Speculation Chad Warner

Remove this Banner Ad

THE_GUN said:
Like i said , Simple question

What was the criteria ?
Was it based on what he has produced or what he is projected to become,
Based on 2024 dont think there would be any list manager that would take harley over Reid but on projection yes you are correct

Not that hard
Click to expand...
Firstly, criteria is the plural form of criterion so your question “what was the criteria?” doesn’t make any sense. Are you asking about a sole criterion or multiple criteria? Simple grammar.

Secondly, it’s been explained to you multiple times that you can take into account whatever you wish to make the decision, that’s up to you. In saying that, it would be pretty stupid for a list manager not to assess the expected career of a trade target, particularly when that career would be anticipated to last another decade in Chad’s case and well over that in Harley’s case.

Thirdly, “dont think there would be any list manager that would take harley over Reid” also makes no sense. You might find this perplexing but Harley and Reid are the same player. Try to keep up.
 
eaglevision said:
It’s as simple as which player would you prefer on your list, what that decision is based on is entirely up to you.
Click to expand...
I’d prefer brayshaw serong young Treacy Amiss Jackson
4 are AA squad or better all under 25
2 are 40+ goalkicking key forwards that are u23
 

Log in to remove this ad.

ghostbat12 said:
It’s like saying you wouldn’t take a young bontempelli over darling or Daniher.

Do freo fans think amiss and treaty are lance Franklin and Tom Hawkins in disguise?
Click to expand...
If you're rating Reid as Bont then those 2 keys can easily be rated as Cameron and Hawkins

In which case, yes we take them
 
THE_GUN said:
Eagles fans would give their 1st born to have the fremantle list
Click to expand...
Not even close.
THE_GUN said:
but yes reid will become a very good player



But this is a bit like saying West Coast were just jealous of fremantle whilst winning flags because fremantle had Natt Fyfe on their list
Click to expand...
Freo arent winning flags right now either mate, they didnt even make finals this year.
 
freo_leo29 said:
If you're rating Reid as Bont then those 2 keys can easily be rated as Cameron and Hawkins

In which case, yes we take them
Click to expand...



Amiss and treacy are never going to be Cameron and Hawkins. At best darling and

No one is talking about those as generational talents but guess who is talked about as that?


Chad Warner also over freo’s darling and larkey.
 
ghostbat12 said:
It’s like saying you wouldn’t take a young bontempelli over darling or Daniher.

Do freo fans think amiss and treaty are lance Franklin and Tom Hawkins in disguise?
Click to expand...
In the last 20 yrs I’m pretty sure only Buddy Hogan and Cameron have started better than Amiss goals wise.
They are all Coleman medalist a good sign.
As for Treacy if he can consistently do what he did this year and be the Roughead type that’s gold.
Excuse our love for Treacy and amiss but they are our only key forwards to Kick 40+ in the last 20 years besides Pav
 
Last edited:
ghostbat12 said:
Amiss and treacy are never going to be Cameron and Hawkins. At best darling and

No one is talking about those as generational talents but guess who is talked about as that?


Chad Warner also over freo’s darling and larkey.
Click to expand...
It took 6 years for Hawkins to kick 40+
Amiss did it in his second season
Treacy in 4th season.
Amiss first 3 seasons
47 games 81 goals
Hawkins
43 games 59 goals
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

eaglevision said:
Firstly, criteria is the plural form of criterion so your question “what was the criteria?” doesn’t make any sense. Are you asking about a sole criterion or multiple criteria? Simple grammar.

Secondly, it’s been explained to you multiple times that you can take into account whatever you wish to make the decision, that’s up to you. In saying that, it would be pretty stupid for a list manager not to assess the expected career of a trade target, particularly when that career would be anticipated to last another decade in Chad’s case and well over that in Harley’s case.

Thirdly, “dont think there would be any list manager that would take harley over Reid” also makes no sense. You might find this perplexing but Harley and Reid are the same player. Try to keep up.
Click to expand...
LOL after the English lesson to a person who english is a 2nd language i think you are wasting your time with that as im 60 years old and could really give a flying *** about grammar

Ill make it simple
Based on Harley Reid 2024 season i would rather have serong treacy and brayshaw on my list in 2024
But if you are asking which player do i want for the next 10 years that would depend on if Reid actually lives up to his hype because currently thats all he is a good young player with alot of hype around him

Lets see if he can even get to Daicos , Sheezel level in his 2nd year because at the moment he is just a kid that got 20 touches a game and 0.5 goals a game.


* You dont have to post my next english lesson , Just PM me ;)
 
RonnieRaven said:
In the last 20 yrs I’m pretty sure only Buddy Hogan and Cameron have started better than Amiss goals wise.
They are all Coleman medalist a good sign.
As for Treacy if he can consistently do what he did this year and be the Roughead type that’s gold.
Excuse our love for Treacy and amiss but they are our only key forwards to Kick 40+ in the last 20 years besides Pav
Click to expand...

Darling.

Facts are not hard to check.
 
ghostbat12 said:
Darling.

Facts are not hard to check.
Click to expand...
We can only judge what has been.
Amiss has played 47 games so go spend hours searching for a better goals per first 47 games drafted in the last 20 years.
I’ll agree he’s no Modra kicking 220 goals in first 50 games but he goes alright.
Darling was a leading goal kicker in a premiership year a great fwd
 
eaglevision said:
It’s not vague, I’d expect any list manager to consider as many variables as possible before pulling the trigger on a trade, it certainly isn’t a question down to two or three criteria. You look at what you gain versus what you lose.

I would be very surprised if any club turned down a trade that brought in Harley or Chad in exchange for Josh Treacy in a straight swap but as I said, if you’d prefer Treacy on your list that’s your prerogative.
Click to expand...
We absolutely would not trade Treacy for Reid. Treacy is currently the most important player on our list IMO. A trade for Warner with Treacy would keep you up at night and be a tougher decision, but I still think we would stick with Treacy.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Speculation Chad Warner

Similar threads

hawkinoz
Recommitted Chad Wingard [re-signed for 2024]
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
178
Views
14K
SSSSSS
SSSSSS

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top