUN]

21 disposals 18 kicks 3 handballs
only 52% De

His kicking was shocking today and really disappointing
I actually thought he would have dominated this game

Anybody know if he had a man ? as he just seemed to be drifting around on his own every time he was in vision

 

[kaiserchief13]

Pick 3 + Barrass or the 1st round pick Barrass trade gets going to Hawthorn/Bulldogs

 

[Cactus_]

Had a bad day, so too did most of his team mates.

But let’s be honest. It would have zero impact on his value.

I do think big game failures damage the value of players

Having said that it probably does need to be in multiple big games, rather that just a one off, to seriously affect a players value, and Warner was pretty good in the 2022 GF, so Warner’s value may not have taken too much of a hit from yesterday’s failure

 

[RUNVS]

I do think big game failures damage the value of players

Having said that it probably does need to be in multiple big games, rather that just a one off, to seriously affect a players value, and Warner was pretty good in the 2022 GF, so Warner’s value may not have taken too much of a hit from yesterday’s failure

He was our best player in the 2022 Grand Final.

 

[ep2018]

Reckon Sydney would prefer picks 3 and 13 over what Freo could offer, suspect he'll stay for next year or demand to be traded to freo this trade period tho. Would rather proven value Warner than who we could pick with those picks.

 

[Jeremias]

I do think big game failures damage the value of players

Having said that it probably does need to be in multiple big games, rather that just a one off, to seriously affect a players value, and Warner was pretty good in the 2022 GF, so Warner’s value may not have taken too much of a hit from yesterday’s failure

Nobody is looking at the game yesterday and reconsidering their valuation of Warner as a footballer or as a potential recruit.

Forget "too much of a hit", it wouldn't have taken a hit at all.

 

[LongSerong]

Who did he support as a kid?

Would love him to nominate us when the time comes and just get it done

 

[uncleoatmeal]

Who did he support as a kid?

Would love him to nominate us when the time comes and just get it done

Geelong mate

 

[THE_GUN]

Nobody is looking at the game yesterday and reconsidering their valuation of Warner as a footballer or as a potential recruit.

Forget "too much of a hit", it wouldn't have taken a hit at all.

Players valuations move up and down like shares after every game
but only on bigfooty

 

[Yeti]

Price / value would have taken a hit after today’s GF

You’d have to question whether Freo would be wise to sell the farm to get this bloke on today’s yesterday’s showing

Similar to Bolton's value taking a hit after this year's performance?

Doubt one down game effects a players value.

 

[Ge3ks]

Nope he's right. Chad is now a spud and should be gettable for a future 3rd rounder.

 

[THE_GUN]

Similar to Bolton's value taking a hit after this year's performance?

Doubt one down game effects a players value.

Anything more than Pick #9 + 2nd rounder for bolton you guys are being taken to the cleaners by Richmond
Surely Freo wouldnt make the same mistake they made with jackson
But Chad is Chad and will still demand 2 x top 10 picks

 

[Celebrity 101]

He’s goneski

 

[bruzaar62]

He’s goneski

Whereski??

 

[Jeremias]

Whereski??

His guess is as good as yours, and mine.

 

[adogsfan5]

The perfect midfielder for todays game.. put him next to a bull or two and let him run. No way the swans trade him now though after another grand final loss.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

His guess is as good as yours, and mine.

Worse I imagine

 

[Jeremias]

Worse I imagine

I was trying to be nice.

 

[Cactus_]

Similar to Bolton's value taking a hit after this year's performance?

Doubt one down game effects a players value.

That isn’t a great analogy, because Bolton is a big game player ~

 

[Julia#13]

WCE get: Ch Warner, Co Warner, Pick 19
Syd get: Pick 3, F1 (3-6), Pick 23


Fair? Not fair? Who says no?

 

[stallon]

WCE get: Ch Warner, Co Warner, Pick 19
Syd get: Pick 3, F1 (3-6), Pick 23


Fair? Not fair? Who says no?

Eagles say no easily.

Id be ok offering 3+wce f1 for Warner+17+Swans f1. No more than that, hes no Chris Judd. His trade value in 12 months time when uncontracted is probably our 2025 1st pick on its own

Corey isnt worth much at all, almost not relevant

 

[Membling]

Eagles say no easily.

Id be ok offering 3+wce f1 for Warner+17+Swans f1. No more than that, hes no Chris Judd. His trade value in 12 months time when uncontracted is probably our 2025 1st pick on its own

Corey isnt worth much at all, almost not relevant

Yyeeeaaahhh... Swans pass on that.

 

[stallon]

Yyeeeaaahhh... Swans pass on that.

That values Warner at a top 4 pick and a pick 7-10ish. If you wont take that then clearly you guys are either unreasonable or are happy to forgo the trade bounty for another chance at a premiership, id prefer the premiership if it was me.

I hope we leave Warner alone this year, should be gettable with our 1st pick alone next year