List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion

[Masked Magician]

 

[Scodog10]

Couldn't be more than a 2nd rounder. But who knows. Also assuming Dees need cap relief. Harmes stats aren't great but I think would be better with more responsibility. In his best season, which was a one-off, he averaged 24 disposals and 4 clearances a game. That's what you'd hope with greater responsibility.

Real Levi Greenwood type, but with better ball use. I think he improves that next soldier up depth, I’d expect he plays 22 matches because he’s durable and high level (price dependent) I’d be on board. He’s a better option than Dunstan, IMO.

 

[well left]

Real Levi Greenwood type, but with better ball use. I think he improves that next soldier up depth, I’d expect he plays 22 matches because he’s durable and high level (price dependent) I’d be on board. He’s a better option than Dunstan, IMO.

Yeah I agree. 27 later this year so probably as old as we’d want to be looking at.

I’d probably pull the trigger if it was a second like Quicky proposed.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Harry O]

Hardly a key forward at 191cm

He is hardly 191cm

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Not a fan?

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Crazy that we have JDG & Moore.

 

[Carlthetruth]

Couldn't be more than a 2nd rounder. But who knows. Also assuming Dees need cap relief. Harmes stats aren't great but I think would be better with more responsibility. In his best season, which was a one-off, he averaged 24 disposals and 4 clearances a game. That's what you'd hope with greater responsibility.

Harmes stats aren't great in a premiership team and you want to acquire him, sound logic. With more responsibility he might be worse. Anyway we don't have to worry about it be 0% chance of happening.

 

[KinderSmock]

View attachment 1428388

Crazy that we have JDG & Moore.

Dustin Martin is a veteran. If you trade for him, you're not getting anything more than a name to turn some cash off-field. He can play good footy but he's unlikely to win a flag. Trac, on the other hand, is a different kettle of fish.

 

[manicpie]

He is hardly 191cm

you might want to check that

 

[Johno9911]

WA boy so might be a tougher ask to get him down to Vic, but Devon Robertson (OOC 2022) wouldn't be a terrible option for us to explore imo. Like many I was surprised he slid to the second round in the 2019 draft, and in a Brisbane side packed with midfield talent he hasn't really had much opportunity (only 20 games in 3 seasons, including being the sub on a couple of occasions too).

Will be 21 at the start of 2023, and is an inside midfielder who wins clearances and is very creative with his handballing in tight to set up more outside types (his clearance and contest work reminds me a lot of Libba at the dogs). I think he'd be a very nice Adams replacement in time, and a nice compliment to the likes of N Daicos or a Fin Macrae as more outside types.

 

[sr36]

Couldn't be more than a 2nd rounder. But who knows. Also assuming Dees need cap relief. Harmes stats aren't great but I think would be better with more responsibility. In his best season, which was a one-off, he averaged 24 disposals and 4 clearances a game. That's what you'd hope with greater responsibility.

Teens pick. Harmes is a good player who would be a starting centre square mid at most clubs.

 

[Jen2310]

WA boy so might be a tougher ask to get him down to Vic, but Devon Robertson (OOC 2022) wouldn't be a terrible option for us to explore imo. Like many I was surprised he slid to the second round in the 2019 draft, and in a Brisbane side packed with midfield talent he hasn't really had much opportunity (only 20 games in 3 seasons, including being the sub on a couple of occasions too).

Will be 21 at the start of 2023, and is an inside midfielder who wins clearances and is very creative with his handballing in tight to set up more outside types (his clearance and contest work reminds me a lot of Libba at the dogs). I think he'd be a very nice Adams replacement in time, and a nice compliment to the likes of N Daicos or a Fin Macrae as more outside types.

from the HS last week

YOUNG LION NOT ON MARKET — YET

Emerging Brisbane Lions on-baller Deven Robertson is out of contract at the end of next season, not this year, as many people believed.

The Lions announced in November 2020 that Robertson, along with teammate Jaxon Prior, had signed a one-year extension to tie them to the club through 2022.
But Robertson, who captained Western Australia at under-18 level, actually committed at the time for two more seasons rather than one.

The No. 22 pick in the 2019 draft has appeared only three times at senior level this year between injury and form but is considered an important part of Brisbane’s future.

 

[Quicky]

Harmes stats aren't great in a premiership team and you want to acquire him, sound logic. With more responsibility he might be worse. Anyway we don't have to worry about it be 0% chance of happening.

Yes Mr Sherman. Everything stinks!

 

[Harry O]

you might want to check that

Because official heights are always so accurate

 

[Pistol Night]

Because official heights are always so accurate

Apparently the boys at North used to piss fart around with Bommer Harvey’s height for the AFL record every year. The AFL rang them one year and asked if it was correct he’d grown 10cm over summer.

 

[manicpie]

Because official heights are always so accurate

ok

 

[KinderSmock]

Official heights are not accurate and fluctuate frequently. Players legitimately grow after they turn 18 as some have not finished their natural growth period. Others grow a lot more than expected and some shrink.

 

[MyManLynch]

Official heights are not accurate and fluctuate frequently. Players legitimately grow after they turn 18 as some have not finished their natural growth period. Others grow a lot more than expected and some shrink.

I refuse to do the Monday morning at St Kilda Beach joke.

 

[manicpie]

Official heights are not accurate and fluctuate frequently. Players legitimately grow after they turn 18 as some have not finished their natural growth period. Others grow a lot more than expected and some shrink.

You can tell by his highlights that he is only about 191cm. Standing next to Sexton, it's plain to see. Why isn't he playing seniors, he kicks a few goals

 

[KinderSmock]

What's Kieran Malone doing these days? He racked up 285 Supercoach points in a NAB League game. Invite him to play VFL?

 

[manicpie]

What's Kieran Malone doing these days? He racked up 285 Supercoach points in a NAB League game. Invite him to play VFL?

Playing for Rushworth

 

[adammania9]

View attachment 1428010

Harmes would be an interesting trade target.

Seriously. GUN. You build flags on players like James Harmes

 

[pablo disco bar]

Looks like De Goey unfortunately will be gone...

So should get a top 10 pick ??

 

[manicpie]

Looks like De Goey unfortunately will be gone...

So should get a top 10 pick ??

I think he has to offered 750kpa for 3 years or 4 to get band 1 compensation. I'm not sure anyone is going to offer that now

 

[Quicky]

Looks like De Goey unfortunately will be gone...

So should get a top 10 pick ??

Too early to make that call. I think it's unlikely.