Speculation Chad Warner

[freo_leo29]

Is there a player at Fremantle you wouldn’t trade in a direct swap for Harley Reid or Chad Warner?

Treacy and Amiss for starters, talls much more valuable than mids

Serong, self explanatory, same draft as chad and Chad's still playing catch up

I wouldn't trade Andy for Chad, ask me again in 2 years for Harley

Jackson, bloke can be anything

Then I'm 50/50 on Young, so maybe ask me in a year for him altho I reckon he's gonna be even better in his second year as a midfielder, he has the kick that none of the players mentioned so far have, a real POD.



Now if we are talking about what Reid is now, then theres a tonne more players but I'm projecting what he possibly can be.

 

[eastfreo75]

Well if Reid is measure of elite, then freo have none.

Good argument, you have a giant intelligent.

 

[Grumpyshades]

View attachment 2187841

Deadset reckon half our squad are elite if Reid is the measuring stick.

We are being generous putting him in there, he isn't elite yet by any means, probably one day but certainly not yet.

wow comparing a 1st year player with your whole list

ranks along side Kane Cornes criticizing Reids fitness levels with players who have been in the AFL system for years..genius I say genius !!!

 

[freo_leo29]

wow comparing a 1st year player with your whole list

ranks along side Kane Cornes criticizing Reids fitness levels with players who have been in the AFL system for years..genius I say genius !!!

Someone said we don't have elite players if we compare them to Reid

So I did the comparison


I was answering a dumb post at their own level

 

[Grumpyshades]

Someone said we don't have elite players if we compare them to Reid

So I did the comparison


I was answering a dumb post at their own level

bit like Freo supporters blaming the West when the one eyed freo editor continually puts Harley on the Back Page..freo fans can't quite work it out...something something West Coast Australian lol

 

[freo_leo29]

bit like Freo supporters blaming the West when the one eyed freo editor continually puts Harley on the Back Page..freo fans can't quite work it out...something something West Coast Australian lol

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/attachments/screenshot_20221201_170110_twitter-jpg.1592472/

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/attachments/screenshot_20221201_164945_twitter-jpg.1592471/

That took 2 minutes to disprove?

This is the sports editor for the West BTW

 

[Grumpyshades]

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/attachments/screenshot_20221201_170110_twitter-jpg.1592472/

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/attachments/screenshot_20221201_164945_twitter-jpg.1592471/

That took 2 minutes to disprove?

This is the sports editor for the West BTW

you probably should of spent more than 2 minutes researching..right name, wrong bloke lol

Jakeb Waddell | Sports Editor

Jakeb Waddell is the Sports Editor of The West Australian and The Sunday Times. He was previously the South West Editor, where he oversaw eight mastheads...

thewest.com.au

 

[freo_leo29]

you probably should of spent more than 2 minutes researching..right name, wrong bloke lol

Jakeb Waddell | Sports Editor

Jakeb Waddell is the Sports Editor of The West Australian and The Sunday Times. He was previously the South West Editor, where he oversaw eight mastheads...

thewest.com.au

Ummm did you just link me a page that has the exact twitter account listed and try to say I had the wrong bloke?

That is one hell of a double down

I know people double down when wrong on the internet but I atleast thought you'd go with something like "his brother must've posted all of those tweets for him"

 

[Grumpyshades]

Ummm did you just link me a page that has the exact twitter account listed and try to say I had the wrong bloke?

That is one hell of a double down

I know people double down when wrong on the internet but I atleast thought you'd go with something like "his brother must've posted all of those tweets for him"

he's a freo flog...gutless wonder took down all his pro freo crap cause he was copping it..absolute coward

 

[freo_leo29]

he's a freo flog...gutless wonder took down all his pro freo crap cause he was copping it..absolute coward

Oh boy

The famous triple down when wrong

 

[Grumpyshades]

Oh boy

The famous triple down when wrong

yes we will all pretend his social media pages were not full of freo garbage just to make you happy

 

[freo_leo29]

yes we will all pretend his social media pages were not full of freo garbage just to make you happy

First we need to explain away all the Eagles posts

I've already given the brother one, how about some more

After that tweet to Zaharakis, David got in contact with him and made him see the light, since that day he has been a Freo supporter.

Or how about my personal favourite, Jakeb was fed up with West Coast not acknowledging him as their #1 digital fan, he has carried a massive vendetta against them to this day, changing allegiances along the way.

Feel free to use any of these in the future when you bring up The Wests "Freo" editor again

 

[ghostbat12]

View attachment 2187841

Deadset reckon half our squad are elite if Reid is the measuring stick.

We are being generous putting him in there, he isn't elite yet by any means, probably one day but certainly not yet.

hyperventilation by freo fans over Reid since we drafted him is off scale.

Just grab popcorn and enjoy the show for the next 10-15 years. Maybe you get some airtime after that.

 

[ghostbat12]

Treacy and Amiss for starters, talls much more valuable than mids

Serong, self explanatory, same draft as chad and Chad's still playing catch up

I wouldn't trade Andy for Chad, ask me again in 2 years for Harley

Jackson, bloke can be anything

Then I'm 50/50 on Young, so maybe ask me in a year for him altho I reckon he's gonna be even better in his second year as a midfielder, he has the kick that none of the players mentioned so far have, a real POD.



Now if we are talking about what Reid is now, then theres a tonne more players but I'm projecting what he possibly can be.

Ah man, I was almost hospitalised from laughter after reading this.

let’s wait for half of freo list to see their development is like. but Harley has, apparently, minimal development to go. It was all a fluke.

You guys have no idea what show you are in for in 2025. Even Freo fans will be clearing their Sunday afternoons to watch Harley.

 

[stallon]

Ah man, I was almost hospitalised from laughter after reading this.

let’s wait for half of freo list to see their development is like. but Harley has, apparently, minimal development to go. It was all a fluke.

You guys have no idea what show you are in for in 2025. Even Freo fans will be clearing their Sunday afternoons to watch Harley.

hyperventilation by freo fans over Reid since we drafted him is off scale.

Just grab popcorn and enjoy the show for the next 10-15 years. Maybe you get some airtime after that.

Theyre just jealous, I dont blame them either tbh.
I would be too if I was a Freo fan

 

[Grumpyshades]

Theyre just jealous, I dont blame them either tbh.
I would be too if I was a Freo fan

well he did humiliate them in his 5th game

 

[THE_GUN]

Is there a player at Fremantle you wouldn’t trade in a direct swap for Harley Reid or Chad Warner?

That would depend

Is that based on Performance or Potential ?

 

[THE_GUN]

Theyre just jealous, I dont blame them either tbh.
I would be too if I was a Freo fan

Eagles fans would give their 1st born to have the fremantle list

but yes reid will become a very good player



But this is a bit like saying West Coast were just jealous of fremantle whilst winning flags because fremantle had Natt Fyfe on their list

 

[Tundrawolf]

Any chance of Chad Warner talk?

 

[eaglevision]

That would depend

Is that based on Performance or Potential ?

It’s as simple as which player would you prefer on your list, what that decision is based on is entirely up to you.

 

[THE_GUN]

It’s as simple as which player would you prefer on your list, what that decision is based on is entirely up to you.

Well based on 2024 season there would be a few
Serong
Brayshaw
Young
Treacy

Just to name a few

Harley is a good young player but unless there is a criteria that is a crazy question as Sheezel /Daicos had a much better 1st year.

There is alot of Hype abour Harley being the next Dusty but he still has to become the next Dusty

 

[eaglevision]

Well based on 2024 season there would be a few
Serong
Brayshaw
Young
Treacy

Just to name a few

Harley is a good young player but unless there is a criteria that is a crazy question as Sheezel /Daicos had a much better 1st year.

There is alot of Hype abour Harley being the next Dusty but he still has to become the next Dusty

If you’d prefer any of those four on your list instead of Harley or the Chad that’s entirely your prerogative. I wouldn’t, although I think Hayden Young is going to be a bona fide star.

 

[THE_GUN]

If you’d prefer any of those four on your list instead of Harley or the Chad that’s entirely your prerogative. I wouldn’t, although I think Hayden Young is going to be a bona fide star.

Thats why a question was asked what the criteria was based on and you were vague

Now in 2024 yes i would take all the above on the list and maybe 2025 & 2026 but if we are talking longer term then that would depend on what produces in the next year.

Currently he just gets 20 touches and 0.5 goals a game with a few flashy things
He has not had the season Sheezel / Daicos had in their 1st year

 

[eaglevision]

Thats why a question was asked what the criteria was based on and you were vague

Now in 2024 yes i would take all the above on the list and maybe 2025 & 2026 but if we are talking longer term then that would depend on what produces in the next year.

Currently he just gets 20 touches and 0.5 goals a game with a few flashy things
He has not had the season Sheezel / Daicos had in their 1st year

It’s not vague, I’d expect any list manager to consider as many variables as possible before pulling the trigger on a trade, it certainly isn’t a question down to two or three criteria. You look at what you gain versus what you lose.

I would be very surprised if any club turned down a trade that brought in Harley or Chad in exchange for Josh Treacy in a straight swap but as I said, if you’d prefer Treacy on your list that’s your prerogative.

 

[THE_GUN]

It’s not vague, I’d expect any list manager to consider as many variables as possible before pulling the trigger on a trade, it certainly isn’t a question down to two or three criteria. You look at what you gain versus what you lose.

I would be very surprised if any club turned down a trade that brought in Harley or Chad in exchange for Josh Treacy in a straight swap but as I said, if you’d prefer Treacy on your list that’s your prerogative.

Like i said , Simple question

What was the criteria ?
Was it based on what he has produced or what he is projected to become,
Based on 2024 dont think there would be any list manager that would take harley over Reid but on projection yes you are correct

Not that hard