Dale Thomas' Kick was over the line

[footyfreak]

It was a crap decision no doubt but there are plenty of other bad decisions that would result in a goal or not further out, it is just that you never get to see it and this one was right on the goal line so it is magnified ten fold.

Geelong got another goal shortly after anyway and led by 12 so it wasn't like their momentum was ruined at that very point.

If the pussies want they can have the goal and the victory they think they might have got it if it was allowed but they have to give the saints last years flag!

 

[Zeke]

All I know Brynes goal was a goal and the goal umpire changed the whole momentum of the match....

I sympathise.

I really do.

I saw Rocca kick a goal in the 2002 grand final that was given a point in a game we subsequently lost by just 9 points.

Tough.

 

[Lestat]

All I know Brynes goal was a goal and the goal umpire changed the whole momentum of the match....

Look, no doubt it was a goal, but the 'changed the whole momentum of the match' is just a complete load of crock.

You guys kicked the next goal...it had no impact on the momentum.

Ben Johnsons goal had much more impact on your 'momentum' then the Burns goal.

 

[maryjames]

Look, no doubt it was a goal, but the 'changed the whole momentum of the match' is just a complete load of crock.

You guys kicked the next goal...it had no impact on the momentum.

Ben Johnsons goal had much more impact on your 'momentum' then the Burns goal.

Of course it changed the course of the match. Cats would had there biggest lead of the match and were on a role.. Changed the momentum for Cats.. But in the end Pies were to good.

 

[Lestat]

Of course it changed the course of the match. Cats would had there biggest lead of the match and were on a role.. Changed the momentum for Cats.. But in the end Pies were to good.

Are you really this stupid or are you just pretending. Did you read what I said.

You guys kicked the next goal. So you wouldn't of 'had the biggest lead of the match' as you say, cause you had that same lead when you kicked the next goal.

You still had the momentum, cause you KICKED THE NEXT GOAL.

ffs, stop with your whinging...your coming across as a pathetic sook that can't handle seeing your team lose.

 

[MagpieMonkey]

Goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood

olllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll colllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllingwooooooooooooooooood foooooooooooooooooooooooooorever!

 

[maryjames]

Are you really this stupid or are you just pretending. Did you read what I said.

You guys kicked the next goal. So you wouldn't of 'had the biggest lead of the match' as you say, cause you had that same lead when you kicked the next goal.

You still had the momentum, cause you KICKED THE NEXT GOAL.

ffs, stop with your whinging...your coming across as a pathetic sook that can't handle seeing your team lose.

How long did it take till Cats kicked the next goal? The whole match went into lock down after that goal was not counted.. The game changed. You really are easy.. Pies fans really take there footy serious..

 

[Dawson]

In all seriousness that should have been a 50 shouldn't it... cos to me it looked blatently over the boundary when he smothered it....

What is the rule?

You seem to know, can you enlighten me?

 

[PumpyChowdown]

The Byrnes "point" certainly changed the momentum of the game.

The AFL simply MUST bring in video replays for goals.

 

[Dawson]

The Byrnes "point" certainly changed the momentum of the game.

The AFL simply MUST bring in video replays for goals.

But didn't Geelong kick the next goal after that?