Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'd take that menegola has some skill. Probably would want a swap of picks aswell 3Rd rounder for their 2nd etc.Menegola for Ablett straight swap?
They do have Carlton's 2nd round pick don't they? That's as good as a late first rounder.
Geelong need a premiership now with the way they've recruited, and not drafted / developed kids. Ablett fits that bill & therefore they need to pay up for him. Otherwise make a strong stance as a club, retire him and not give a rival a free kick.
Also a large chunk of his contract was front ended. The guy has some cheek and I seriously hope he doesn't play another game for us.
Menegola for Ablett straight swap?
Menegola just re-signed for 3 years mate.
Ok so a contract all of a sudden matters at Geelong but not up here on the GC..
Ok so a contract all of a sudden matters at Geelong but not up here on the GC..
I think every gc supporter would be happy to see him go now. Not worth the trouble.The question is not so much if a contract matters to Geelong ..its whether a player who has a contract and seems happy will agree to a move. Its not usa sports , although plenty would like it to change to something like it , where a club can push trade an unwilling player. Here a contract give the player power.
So really the starting point must be identifying a player who you like , and who sees the advantage of going to the Suns. If he is worth more or less than GA it could be balanced with a pick swap , the key is to just finding the player who wants a fresh start. Traditionally , unless there is a great incentive , most players rarely move if they are contracted , getting regular games and are happy.
To me , if a deal with a player is involved , it would be more likely to be a player that plays a similar role now to what GA may play and may get pushed down the selection list (eg. Lang , Gregson ) or a player that is fringe and may be looking for a regular game (eg. GHS , Ruggles ) ...or a player who is still uncontracted and could be tempted with a big offer. The obvious example would be throwing a bucket of money JK's way ..several 100 more than we could offer may turn his head.
Unfortunately , it seems a deal of some sort will be done. I think I have been clear on my pov. From an outsider view Id suspect with a new coach to be appointed at the Suns he would want clean air as much as anything. Would he want another 12 months of these on and off games? He may just be happy to make GA someone else's problem ..and if can get a solid player that strengthens your best 22 selection options for 5 plus years from the deal , all the better.
I think every gc supporter would be happy to see him go now. Not worth the trouble.
Get a deal done quickly and both clubs can move on. Pick 19 or GHS and 33 for Ablett and 39 would surely satisfy most people.
A swap of picks or a pick alone. GHS is as soft as butter, no more list cloggers.I think every gc supporter would be happy to see him go now. Not worth the trouble.
Get a deal done quickly and both clubs can move on. Pick 19 or GHS and 33 for Ablett and 39 would surely satisfy most people.
I'm a fan of spite.I'd be happy to make GAJ retire purely out of spite
I'll pay thatOk so a contract all of a sudden matters at Geelong but not up here on the GC..
He's a free agent. I would definitely like him at the SunsWould we be Ok with Motlop as he is definitely going?
I've willingly lost a nose or two for it over the yearsI'm a fan of spite.
I would have thought that Geel will baulk at giving too much for Ablett and certainly not Menegola. Mitchell was playing more games than GAJ and he was given away for virtually nothing as was Lewis. Ablett wants out and i'm assuming GC will want an end to the fact he wants out and doesn't want to play for your club. He may well only play 1 more season and unlikely a full one given his injuries.The question is not so much if a contract matters to Geelong ..its whether a player who has a contract and seems happy will agree to a move. Its not usa sports , although plenty would like it to change to something like it , where a club can push trade an unwilling player. Here a contract give the player power.
So really the starting point must be identifying a player who you like , and who sees the advantage of going to the Suns. If he is worth more or less than GA it could be balanced with a pick swap , the key is to just finding the player who wants a fresh start. Traditionally , unless there is a great incentive , most players rarely move if they are contracted , getting regular games and are happy.
To me , if a deal with a player is involved , it would be more likely to be a player that plays a similar role now to what GA may play and may get pushed down the selection list (eg. Lang , Gregson ) or a player that is fringe and may be looking for a regular game (eg. GHS , Ruggles ) ...or a player who is still uncontracted and could be tempted with a big offer. The obvious example would be throwing a bucket of money JK's way ..several 100 more than we could offer may turn his head.
Unfortunately , it seems a deal of some sort will be done. I think I have been clear on my pov. From an outsider view Id suspect with a new coach to be appointed at the Suns he would want clean air as much as anything. Would he want another 12 months of these on and off games? He may just be happy to make GA someone else's problem ..and if can get a solid player that strengthens your best 22 selection options for 5 plus years from the deal , all the better.
Don't need too trade for Motlop he's a free agentI think Motlop is rumoured to Port, so maybe a 3 way trade?
Ablett is still a top 5 player in the comp, no club would give him away for nothing. We would rather see him retire. If the family mater was that bad he would of walked away by now. He's just trying to screw everyone over, he's not even injured, watch him play every game next year at Geelong if they can get a deal doneI would have thought that Geel will baulk at giving too much for Ablett and certainly not Menegola. Mitchell was playing more games than GAJ and he was given away for virtually nothing as was Lewis. Ablett wants out and i'm assuming GC will want an end to the fact he wants out and doesn't want to play for your club. He may well only play 1 more season and unlikely a full one given his injuries.
I would avoid the confrontational approach and let him walk and then give some younger players the chance to take up the midfield slack.
I'm not sure how others look at it, but for me he doesn't want to be at the GC for family reasons so accept it and more on. Brad Hill didn't screw us over we traded him for less than his worth because that's what he wanted.Ablett is still a top 5 player in the comp, no club would give him away for nothing. We would rather see him retire. If the family mater was that bad he would of walked away by now. He's just trying to screw everyone over, he's not even injured, watch him play every game next year at Geelong if they can get a deal done