-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Fevola Trade Thread (Part 2)
- Thread starter WALL-e
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
there will be a few bidders and they will get good value.
of course, fans on BF wont recognize it as good value when it happens, but it will be. a late first rounder and a rising star nom will be a very good result for them
yeah, i dont reckon he will stay under any circumstances, i think its beyond reconciliation, and carlton will take what they can get, they will go for the highest bidder.
there will be a few bidders and they will get good value.
of course, fans on BF wont recognize it as good value when it happens, but it will be. a late first rounder and a rising star nom will be a very good result for them
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
My other question:
If a club is willing to contribute a large portion to paying off Fevola's contract....is that as good as a 1st round pick for the Blues?
If you free up 700K in the Blues Salary Cap spending, all of a sudden they can go for someone like Tarrant of O'Keefe quite hard.
So for example, Collingwood offer Pick 14 and payment of his contract. That has to be valuable to Carlton.....again provided they are 100% dedicated to trading him.
Don't know where Collingwood sits with salary cap, but a team like Brisbane, Sydney, West Coast or Kangaroos surely have this option if they want him with a lesser trade.
My other question:
If a club is willing to contribute a large portion to paying off Fevola's contract....is that as good as a 1st round pick for the Blues?
If you free up 700K in the Blues Salary Cap spending, all of a sudden they can go for someone like Tarrant of O'Keefe quite hard.
So for example, Collingwood offer Pick 14 and payment of his contract. That has to be valuable to Carlton.....again provided they are 100% dedicated to trading him.
Don't know where Collingwood sits with salary cap, but a team like Brisbane, Sydney, West Coast or Kangaroos surely have this option if they want him with a lesser trade.
Re: Pies in the Mix
The interest. And there's plenty of it.
Don't worry, don't mention the last 50 years, just focus on the last few years.
The interest. And there's plenty of it.
Don't worry, don't mention the last 50 years, just focus on the last few years.
astro_toby
Cancelled
- Sep 30, 2004
- 5,455
- 1,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
What or who do Carlton actually want???
I dare say they don't rate the draft as they were extremely happy to trade away pick 11 for McLean
If they want a key position full back - who?
If they want a full forward - who??
Struggling to understand exactly what the blues expect to get for him that fits their requirements
What or who do Carlton actually want???
I dare say they don't rate the draft as they were extremely happy to trade away pick 11 for McLean
If they want a key position full back - who?
If they want a full forward - who??
Struggling to understand exactly what the blues expect to get for him that fits their requirements
astro_toby
Cancelled
- Sep 30, 2004
- 5,455
- 1,339
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
agree
Cannot see them trading him to a arch rival either - especially one they are in direct competition for with a grand final over the next 3 years
The only way they would trade him to a similar level of squad is if they get players that can make the same impact on the side instantly as fev would
agree
Cannot see them trading him to a arch rival either - especially one they are in direct competition for with a grand final over the next 3 years
The only way they would trade him to a similar level of squad is if they get players that can make the same impact on the side instantly as fev would
Re: Pies in the Mix
If my club lost the best forward (only) in the team to an opposition club, and had to pay his salary still, I would be furious.
Seriously, regardless of what transpires, Carlton are the loser in this deal.
And what has 50 years got to do with it? You are only probably 18, do you care what went on in the 1960's?
There's always interest in a train wreck....
If my club lost the best forward (only) in the team to an opposition club, and had to pay his salary still, I would be furious.
Seriously, regardless of what transpires, Carlton are the loser in this deal.
And what has 50 years got to do with it? You are only probably 18, do you care what went on in the 1960's?
Whyte Line Feva
Debutant
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
There have been posts claiming "reliable sources" that Fev will be traded to collingwood which collingwood have agreed to, just the ducks guts of this trade to be sorted out.
This is definately the best lead up to trade week in recent years..
There have been posts claiming "reliable sources" that Fev will be traded to collingwood which collingwood have agreed to, just the ducks guts of this trade to be sorted out.
This is definately the best lead up to trade week in recent years..
Football Pope
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 24, 2009
- 8,345
- 4,151
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Australian International Sides
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
Yep....and of course his management (Alistair Lynch & co) would be wanting the best deal for their client.....Lions are likely to trade pick 12..
"THE BRISBANE Lions will take the best available player rather than target certain positions with their first pick at November's NAB AFL Draft.
Coach Michael Voss said the Lions would take a different philosophy to the draft than in previous seasons because their finals finish meant they were lower in the pecking order. Their first choice is not until pick No.12.
"We've got a range of players we're speaking to," he said. "If we don't have a type of player we've got to go down a different route.".......
http://www.lions.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/5085/newsid/85599/default.aspx
Yep....and of course his management (Alistair Lynch & co) would be wanting the best deal for their client.....Lions are likely to trade pick 12..
"THE BRISBANE Lions will take the best available player rather than target certain positions with their first pick at November's NAB AFL Draft.
Coach Michael Voss said the Lions would take a different philosophy to the draft than in previous seasons because their finals finish meant they were lower in the pecking order. Their first choice is not until pick No.12.
"We've got a range of players we're speaking to," he said. "If we don't have a type of player we've got to go down a different route.".......
http://www.lions.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/5085/newsid/85599/default.aspx
Orson Welles
Senior List
Fev to St Kilda - what is fair?
I reckon Luke Ball with pick 48 chucked in as a sweetener. Thoughts?
I reckon Luke Ball with pick 48 chucked in as a sweetener. Thoughts?
Whyte Line Feva
Debutant
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
why would you want to trade 29 year old fevola, for 31 year old bradshaw..?
When you have the currency to demand a first round pick and one possibly two YOUNG players you can groom into a 200 game servants of your club..?????
Bradshaw prone to hamstring injuries.. has one maybe two years left..??
Not smart..!
Fevola for Bradshaw & pick 12
why would you want to trade 29 year old fevola, for 31 year old bradshaw..?
When you have the currency to demand a first round pick and one possibly two YOUNG players you can groom into a 200 game servants of your club..?????
Bradshaw prone to hamstring injuries.. has one maybe two years left..??
Not smart..!
Re: Fevola Trade (merged thread)
chris dawes and pick 14 for fev
and straight away... pies are title contenders!
chris dawes and pick 14 for fev
and straight away... pies are title contenders!
Re: Pies in the Mix
How interesting. I've seen my team win six flags. I have no complaints.
Interesting to hear Neal Balme on the radio earlier, a man who can be respected. He feels that Fev is worth a bit and there'll be interest.
Carlton won't lose. We'll trade him (reasonably high, not his highest) and or we'll keep him.
You should focus on keeping Buddy out of trouble. Let your little head worry about that.
There's always interest in a train wreck....
If my club lost the best forward (only) in the team to an opposition club, and had to pay his salary still, I would be furious.
Seriously, regardless of what transpires, Carlton are the loser in this deal.
And what has 50 years got to do with it? You are only probably 18, do you care what went on in the 1960's?
How interesting. I've seen my team win six flags. I have no complaints.
Interesting to hear Neal Balme on the radio earlier, a man who can be respected. He feels that Fev is worth a bit and there'll be interest.
Carlton won't lose. We'll trade him (reasonably high, not his highest) and or we'll keep him.
You should focus on keeping Buddy out of trouble. Let your little head worry about that.
Fevola trade to brisbane
I read in the paper today that Brisbane are the new front runners for fev and are prepared to trade Bradshaw and a pick(2nd or 3rd round i presume). in my opinion if we did also get a second round pick i would attempt to trade it to west coast for Ben Mckinley....we may have to throw in Brad Fisher to sweeten the deal.
I also read in the Australian that Port are keen to trade for Shaun Hampson and may be prepared to pass on there number 9 pick they will recieve for Shaun Burgoyne in order to get him. If this were to occur i would have a crack at Taylor Walker with this pick.
leaving us with a forward structure looking something like
HF: Yarran Walker Garlett
F: Betts Bradshaw Mckinley
which i think looks a whole lot better than the fevola dominated one we play to now.
thoughts???
I read in the paper today that Brisbane are the new front runners for fev and are prepared to trade Bradshaw and a pick(2nd or 3rd round i presume). in my opinion if we did also get a second round pick i would attempt to trade it to west coast for Ben Mckinley....we may have to throw in Brad Fisher to sweeten the deal.
I also read in the Australian that Port are keen to trade for Shaun Hampson and may be prepared to pass on there number 9 pick they will recieve for Shaun Burgoyne in order to get him. If this were to occur i would have a crack at Taylor Walker with this pick.
leaving us with a forward structure looking something like
HF: Yarran Walker Garlett
F: Betts Bradshaw Mckinley
which i think looks a whole lot better than the fevola dominated one we play to now.
thoughts???
- Nov 28, 2006
- 28,855
- 11,890
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Re: Fevola trade to brisbane
Lol at thinking you can get Taylor Walker.
Lol at thinking you can get Taylor Walker.
Miguel Sanchez
(Unique injury) TBC
Re: Fevola trade to brisbane
Your second-rounder (or Brisbane's) won't get you McKinley. Throwing Fisher into the deal adds nothing, we don't want your castoffs.
Pick 9 won't get you Walker either.
Your second-rounder (or Brisbane's) won't get you McKinley. Throwing Fisher into the deal adds nothing, we don't want your castoffs.
Pick 9 won't get you Walker either.
Re: Fevola trade to brisbane
well what do u think mckinleys worth then?
certainly not a first rounder...he doesnt even make ur starting 18 half the time
well what do u think mckinleys worth then?
certainly not a first rounder...he doesnt even make ur starting 18 half the time
Re: Fevola trade to brisbane
wouldnt say his a hack...but i would much rather fevola...thats just the word not saying i agree with it
wouldnt say his a hack...but i would much rather fevola...thats just the word not saying i agree with it
sergei
Debutant
Re: Fevola trade to brisbane
There is absolutely zero chance of anyone getting Taylor Walker. Hypothetically if he were on the market, Rendell and Craig have already openly stated that they don't rate this years draft, so much much more than Pick 9 would be required. The only way an offer would be considered by the crows is if Gibbs were included, and we all know that won't happen.
