Goulburn Valley FL 2014

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bit of thinking time - Top 10 in order

This is taking into account at present time. not any (at his best) or ( in previous years) - Bullshit!

1 - Paul Newman
2 - Luke Morgan
3 - Dan Lovick
4 - Saad Saad
5 - Jason Eagle
6 - Tom Sheldon
7 - Brendan Hollow
8 - Paul Colbert
9 - Mark Blake
10 - Ash Watson

Open for debate!!

Also hearing the Nick Meese Northern Blues ruckman will sign with Seymour - Good Get.
 
What is with united mystery signing in the shepp news?? Sounds like he'll fit in well with all the other egos with legs at united if he doesn't want to be made public till the new year!!
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Sandra7 said:
1. Paul Newman
2. Rhys Archard
3. Saad Saad
4. Simon Seddon (at his best)
5. Paul Colbert
6. Dan Lovick
7. Brendan Hollow
8. Luke Morgan
9. Jason Eagle
10. Brendan Liddel
Click to expand...
Turn it up, how could you have seddon number 4 at his best , might as well have grant weeks no 1 coz at his best he would be. Plus think archard didn't have that good of a year. Sheldon could have been up there.
 
H
Space Jam said:
Also hearing Brendan Hollow was on 1100 at Tatura and moving to Rochy for 1500 and also to play with close mates.
Click to expand...
hollow could have played at tat with his close mates if he wanted to, the money would have had a lot to do with him and his two mates playing at rochy. Thou from what I hear he is worth the money!!! but as a wise man once told me... money talks and bullshit walks. ( no direct dig at hollow just a great saying)
 
There was a big fat dirty sign on fee at Tatura as well and quite possibly that wasn't available again in the 2nd year could have been where the Tigers got him. Word is Shepp have set themselves for 4 wins and are building towards a list that can do it. What's Seymour's prospects like Ringo?
 
mishmash said:
Can this be confirmed.......i hope he says he is "going to play with mates";)
Click to expand...
Rhys is a life member and has given great service to the club. He goes with our best wishes. Playing with mates or not. Hard to be a life member of any club especially when your boy can't stay at the one club for long ;)
 
Snowman12 said:
H
hollow could have played at tat with his close mates if he wanted to, the money would have had a lot to do with him and his two mates playing at rochy. Thou from what I hear he is worth the money!!! but as a wise man once told me... money talks and bullshit walks. ( no direct dig at hollow just a great saying)
Click to expand...
that is a great saying with today's players snowman
 
Bush Fly said:
There was a big fat dirty sign on fee at Tatura as well and quite possibly that wasn't available again in the 2nd year could have been where the Tigers got him. Word is Shepp have set themselves for 4 wins and are building towards a list that can do it. What's Seymour's prospects like Ringo?
Click to expand...
Not sure mate but Meese is a great pick up and will be the best tall in the league. If they have got one out of the Northern Blues then you'd expect Meese to have another one or two coming with him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ringo1 said:
Not sure mate but Meese is a great pick up and will be the best tall in the league. If they have got one out of the Northern Blues then you'd expect Meese to have another one or two coming with him.
Click to expand...
Better then Blake & Kirby? Big call ringo, I'd wait until he has a Morrison around his neck or a vic country jumper on his back till I say he's the best big man in the comp! ;)
 
ringo1 said:
Not sure mate but Meese is a great pick up and will be the best tall in the league. If they have got one out of the Northern Blues then you'd expect Meese to have another one or two coming with him.
Click to expand...
Will Sullivan, who tore Mark Blake a new A-Hole when Benalla played Mooroopna last year, and who will play the majority of the year for Benalla this year, would be a better tall than Meese.
 
Thirdmanup said:
Better then Blake & Kirby? Big call ringo, I'd wait until he has a Morrison around his neck or a vic country jumper on his back till I say he's the best big man in the comp! ;)
Click to expand...


I agree with Ringo. Saw him play a few games the last few years and acquitted himself against 2nd string AFL ruckman very well. Big body like Kirby but more agile. Doesnt jump as much as Blake but stronger at boundary throw ins. Strong, pretty good kick, can mark and pick up balls below knees. Seymour will be doing a rain dance as in the wet would be hard to beat. Very good pickup, no doubt.
 
Bush Fly said:
There was a big fat dirty sign on fee at Tatura as well and quite possibly that wasn't available again in the 2nd year could have been where the Tigers got him. Word is Shepp have set themselves for 4 wins and are building towards a list that can do it. What's Seymour's prospects like Ringo?
Click to expand...
No doubt he would have got a sign on fee as nearly all players do, but why would he expect to get another one when he is already contracted at the club the year before. Does not make sense! Any more big recruits coming into the gvfl? Has euroa or Shep bears announced any yet?
 
Doggies#8 said:
Will Sullivan, who tore Mark Blake a new A-Hole when Benalla played Mooroopna last year, and who will play the majority of the year for Benalla this year, would be a better tall than Meese.
Click to expand...
Not sure he tore Blake a new a-hole seeing as though Blake kicked a goal & got in the best yet there was no mention of Sullivan in the better players on the day! ;)
 
No doubt he would have got a sign on fee as nearly all players do, but why would he expect to get another one when he is already contracted at the club the year before. Does not make sense! Any more big recruits coming into the gvfl? Has euroa or Shep bears announced any yet?


That's true Snowman no need for Tatura too pay a sign on fee twice but I would say that moving to Rochester opened the door for another sign on.
 
With the minimal games I watched last year I would roll with the below. (In order)
1. Jason Morgan
2 Saad Saad
3 Paul Newman
4 Brendan Hollow
5 Paul Colbert
6 Dan Lovick
7 Tim Looby
8 Mark Blake
9 Shaun Huy
10 Paul Kirby
I would have liked to fit Luke Morgan in and also Matt Di Bella after his GF performance.
I have tried to take the emotion out of selection unlike a few others. ;)
 
Bush Fly said:
No doubt he would have got a sign on fee as nearly all players do, but why would he expect to get another one when he is already contracted at the club the year before. Does not make sense! Any more big recruits coming into the gvfl? Has euroa or Shep bears announced any yet?


That's true Snowman no need for Tatura too pay a sign on fee twice but I would say that moving to Rochester opened the door for another sign on.
Click to expand...

Think people need to look at the issue of Tatura cutting all there Melbourne based recruits, so not sure whether there was ever the option for hollow 2 continue playin at Tat in 2014
 
next year said:
With the minimal games I watched last year I would roll with the below. (In order)
1. Jason Morgan
2 Saad Saad
3 Paul Newman
4 Brendan Hollow
5 Paul Colbert
6 Dan Lovick
7 Tim Looby
8 Mark Blake
9 Shaun Huy
10 Paul Kirby
I would have liked to fit Luke Morgan in and also Matt Di Bella after his GF performance.
I have tried to take the emotion out of selection unlike a few others. ;)
Click to expand...
Judging by Shepp United whole finals series I would have Dibella in front of Huy
 
next year said:
With the minimal games I watched last year I would roll with the below. (In order)
1. Jason Morgan
2 Saad Saad
3 Paul Newman
4 Brendan Hollow
5 Paul Colbert
6 Dan Lovick
7 Tim Looby
8 Mark Blake
9 Shaun Huy
10 Paul Kirby
Click to expand...

Just judging from my own experiences
1.Jason Morgan
2.Paul Newman
3.Saad Saad
4.Ash Watson
5.Brandon Hollow
6.Jason Eagle
7.Paul Colbert
8.Simon Buckley
9.Dan Lovick
10.Grant Weeks
Unlucky to miss- Matt Pollock, Tom Sheldon, Paul Kirby, Mark Blake, Tim Looby, Daniel Lewis, Sam Martyn and Luke Morgan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

B
  • Sticky
Goulburn Valley FL 2025
2 3 4
Replies
85
Views
2K
Normo3
N
G
Goulburn Valley FL 2024
120 121 122 123 124
Replies
3K
Views
257K
Blues1977
B
Trent the flight Steward
Goulburn Valley FL 2023
124 125 126 127 128
Replies
3K
Views
300K
Long Run
L

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top