Do they make the grade?

[Captain Blood]

If there were only 12 teams in the competition, would any of these players make it onto a list? Remeber, you would lose around 160 players.
Do they make the grade?

Tent Croad
Jason Cloke
Scott Lucas
Troy Longmuir
Tom Harley
Joel Bowden
Jade Rawlings
Drew Petrie
Robert Copeland
Ashley Sampi
Chad Cornes
Matt McGuire
Brett Burton
Ben Holland
Brett Kirk
The entire Carlton list

 

[bOmBeR_BoY1]

They all would, except for Trent Croad and Ben Holland.
Would be some question marks over Jason Cloke though.

 

[Lidge]

Can only assume you don't watch many (if any non Richmond games)!

Of that list...Croad, Cloke, Holland - possibly Bowden would be chasing kicks in the SANFL/WAFL/VFL

 

[CharlieG]

Putting Kirk in that list betrays your ignorance of how football works.

Agree with Lidge - the only players that are doubtfuls are Holland, Cloke and Croad. Bowden is no star but he would certainly be useful as a fourth/fifth best midfielder. Would get into about 14 of the 16 teams in the comp.

 

[Ateen7tee]

Originally posted by Captain Blood
If there were only 12 teams in the competition, would any of these players make it onto a list? Remeber, you would lose around 160 players.
Do they make the grade?

Tent Croad
Jason Cloke
Scott Lucas
Troy Longmuir
Tom Harley
Joel Bowden
Jade Rawlings
Drew Petrie
Robert Copeland
Ashley Sampi
Chad Cornes
Matt McGuire
Brett Burton
Ben Holland
Brett Kirk
The entire Carlton list

Chad Cornes?? Why not add Tredrea while you're at it ....

 

[dan warna]

sampi, cornes, maguire, lucas and rawlings are pretty classy units.

cloke might just make it.

croad is a superstar and deserves to be paid 500K, preferably by a modelling agency...

the carlton list would make a pretty gun outfit in the wangaratta little league 3rds...

 

[Ron]

Originally posted by Captain Blood

Scott Lucas
Jade Rawlings
Drew Petrie
Robert Copeland
Ashley Sampi
Chad Cornes

Your stupidity amazes me

 

[bigbaddaz]

I agree with "your stupidity amazes me"

The entire Carlton list. Sure its not the best.

Nick Stevens
Brendan Fevola
Anthony Koutoufides
Lance Whitnall
Ryan Houlihan
Matthew Lappin
Scott Camporeale

they would all make into teams if there was 12 clubs

and as for jade rawlings, if he kicks straight, he could go close to winning the coleman medal this year!

 

[Adrian Shelton]

With 10 shots at goal every week Jade will win the Coleman(with 100.120 by the way) You can send all the other guys to the SANFL anytime you want too!

 

[theorangeapple]

im sorry but did i miss something. captain blood are u suggesting these players shouldnt be on AFL lists.

all except cloke and possibly holland. give croad a year to prove howbad he is then he'll be their aswell.

btw, sampi and maguire are 2 of the top youngsters in the league.

 

[Cat In A Hat]

Tom Harley makes it, very under-rated.

 

[Chemical]

Originally posted by Captain Blood
The entire Carlton list

but we still beat you...weird

 

[Cat In A Hat]

when did u beat rich? a rich supporter started the thread

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Amazes me when people think that when a team is bad, the whole list must be bad. You can have a dozen great players in a side and if your next 6 are hopeless, the team will fail dismally.

Carlton have plenty of players that other clubs would readily snap up IMO.

Nick Stevens
Brendan Fevola
Anthony Koutoufides
Lance Whitnall
Ryan Houlihan
Matthew Lappin
Scott Camporeale

Add to that Thornton, Scotland, Sporn, Waite, Angwin for sure. It won't be long before Norman and Fisher are rated as well.

These Carlton jokes might have been funny when they seemed to be true but now they are just ignorant. Carry on, makes no difference to me whether I laugh at the post or the poster!

 

[smilingassassin]

Sampi?

He kicked five goals on Saturday f..kwit! And he won the game for WC against a gallant Bulldogs Team.

Captain Blood? Should be Captain ****stain.

And any team in the competition would bite Mark Williams arm off if he offered up young Cornes.

 

[noodle]

add richo to your list blood.

 

[Eagles4Ever]

Some people will write any old crap to start a new thread.
FFS if its not worth posting then dont post it. It just clutters the forum.

 

[BALLDALROOXGOD]

Originally posted by Captain Blood
If there were only 12 teams in the competition, would any of these players make it onto a list? Remeber, you would lose around 160 players.
Do they make the grade?

Tent Croad
Jason Cloke
Scott Lucas
Troy Longmuir
Tom Harley
Joel Bowden
Jade Rawlings
Drew Petrie
Robert Copeland
Ashley Sampi
Chad Cornes
Matt McGuire
Brett Burton
Ben Holland
Brett Kirk
The entire Carlton list

Do you have a clue???????????? why am i asking??

Sampi was nearly BOG on the weekend
Maguire has been a champion since febuary holding the saints backlline intact
Croad will get there he's still settling dont forget what he can do!!!
Chad Cornes?? get real he plays for port he has to be good!
Burton! hes obvoiusly in his last years but dont disrespect a great premiership player
Lucas kicked 4 great goals on the weekend keeping the bombers in it!

YOUR A FOOL!! These 12 players would make any of those 12 teams!!!
BUT...... I think I know what your getting at and youre right but YOU HAVE NAMED THE WRONG PLAYERS!!! the last 6 players on carltons Bullies and few other AFL clubs should be noted not outright GUN players that you have mentioned!!