DT/SC questions here (check roster watch first)

[Magpie Ink]

Thanks for that whatboutbob

 

[benbanjo]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

hi guys sorry to intrude....

just wanted to ask.... black picked up 31 disposals... yet only polled 76... i dindt watch the game.... but did he totally butcher the ball? seems somewhat low no?

 

[POBT]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

hi guys sorry to intrude....

just wanted to ask.... black picked up 31 disposals... yet only polled 76... i dindt watch the game.... but did he totally butcher the ball? seems somewhat low no?

Has been less effective with his disposal this year overall. He had a good game against Richmond where he hit the target more efficiently but wasn't great with his disposal on Sat night.

 

[setantypants]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Hey guys, what's the injury situation on Rohan Bewick? Should I keep him or trade him out this week?

 

[T Rick]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Hey guys, what's the injury situation on Rohan Bewick? Should I keep him or trade him out this week?

no longer on the injury list, considering our midfield got outclassed by the gold coast it's very likely rohan will slot straight back in this week. i'd hold on, he hasn't made enough cash yet to be worth the trade. (i'm in the same position).

 

[setantypants]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

no longer on the injury list, considering our midfield got outclassed by the gold coast it's very likely rohan will slot straight back in this week. i'd hold on, he hasn't made enough cash yet to be worth the trade. (i'm in the same position).

Awesome, thanks. Yeah he could make another 150,000 if he gets the gametime!

 

[pill]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Whats the deal with Polec? Is he injured or just out of favour?

 

[whatboutbob]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Whats the deal with Polec? Is he injured or just out of favour?

Not injured. Needs to work on his game a bit.

 

[Demon 86]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Hi guys, what is Retzlaffs job security like? Especially now that Browny is a week away? Thanks in advance!

 

[whatboutbob]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Hi guys, what is Retzlaffs job security like? Especially now that Browny is a week away? Thanks in advance!

A very good chance to be the one to make way for Brown's return.

 

[Demon 86]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Yeah thought that might be the case...

Cheers mate!

 

[berisha]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Is Xavier Clarke likely to get a gig anytime soon?

 

[whatboutbob]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Is Xavier Clarke likely to get a gig anytime soon?

As per his Roster Watch thread he tweaked his hammy last week, so he's out for "a couple of weeks". Given his injury history I'd steer clear.

 

[berisha]

Re: Never thought it would come to thid

Kudos.

 

[Simmonds2Hislop]

How far away is Polec from getting a recall?

 

[Covvy]

Josh Green, will he be the sub or not?

Cheers

 

[greennick]

How far away is Polec from getting a recall?

I would be keen to know this too. I am pretty sure he's going to be out for Hibberd this week to give me additional flexibility in my mid/fwd.

 

[POBT]

Josh Green, will he be the sub or not?

Cheers

I reckon he might. I'd like to see Voss replace a tall with a small on the subs bench and Green would be a good option to come in for Retzlaff or Maguire.

 

[POBT]

I would be keen to know this too. I am pretty sure he's going to be out for Hibberd this week to give me additional flexibility in my mid/fwd.

Hard to say. He's underweight and runs out of puff a bit too quickly at senior level. He'll be back this year but could be a little while longer before he is.

 

[whatboutbob]

Two crystal ball questions I'm afraid.

Polec had a poor game in the NEAFL last week apparently, for what that's worth.

As for Green being the sub - with the number of rookies in our squad it is impossible to tell.

 

[blynd_freddie]

Josh Green, will he be the sub or not?

Cheers

If it were my call I would not have Josh start as a Sub.

IMO too much nervous energy might be wasted while sitting on the pine...
but I suppose this may vary depending on the individual [Gaff being regularly selected as the sub is an obvious counterclaim to my opinion ]

 

[Covvy]

Yes, well that's my problem. I want to trade out either Gaff or Atley for Green, but there's no point in doing it if Green's the sub.

 

[Shaka]

Re: Josh Green

Hopefully he won't get the fright of the big stage - all the best the him. For those who have watched him, will his body size be a disadvantage? Also thinking of bringing him in my supercoach team - good/bad call?

 

[greennick]

Two crystal ball questions I'm afraid.

Polec had a poor game in the NEAFL last week apparently, for what that's worth.

As for Green being the sub - with the number of rookies in our squad it is impossible to tell.

Thanks. I ended up keeping Polec and getting rid of Curnow due to the length of his injury. I will re-assess Polec next week and consider upgrading him to a premium with the Curnow cash.

 

[POBT]

Re: Josh Green

Hopefully he won't get the fright of the big stage - all the best the him. For those who have watched him, will his body size be a disadvantage? Also thinking of bringing him in my supercoach team - good/bad call?

If you can avoid it, I wouldn't bring Green in this week. It will be so much easier to assess his form with 1 or 2 senior games under his belt. If circumstances dictate that you need to bring someone in, he's not a bad option IMO as he should get games given our position on the ladder.