Geelong and Hawthorn record monumentally embarrassing 800 page shitfight thread.

[Danger_Cat]

Melt - so yep you got nothing again....

Just like the Cats in 2008

You been destroyed so badly in this thread you've had to change your avatar to try and score points.

Sad really.

 

[Nuggets73]

We were talking about AA and that is decided before finals. You knew that though

Mate ... I know at the Cattery put such an emphasis on AA / Individual honours ... Meh, doesn't even rate a mention at Glenferrie.
... we are all about the silverware handed out in the last Saturday of September ... AA's mean sweet **** all to us.

 

[Lethality]

You happy you took Mitch Thorp over Joel Selwood?

Smedts is just one of many Geelong clangers in the draft on which hawthorn have capitalized. It's why the hawks have maintained while Geelong have declined.

 

[Josh_hawk]

You been destroyed so badly in this thread you've had to change your avatar to try and score points.

Sad really.

Let me get this right yeah - an avatar on BF identifies you? And here I was thinking that was a username

And on top of this it also scores you points?? What sort of points?? The points of meth you've been smoking ?

 

[Josh_hawk]

Mate ... I know at the Cattery put such an emphasis on AA / Individual honours ... Meh, doesn't even rate a mention at Glenferrie.
... we are all about the silverware handed out in the last of September ... AA's mean sweet **** all to us.

Its a team game

 

[Lethality]

Hmm bringing out Dream Team stats are we? Can we start talking about Cyril then?

Duncans play does not transcend ordinary stats. He's a straight vanilla player.

 

[A Cut Above]

Hey question for Cats fans.

What is the deal with Mitch Duncan?

I thought he was kicked out of the leadership group and now I see he is back in?

Lack of viable options. The fact that they slotted mercenary turncoat Dangerfield straight in there demonstrates the club's leadership vacuum.

Then again, who the hell would want to be bossed around by Sookwood on and off the field?

 

[RedVest4]

Smedts is just one of many Geelong clangers in the draft on which hawthorn have capitalized. It's why the hawks have maintained while Geelong have declined.

Nah it's cause you tanked for consecutive seasons and got priority picks

 

[RedVest4]

Lack of viable options. The fact that they slotted mercenary turncoat Dangerfield straight in there demonstrates the club's leadership vacuum.

Then again, who the hell would want to be bossed around by Sookwood on and off the field?

Sookwood - not bad I'll pay that.

Your posts are getting into PackedLunch territory (this is a compliment). Enjoying your work

 

[RedVest4]

Duncans play does not transcend ordinary stats. He's a straight vanilla player.

Can we compare Duncan's and Cyril's dream team stats? I know you are a big stats man...

 

[Josh_hawk]

Wheres Danger Wagon gone?

Can i find him via his avatar??

 

[Nuggets73]

We were talking about Mitch Duncan vs Isaac Smith, but surprise surprise as soon as you realise your argument is futile you change the subject to something else. You're like a mini Podgey, remind me not to engage you in the future.

Mitch Duncan - 16 disposals and 0.5 goals average in finals. No dice. Isaac Smith goes at 19 and 1 in finals.

Lethal ... Don't dare bring up facts, you might back them in to a corner ... Then all the dribble posts start!

STP ... As your mate Nakia has proven numerous times ... You have great "home & away" team, but fold like a deck of cards come September ... Been going on for decades!

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Lethal ... Don't dare bring up facts, you might back them in to a corner ... Then all the dribble posts start!

STP ... As your mate Nakia has proven numerous times ... You have great "home & away" team, but fold like a deck of cards come September ... Been going on for decades!

Won 3 of their 4 most recent GFs. Sames as the Hawks, no?

 

[Josh_hawk]

Won 3 of their 4 most recent GFs. Sames as the Hawks, no?

 

[Lethality]

Nah it's cause you tanked for consecutive seasons and got priority picks

Geelong could've had hill, Shiels, breust, smith, among others. They ended up with a handful of deformed spuds.

 

[RedVest4]

Geelong could've had hill, Shiels, breust, smith, among others. They ended up with a handful of deformed spuds.

If only we tanked like you did...

 

[Nuggets73]

Won 3 of their 4 most recent GFs. Sames as the Hawks, no?

Ahhhh ... Where's 2008 in your equation??? ... I dearly love how yous feline's conveniently leave that one out!!
..... Hawthorn 4-5 (80%) ... Cats 3-4 (75%) .... we still have you covered!!!

ALSO - You might be able to beat up on the WORST performing grand final sides in VFL / AFL history ... But when the REAL heat comes (2008 GF, 2013 PF), we all know how your side "performs"

 

[Josh_hawk]

Ahhhh ... Where's 2008 in your equation??? ... I dearly love how yous feline's conveniently leave that one out!!
..... Hawthorn 4-5 (80%) ... Cats 3-4 (75%) .... we still have you covered!!!

ALSO - You might be able to beat up on the WORST performing grand final sides in VFL / AFL history ... But when the REAL heat comes (2008 GF, 2013 PF), we all know how your side "performs"

Followed in 2009 by GF heavy weights St Kilda and in 2011 by perennial GF losers in Collingwood....

 

[Geelong Dynasty]

Hawks claiming their Premierships against Freo, Sydney and WCE are somehow superior.

 

[db bennie]

geelong is only team that i rate worse than my own.

 

[Nuggets73]

Followed in 2009 by GF heavy weights St Kilda and in 2011 by perennial GF losers in Collingwood....

Hehehe ... They don't like when you bring up 2008 ... they get all salty about it, absolutely DESTROYED their pitiful "dynasty".
They are happy to spruik their wins against the Collywobbles, Dwarf Burners & Puffers ... But the 2008 GF never existed according to them.

... we've got these Feline's EASILY covered ... and they know it ... It's great watching them trying to justify their 1-Peat Dynasty!

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Ahhhh ... Where's 2008 in your equation??? ... I dearly love how yous feline's conveniently leave that one out!!
..... Hawthorn 4-5 (80%) ... Cats 3-4 (75%) .... we still have you covered!!!

Each side has won 3 of it's last 4, that's an even comparison. Makes your statement look a little bit silly, I understand you wouldn't like it.

ALSO - You might be able to beat up on the WORST performing grand final sides in VFL / AFL history ... But when the REAL heat comes (2008 GF, 2013 PF), we all know how your side "performs"

Geelong beat the best the comp had to offer, that's how GFs work.

 

[Nuggets73]

Hawks claiming their Premierships against Freo, Sydney and WCE are somehow superior.

That may be debatable ... But one thing I can assure you 100% ..... The 2008 Cup can't!!!

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Hehehe ... They don't like when you bring up 2008 ... they get all salty about it, absolutely DESTROYED their pitiful "dynasty".
They are happy to spruik their wins against the Collywobbles, Dwarf Burners & Puffers ... But the 2008 GF never existed according to them.

... we've got these Feline's EASILY covered ... and they know it ... It's great watching them trying to justify their 1-Peat Dynasty!

This must be one of those dribble posts you mentioned.

 

[Josh_hawk]

Hawks claiming their Premierships against Freo, Sydney and WCE are somehow superior.

13 > 9
members > non members