EDFL Premier Discussion 2024

[keilorwest600]

Mate the reserves unfortunately is only for family and club orientated people as the standard is horrendous. There used to be 6-7 players you could say were senior quality in either premier, div1 or lower leagues but no struggling to find even 2 who you would chase..

Absolute cap Strathmore didn't have as strong as a team as they did last year when they won it but keilors team anyone of them could play seniors at other clubs probably even in premier so wouldn't say its that bad when Sadler and Cassar running round in it, the game today overall wasn't great but was just a weird game

 

[Turbos mail]

Pacco are pretenders turbo
Spending the most over the last 5-6 years still can’t win it
To busy celebrating there first finals win flogs

Keilor are a very good team but they have nothing on clubs like Melton when it comes to looking after their own. They play with 20 x 1 pointers. Keilor although they talk up there junior programs they played on 45/46 points. If we are being real and the league had some courage they would be on maybe 40 points with the amount of juniors they have and pillage. It’s the only way to bring these clubs back to the pack.
But I congratulate them on the win.

 

[Turbos mail]

Absolute cap Strathmore didn't have as strong as a team as they did last year when they won it but keilors team anyone of them could play seniors at other clubs probably even in premier so wouldn't say its that bad when Sadler and Cassar running round in it, the game today overall wasn't great but was just a weird game

Nah maybe 2-3 could play premier. Burke & Cooper McKenzie-George maybe

 

[Gremlin77]

Nah maybe 2-3 could play premier. Burke & Cooper McKenzie-George maybe

The Strathmore reserves coach is taking over at Tulla so maybe we will see how many he can get and if they can play regular senior footy. It was very swirly out on the ground it wasn’t easy to play clean footy and that took away a bit from the spectacle. IMO there would be a dozen plus that could handle Div.1 footy from todays game

 

[halfback10]

Keilor are a very good team but they have nothing on clubs like Melton when it comes to looking after their own. They play with 20 x 1 pointers. Keilor although they talk up there junior programs they played on 45/46 points. If we are being real and the league had some courage they would be on maybe 40 points with the amount of juniors they have and pillage. It’s the only way to bring these clubs back to the pack.
But I congratulate them on the win.

Maybe check your facts before commenting....Keilor played on 39/46 points, Pascoe Vale played on 46/46.

 

[ZingerAbed]

The Strathmore reserves coach is taking over at Tulla so maybe we will see how many he can get and if they can play regular senior footy. It was very swirly out on the ground it wasn’t easy to play clean footy and that took away a bit from the spectacle. IMO there would be a dozen plus that could handle Div.1 footy from todays game

There’s only been a few that have left after being stuck in the twos at Keilor/Strathmore/Abers in recent years so not a big pool to draw from to assess

I agree with your call around a dozen+ reserves from today would hold their own in Div 1

 

[Wysiwyg]

What do we think of the goal awarded in the 2nd from the spoil that went into the square. Surely that wasn’t a goal. The vision didn’t show much and the keilor player wasn’t even celebrating. Oh my…. Poor call in a GF.

Wasn’t even close. Goal umpire totally lost.

 

[ChaosMail]

Yes they all are in premier hence my response. Pacco played a lot of kids so will only improve I reckon.
Keilor young forwards were great. The taller one #45 was on the interchange bench for reserves vs APW. So were they trying to qualify him?

Who cares it’s part of the rules they can sit on a ressies bench so what. Every team with vfl players can do it so no biggie

 

[Calmdowngoldy]

I loved East Keilor so much I wasn't even paid to coach. In fact I paid them to let me pretend to coach. I thought my inability to teach skills or strategy might have got in the way but cash talks.

Pat I know I you are out of coaching now but is there anything different over the journey you could pass on

 

[Wysiwyg]

Forgot the most important Trump card Tudor has in his deck...I'll give you his stats tomorrow night!

Go on.

 

[ChaosMail]

Was talking to a Keilor supporter today he said 18/22 today have VFL/AFL exp and still 3-4 with VFL exp that didn’t play today, that’s absurd if true.

Then add the best local footy coach of all time to a team that doesn’t even need to be coached…. That’s taking the absolute pi55

Parker’s have enough cash to beat that longbow???

 

[The Longblow]

Was talking to a Keilor supporter today he said 18/22 today have VFL/AFL exp and still 3-4 with VFL exp that didn’t play today, that’s absurd if true.

Then add the best local footy coach of all time to a team that doesn’t even need to be coached…. That’s taking the absolute pi55

Parker’s have enough cash to beat that longbow???

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

 

[stroketurboego]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

On a far inferior comp… yeah good one


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

Deer Park would never have won a flag if they played those seasons in the EDFL. And their results in 2024 prove it

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

On another note, whos Mark Bullen

 

[Deer park over 40s res]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

lol yeh in the wrfl were dp bought 7

 

[ChaosMail]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

Nah longbow cmon now, your not comparing Bullen coaching a team that cost 500k a year in a disability league, vs McGuanne and EDFL. Bullen not qualified to tie mcguannes laces.

What would Keilor do to the current WRFL premiers in hoppers crossing? Win by 30 goals is my tip

 

[ROOTA#6]

Nah longbow cmon now, your not comparing Bullen coaching a team that cost 500k a year in a disability league, vs McGuanne and EDFL. Bullen not qualified to tie mcguannes laces.

What would Keilor do to the current WRFL premiers in hoppers crossing? Win by 30 goals is my

Mick had a reasonable stint at Gisborne also

 

[Jen2310]

It was a good game. Decent crowd, I wonder that number --

Keilor got on top after QT I'd say, and the second half was dominant.
Though there was a goal or two Pascoe Vale were stiff.

There was one from a Keilor player It didn't look like he went off his boot on the goal line, but the umpires paid it as a goal. I said to the blokes next to me - I'm not sure he even got a boot to it. But no ARC here lol

Petric kicked a ripper dribbler from the pocket that was pretty crazy. He had a good day out with 4 goals.

A few AFL boys came down to watch. I saw Elijiah Hollands pass me by, and I heard Oskar Baker

13

Oskar Baker

Age

26

Ht

184cm

Wt

87kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.8

4star

K

8.8

3star

HB

5.0

4star

M

4.4

4star

T

1.7

4star

CL

1.3

3star

No current season stats available

D

16.0

4star

K

10.8

4star

HB

5.2

4star

M

5.2

5star

T

2.0

4star

CL

1.2

4star

was around as well.

This was my 2nd ever local game (my first being last week's prelim) and I'm not sure of other leagues, but felt the standard here was pretty good. Quite enjoyable to watch
The atmosphere from the crowd and players was fun.

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

It was a good game. Decent crowd, I wonder that number --

Keilor got on top after QT I'd say, and the second half was dominant.
Though there was a goal or two Pascoe Vale were stiff.

There was one from a Keilor player It didn't look like he went off his boot on the goal line, but the umpires paid it as a goal. I said to the blokes next to me - I'm not sure he even got a boot to it. But no ARC here lol

Petric kicked a ripper dribbler from the pocket that was pretty crazy. He had a good day out with 4 goals.

A few AFL boys came down to watch. I saw Elijiah Hollands pass me by, and I heard Oskar Baker was around as well.

This was my 2nd ever local game (my first being last week's prelim) and I'm not sure of other leagues, but felt the standard here was pretty good. Quite enjoyable to watch
The atmosphere from the crowd and players was fun.

Essendon FCs recruiting team were there too

 

[Bissa3]

Mark Bullen leaves Mick McGuanes coaching record for dead when you compare matches coached and flags. Thank you.

My grandma would of coached those $500k DP teams to flags in that comp.

 

[Jerry gee]

Deer Park would never have won a flag if they played those seasons in the EDFL. And their results in 2024 prove it

Watch this space the sleeping giant is coming.
3 ex afl players one being a former Gold Coast and Port Adelaide player to be announced as playing coach along side 1 point players returning

 

[ChazzMichaels]

Watch this space the sleeping giant is coming.
3 ex afl players one being a former Gold Coast and Port Adelaide player to be announced as playing coach along side 1 point players returning

A sleeping giant would not pump themselves up consistently and remind us all how many flags you’ve won in another comp. How close did you get to Keilor this year? And that was without them being full strength. As stated previously, start by beating some of the top 5 teams (which you didn’t this year). And make finals. That would be a good start.

 

[Turbos mail]

Watch this space the sleeping giant is coming.
3 ex afl players one being a former Gold Coast and Port Adelaide player to be announced as playing coach along side 1 point players returning

Trent McKenzie??

 

[Flyingleslieskite]

Watch this space the sleeping giant is coming.
3 ex afl players one being a former Gold Coast and Port Adelaide player to be announced as playing coach along side 1 point players returning

Yes we knew about Trent Mckenzie, I reckon Deer Park were in talks with his management for the last six years wanting to know if he was being delisted or not