For whatever reason umpires historically have paid HTB in this situation. Not sure what’s in the rule book but a little 1 metre handball - clearly to yourself as your “disposal” when being tackled - has been deemed HTB from my perspective historically.The htb annoyed me, because the tackler didn’t hold him or the ball up, even if he had prior.
When I saw the decision the other night I wasn’t surprised and it was consistent with what I have always seen (perhaps without exception) in such similar incidences adjudicated. Would be good to get clarity on this from the AFL