Was interested to see the stat pre-game that Hawthorn now receive more high free kicks than any other team. After years of Selwood vitriol, while Puopolo and Breust were plying their trade, it would be interesting to hear the perspective on it now. Dylan Moore is my current favourite. And apparently Ginnivan goes alright too. Oh the ironing.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Umpiring Hawthorn now the High FK Kings.
- Thread starter z547043
- Start date
- Tagged users None
AFL should’ve stamped it out when Selwood introduced it. Instead we were told have brave he is and that we needed to relearn how to tackle.
You reap what you sow.
You reap what you sow.
- Feb 26, 2013
- 575
- 1,050
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Delicious. Much prefer to be hated than pitied. We must be doing well.
As a fan, you can't be pleased with what the Hawthorn players dish up each week in terms of their staging? Surely not.
It's a disgrace to the sport.
Actually, I'm going to go a step further and say it's a disgrace to humanity.
They dont do it any more than any other team.
It's only pissing people off because they're young and arrogant
Not true.
You're being very one eyed of you don't recognise that Hawthorn have several players who chronically stage for Frees.
Most teams have 'that guy'. One dude who does it.
Hawthorn have about 8 of them.
It's shameful.
Oh, I've got no delusion about the contribution hawks players have towards the frees.
I also have no delusion about the state of the game. Hawks are the last team to contribute to it. I questioned why it took so long for us to join the party
Honestly, I find that incredibly sad.
I understand your perspective, but it saddens me that we've reached a point where fans want their players to behave like this.
Would I prefer they didn't, of corse.
I'm a realist though. There's half a dozen in every side.
The only reason people care, as I said, is the arrogance of the players doing it.
The media also contributed to it by using them as the only examples
No there's not.
Most sides have one, maybe two.
Hawthorn have about 8. It's like a legit strategy to stage.
It's awful.
Live in denial mate.
There's divers, duckers, floppers etc. All as bad as each other
As I said, o think you're being very one eyed if you can't see that Hawthorn are the standout culprit.
It's Hawthorn.....daylight.....the Bulldogs....daylight....a bit more daylight.....everyone else.
- Aug 17, 2006
- 23,678
- 22,259
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Separate (but related) to the staging, I don't think I've ever seen a team collectively carry on with appealing for free kicks like nuffies in the outer (in particular, free kicks that are absolutely not there), mimicking the umpires signals for holding the ball when an opponent is tackled instantly after taking possession, throwing their arms out whenever the ball crosses the boundary line after last making contact with an opposition player, like this Hawthorn outfit.
Iagree but what do you expect when the umpiring is so diabolical? How many frees did duckwood get? Far too many, Ginny was open season at Collingwood, and boy are the umps making that right now he’s a hawk.
When the system act rewards cheating to the point of deciding games what do you expect?
I’ve been told I’m too hard on umpires but for the money they make they should be so much better.
For what it’s worth Wayne Harmes was right in front of me as a tender teen at my first grand final live!
- Feb 12, 2017
- 18,784
- 49,750
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Current Hawthorn team is killing the tackle. Every one of them gets their head to turf whenever they can.
AFL introduced the Dangerous Tackle to try minimise head injuries, but instead we now have players driving their own heads into the ground to get a free
andrewroberts91
Senior List
- Apr 27, 2016
- 283
- 533
- AFL Club
- Carlton
They are pushing the boundaries of footy etiquette with their milking of free kicks. It’s almost similar to soccer players diving for penalties… they score a lot of goals from F50 free kicks…
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 22,118
- 50,833
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
Last nights display was more in keeping with WWE than AFL disgusting
- Jul 16, 2013
- 15,032
- 19,808
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Yes and a very large collection of them play for your team.
They got a couple of iffy ones last night but I tell ya what, as long as I've watched footy, I've found that in finals getting the ball first is so imperative. Umps aren't afraid to pay forwards who play the ball free kicks early on in finals.
Focus on what you can control. In quicker and harder and you give yourself a chance.
Focus on what you can control. In quicker and harder and you give yourself a chance.
Gaspard
Team Captain
- Apr 27, 2021
- 426
- 1,359
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Selwood was the first I knew of to actually create a technique for manufacturing free kicks. Most teams had a few players quickly adopt it, but less consistently. The AFL did nothing.
Ginnivan at Collingwood developed it further, and was the first to rub the opposition's nose in it. The AFL through its umpires had a period of open season on Ginnivan to try to beat it by forcing him from the game. This didn't work, and we had reverted to the do nothing approach by the end of Ginnivan's time at Collingwood.
The modified Selwood method is now pretty standard, with Hawthorn players the best exponents. The AFL has taken the view that high tackles can't be allowed (very true) and so the cheats (and that's what they are) have to be allowed to get away with it to protect every player's head, at least a little bit. The bang the head on the ground free kick is an added complication.
I really can't see a simple solution. I think we are stuck with the current unsatisfactory situation where the umpire has to judge whether the player set up the free kick or not. As I see it, they are erring on the side of the cheats at the moment, but that could change at any time.
A start would be to direct the commentators to stop calling it "drawing a free kick" and routinely call it staging and cheating, which is what it is. This is not an answer, but it at least faces the problem.
Ginnivan at Collingwood developed it further, and was the first to rub the opposition's nose in it. The AFL through its umpires had a period of open season on Ginnivan to try to beat it by forcing him from the game. This didn't work, and we had reverted to the do nothing approach by the end of Ginnivan's time at Collingwood.
The modified Selwood method is now pretty standard, with Hawthorn players the best exponents. The AFL has taken the view that high tackles can't be allowed (very true) and so the cheats (and that's what they are) have to be allowed to get away with it to protect every player's head, at least a little bit. The bang the head on the ground free kick is an added complication.
I really can't see a simple solution. I think we are stuck with the current unsatisfactory situation where the umpire has to judge whether the player set up the free kick or not. As I see it, they are erring on the side of the cheats at the moment, but that could change at any time.
A start would be to direct the commentators to stop calling it "drawing a free kick" and routinely call it staging and cheating, which is what it is. This is not an answer, but it at least faces the problem.
- Jul 16, 2013
- 15,032
- 19,808
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Start fining players.
Absolutely agree!!
This is exactly what needs to happen. For the good of the sport, commentators and fans alike (especially supporters of the players that do it) need to openly ridicule and condemn players cheating for Frees.
