News Farewell Scully, KMarshall, Narkle, FEvans, Clurey

Remove this Banner Ad

TeeKray said:
It confuses me that people have a problem with fringe players being past a certain age but then also complain about lack of depth.
Click to expand...

I don't have a problem with our depth apart from maybe key defence, which I still think is comfortably within manageable limits.

I don have a problem with our attitude towards developing talls. Guess we'll just use another future first to plug that gap down the line.
 
TeeKray said:
It confuses me that people have a problem with fringe players being past a certain age but then also complain about lack of depth.
Click to expand...
There’s depth and then there’s Boak.
Better off drafting a late pick kid who might turn out good against someone we know is finished.
I like him personally but no way he should be on our list.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The issue with our depth is that Hinkley prefers to play middling veterans to genuine spuds to unaccountable older players at the expense at trying younger players.

There were 44 games handed out to McEntee, Narkle and Evans, two of which were delisted and Jed being saved by his contract.

Boak got 23 games and he played OK but it would've been nice to invest in a guy who could leapfrog his type of impact after a fair whack of games like Lorenz.

Obviously Dixon on one leg with 18 games. There wasn't a lot of options but I still would've played Lord with two legs and see what happens.

The unaccountable Burton with 15 games.
 
Holden Hillbilly said:
Did Port Adelaide make a mistake delisting teenage key forward Thomas Scully while retaining 36-year-old veteran Travis Boak? That was the question posed by Mark Bickley on SEN SA Breakfast on Tuesday morning.
The Power announced a slew of delistings on Monday, including Quinton Narkle and Francis Evans, who both featured in finals action in 2024. It came following the decision to re-sign Boak, who played 23 games this season.
Scully, a 19-year-old 203cm key forward did not debut for the Power, stuck behind the likes of Charlie Dixon, Todd Marshall, Mitch Georgiades, Jeremy Finlayson and Ollie Lord.
He was also stuck in a SANFL team that went 4-14 and finished with a percentage of 40, making it tough for a key forward to develop and perform.
Bickley feels Scully had some potential and was caught off guard by his culling. “I was a little bit surprised because he at different stages showed a little bit at SANFL level,” the two-time premiership skipper told SEN SA Breakfast.
“And that’s difficult when you’re a forward and there’s not a lot of ball coming in. “He’s 200cm and it takes a little bit longer for big guys to develop.”
www.sen.com.au

Did Port Adelaide make the right call delisting teenage key forward while keeping Travis Boak?

“I was a little bit surprised because he at different stages showed a little bit at SANFL level.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au
Click to expand...
**** YES
 
FishingRick04 said:
Which long term player would we play instead?
Click to expand...
Like Macca said Lorenz and Jackson for a start. I get that they wanted to pick a team to try to win but if they’re players who aren’t in the long term picture then why continue playing them if they didn’t think they’re worth keeping in the long run?
 
El_Scorcho said:
I don't have a problem with our depth apart from maybe key defence, which I still think is comfortably within manageable limits.

I don have a problem with our attitude towards developing talls. Guess we'll just use another future first to plug that gap down the line.
Click to expand...

I agree. There are a few issues at play here, firstly that a number of our young players are late picks and have not been in the system for long. Having said that, Lorenz and Anastasopulos showed enough to get more than one quarter of AFL football between them in the minor round. But Ken locked onto 25-6 players he would only choose from, especially late in the year when he was trying to protect his job after being booed by those meanies.

Physical development is an issue, Scully and Marshall would never have been ready to go this year (and Marshall never showed enough to be picked). I've said already I would've given Scully another season. All of our first year players looked too lightweight.

Jackson keeps getting injured at the wrong times, I have a lot of time for him, although he could do with a few extra kgs as well. There's a borderline case to be made for him having been given a game or few by now.

Charleson was injured a lot and didn't really ever look like it. Hope he shows more next year. McCallum just never looked like it.

Walsh looks a get, just needs some more size and experience. Lord needs an injury free run, he has to show something next year.

Sinn looked like he could establish himself, his last few games were ok.

Visentini is a potential first ruck, Williams is in the twilight zone.

Evans is a beauty. Great pick up.
 
backtozero said:
Depth is atrocious across the park.

I don't know how anyone could watch the Magpies this year and think otherwise.
Click to expand...

Barring a clear run with injury/suspension, the Magpies isn't the depth, it's the depth of the depth.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ford Fairlane said:
I agree. There are a few issues at play here, firstly that a number of our young players are late picks and have not been in the system for long. Having said that, Lorenz and Anastasopulos showed enough to get more than one quarter of AFL football between them in the minor round. But Ken locked onto 25-6 players he would only choose from, especially late in the year when he was trying to protect his job after being booed by those meanies.

Physical development is an issue, Scully and Marshall would never have been ready to go this year (and Marshall never showed enough to be picked). I've said already I would've given Scully another season. All of our first year players looked too lightweight.

Jackson keeps getting injured at the wrong times, I have a lot of time for him, although he could do with a few extra kgs as well. There's a borderline case to be made for him having been given a game or few by now.

Charleson was injured a lot and didn't really ever look like it. Hope he shows more next year. McCallum just never looked like it.

Walsh looks a get, just needs some more size and experience. Lord needs an injury free run, he has to show something next year.

Sinn looked like he could establish himself, his last few games were ok.

Visentini is a potential first ruck, Williams is in the twilight zone.

Evans is a beauty. Great pick up.
Click to expand...

I’d of delisted Williams before Scully. The sanfl games I watched, Williams was trash.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
TeeKray said:
.... Otherwise he would've just sat there and collected another ~400-500k to play SANFL as he did this year.
Click to expand...
Fancy paying an existing Port Adelaide player to provide experience and leadership in the SNAFL side when we could trade in Ratkins instead. :rolleyes:
 
Scodges said:
I’d of delisted Williams before Scully. The sanfl games I watched, Williams was trash.
Click to expand...
Looked lazy and disinterested in a couple of the Magpies games I saw live.

Contracted until the end of next season so probably lucky not to be coming out of contract.
 
[emoji[emoji6]][emoji[emoji6]][emoji[emoji6][emoji6]]" data-quote="Steve Dore" data-source="post: 0" class="bbCodeBlock bbCodeBlock--expandable bbCodeBlock--quote js-expandWatch">
Steve Dore said:
Looked lazy and disinterested in a couple of the Magpies games I saw live.

Contracted until the end of next season so probably lucky not to be coming out of contract.
Click to expand...

He’s not making the most of his AFL career. Shame that, he’s probably one of our best kicks.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
240volt said:
Lorenz definitely should have got more games last year.
Jackson I’m not so sure about, his season wasn’t as good for me as his 2023 season.
Maybe because playing in a shit side but he showed little to be worthy of selection.
Click to expand...
Sinn not playing that Fremantle game in the final round was stupid both at the time and in hindsight.
 
Holden Hillbilly said:
Did Port Adelaide make a mistake delisting teenage key forward Thomas Scully while retaining 36-year-old veteran Travis Boak? That was the question posed by Mark Bickley on SEN SA Breakfast on Tuesday morning.
The Power announced a slew of delistings on Monday, including Quinton Narkle and Francis Evans, who both featured in finals action in 2024. It came following the decision to re-sign Boak, who played 23 games this season.
Scully, a 19-year-old 203cm key forward did not debut for the Power, stuck behind the likes of Charlie Dixon, Todd Marshall, Mitch Georgiades, Jeremy Finlayson and Ollie Lord.
He was also stuck in a SANFL team that went 4-14 and finished with a percentage of 40, making it tough for a key forward to develop and perform.
Bickley feels Scully had some potential and was caught off guard by his culling. “I was a little bit surprised because he at different stages showed a little bit at SANFL level,” the two-time premiership skipper told SEN SA Breakfast.
“And that’s difficult when you’re a forward and there’s not a lot of ball coming in. “He’s 200cm and it takes a little bit longer for big guys to develop.”
www.sen.com.au

Did Port Adelaide make the right call delisting teenage key forward while keeping Travis Boak?

“I was a little bit surprised because he at different stages showed a little bit at SANFL level.”
www.sen.com.au www.sen.com.au
Click to expand...
I mean acting like this was a choice between Boak and Scully when we literally recruited Rory Atkins is pretty ridiculous.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

News Farewell Scully, KMarshall, Narkle, FEvans, Clurey

Similar threads

Ford Fairlane
News Quinton Narkle signs with Fremantle
15 16 17 18 19
Replies
466
Views
35K
Willsy10
Willsy10

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top