Do the Swans now have the best forward line in the comp?

[TheWhiteRhino]

FF: McGlynn Tippett Morton
HF: Goodes Reid Jetta

Throw in Rohan, LRT and Pyke and O'Keefe and McVeigh rotating through.

I still think the Hawks are out in front, but it's closing at the top.

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

The best forward line that money can buy.

 

[ruka]

I think West Coast and Collingwood would be closer to Hawthorn than Sydney. Tippett is overpaid mediocrity and Lynch was a far better pick up.

 

[TheWhiteRhino]

We may have overpaid for Tippett, but to say that Lynch was a far better pick up just shows come rose coloured and completely jaded Adelaide supporters have become towards Tippett.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

No, West Coast, Hawthorn and Collingwood have better forward lines.

 

[ruka]

Heh, no.

I thought Tippett was shit even when he played for Adelaide. He had sone misguided role of keeping KPD's off Tex.

 

[coryne]

FF: McGlynn Tippett Morton
HF: Goodes Reid Jetta

Throw in Rohan, LRT and Pyke and O'Keefe and McVeigh rotating through.

I still think the Hawks are out in front, but it's closing at the top.

Not for the first half of the 2013 season ................

 

[MarkP]

The best forward line that money can buy.

Well gosh.

Who would have thought that in a game where you buy players you get a forward line paid for by money?

Staggers the imagination doesn't it?

And no, West Coast, those funnny angry people we beat in September that seem to cry a lot and Collingwood have better forward lines than Sydney. Geelong too I believe. Ours is above average at best but not outstanding by any means. All Tippett does IF he gets to Sydney is make the matchups harder for the opposition.

 

[.Shotties.]

I hate you, TWR.

 

[Top_4_Tiger]

Lol Morton?

Fail.

 

[Morris Major]

West Coast and Hawthorn

/thread

(Goodes does his best work in the middle and Morton has only played a few good games since McGlynn went down, notsureifsrs about OP)

 

[BUTTON 92]

So you think adding Tippett to one of the weaker forwardlines in the comp makes it jump to the best in the comp?
Yet Tippett was only worth pick 23 and a pile of shite Jesse White?

 

[.Shotties.]

Yet Tippett was only worth pick 23 and a pile of shite Jesse White?

No, he's worth two first round draft picks, two second rounders and a few hundred thousand dollars.

 

[thekelvin]

West Coast and Hawthorn surely?

Darling Kennedy Le Cras Cox Nic Nat Hill Nicoski
Throw masten and shuey on the flanks

It's easy to forget West Coast had a decimated forward line in 2012, but the talent is still on our list, touch wood is all available for 2013.

 

[Morris Major]

No, he's worth two first round draft picks, two second rounders and a few hundred thousand dollars.

LOL'd hard at that one

Nicoski

Underrated 2011 season, what a revelation in the forward line!

 

[StevenwellerHFC]

Far from it.

 

[swansfan51]

FF: McGlynn Tippett Morton
HF: Goodes Reid Jetta

Of those 6 you listed: 1 has had a 50+ goal season, 3 have had 40+ goal seasons, 2 have had 30+ goal seasons

 

[Balance]

They have the best forward line without Tippett. A good forward line does not need stars rather, players who can share the ball, rotate, and good feed coming in from the midfield.

 

[WIZARD24]

Yes but in the non conventional way they can all can play different roles which stops opposition defences getting on top for long periods but its will be the end for a a few by the end of next season

 

[J_Moore]

Lol Morton?

Fail.

Lol 2 goals in 10 minutes in a GF.

 

[swansfan51]

Lol Morton?

Fail.

Was your leading goalscorer in 2009

 

[Silvagnis]

FF: McGlynn Tippett Morton
HF: Goodes Reid Jetta

Throw in Rohan, LRT and Pyke and O'Keefe and McVeigh rotating through.

I still think the Hawks are out in front, but it's closing at the top.

Only if they add Tommy Walsh...

 

[legend166]

Depends on Reid's ceiling. If he's near it now, nah. If he can become a 50-60 goal forward in a couple of years, yeah.

But for 2013, no. But it's better than 2012 and we won the flag, so I'm happy.

 

[BUTTON 92]

Of those 6 you listed: 1 has had a 50+ goal season, 3 have had 40+ goal seasons, 2 have had 30+ goal seasons

As I'm sure would be the case with most forward lines. If not they would be better statistically that way...

 

[Top_4_Tiger]

Lol 2 goals in 10 minutes in a GF.

You'll be disappointed if you expect him to be a consistent 25 game player in "the best forward line in the AFL" if you're basing it off, as you said, 10 minutes of football as a depth player

Barely got a game in 2012 and your own players said they didn't trust him halfway through the season, yet you think he'll be part of "the best forward line in the AFL"